Tactile Location Perception Encoded by Gamma-Band Power
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe paper is well written it concerns tacticle location perception by gamma band power during EEG. Included are 6 figures and 1 table no major grammer/spelling errors detected.
The study is about EEG, specifically - Tactile Location Perception Encoded by Gamma-Band Power
- aim to characterize spatial location perception of the upper body.
- Characterization of EEG location perception
- I am not familiar with the related literature, but I think that it adds its conclusions (that fundamental mechanisms of the tactile system, as well as applications in brain-computer 23 interface that rely on tactile stimulation.
- potentially additional human subjects (other species/ages).
major issues - provide ethics statement. Include gender/age for the human samples. Potentially apply additional statistical tests on the data (e.g. such as ANOVA with FDR) minor issues - none found.
Author Response
We have addressed all the questions, including adding the gender information and changing the two-way ANOVA to a three-way ANOVA to examine gender effect, see attached file for details.
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors（1）The details of signal processing and classification are not enough. Is there a math model or math equation method to show?
（2）What is the physical meaning of CI? The p and n in CI equation，what's meaning?
（3）What is your conclusion and future research plan? It should be added a new section to illustrate.
（4）The nearest new references are less.
Author Response
Thanks for the useful suggestions. We have addressed all the questions, see the attached file for details.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
