3.1. SSF with A. niger
Yarrowia lipolytica W29 has been previously selected for enzyme production in SSF using by-products from vegetable oil industries [
9]. After substrate mixture and cultivation time optimization, lipase activity of (102 ± 17) U/g was attained after 2 days of SSF with a 50% (
w/w, dry basis) mixture of OC and SC. While SSF resulted in 29% reduction in the lipid content of this substrate mixture, significant changes in fiber percentage were not registered. This outcome is due to
Yarrowia species’ inability to produce lignocellulosic enzymes; thus, complex polysaccharides, such as cellulose and hemicellulose, are not hydrolyzed during SSF.
Likewise, mixed cultures of microorganisms that do not secrete these enzymes with filamentous fungi producers of lignocellulolytic enzymes could be a suitable strategy to increase substrate utilization and microbial growth, resulting in high biocompound yields. In the present work, two co-culture strategies with
Y. lipolytica W29 and
A. niger CECT 2915 were studied and the influence of co-culture on enzyme production was evaluated. Nevertheless, before the co-culture experiments, SSF with
A. niger CECT 2915 was performed to assess enzyme production on a substrate composed of 50% (
w/w, dry basis) OC and SC. SSF was followed up to 4 days and the results are present in
Table 1.
Aspergillus niger is widely used in SSF for lignocellulosic enzyme production [
4,
22,
27,
28]. The utilization of lignocellulosic materials as solid substrates in SSF can induce the production of lignocellulosic enzymes, which results in the conversion of the lignocellulosic matrix into single sugars that are easily metabolized by microorganisms [
1,
27]. Furthermore, some studies already reported the use of OC [
4,
22] and SC [
27] as solid substrates for SSF processes with
A. niger, showing the potential of the substrate mixture used in the present work for fungal growth. Moreover, a 9-fold increase in lignocellulosic enzymes was observed from the second to the fourth day of SSF, highlighting xylanase activity that reached 290 U/g after 4 days of SSF (
Table 1). The fact that OC, which corresponds to 50% of the substrate mixture, have higher content in hemicellulose in comparison to cellulose [
4] could induce the production of xylanase. Lipase activity increased by 2-fold from the second to the fourth day of SSF; however, this enzyme had the lowest activity detected in these experiments. While the residual oil present in OC could induce lipase production by the filamentous fungi, SSF with
Aspergillus species for lipase production are often carried for a minimum of 7 days [
29,
30], which explains the low lipase production observed. Moreover, the low protein content in OC may have a negative effect on protease activity because the production of this enzyme by
A. niger is induced in protein-rich substrates [
31]. Regardless of the high activities of the enzymes cellulase and xylanase, the concentration of reducing sugars, which was around 58 mg/g in the substrate mixture prior to
A. niger inoculation, decline throughout SSF. This result revealed that the sugar consumption rate by
A. niger was higher than the sugar release by the action of the lignocellulosic enzymes; thus, an increase in sugar concentration was not detected. Similarly, before
Y. lipolytica inoculation in pre-fermented okara with the fungi
Rhizopus oligosporus for 24 h, a decrease in sugar concentration was also observed [
32]. In contrast, an increase in reducing sugars after 72 h of SSF with
Mucor flavus was reported using a mixture of okara and buckwheat husk prior to substrate sterilization and
Y. lipolytica inoculation [
8]. Likewise, the release and consumption of reducing sugars by filamentous fungi in SSF is likely dependent on fungal species and the by-products selected as solid substrates. In spite of the reducing sugar consumption by
A. niger, the fungal growth in the substrate mixture could release other biomolecules, such as proteins [
4], that could improve microbial growth.
3.2. Simultaneous or Sequential SSF with Y. lipolytica and A. niger
Co-culture or sequential SSF with
Y. lipolytica and filamentous fungi species have been used for substrate biotransformation and biocompounds production [
8,
32]. In the present work, two strategies were employed to evaluate the effectiveness of co-culture for lipase production by
Y. lipolytica: a sequential SSF, where
A. niger CECT 2915 was first inoculated in the substrate mixture and, after two days of SSF, yeast inoculation was performed, and a simultaneous co-culture with the inoculation of the two microorganisms at the same time (
Table 2).
In the sequential SSF, (8 ± 2) U/g of lipase activity was attained in the second day after yeast inoculation (
Table 2) and, despite the 2-fold increase in this enzyme activity in comparison to
A. niger monoculture (
Table 1), the production in these conditions was very low. Inoculation of the filamentous fungus two days before
Y. lipolytica decreased free reducing sugars, as shown above, in spite of the carbohydrases production that contribute to assimilable sugars release. However, sugar concentration in the medium is the balance of the sugars released and sugar consumed by microorganisms. The competition for substrate and other nutrients between the yeast cells and the fungus may limit yeast growth and lipase production because the most active phase of fungal growth seems to be from the second to fourth day of fermentation (
Table 1). For this reason, a simultaneous co-culture was performed and, in these conditions, lipase activity reached (49 ± 7) U/g in the second day of SSF, corresponding to a 6-fold increase compared to the two-phase strategy (
Table 2). It appears that lipase secretion observed in these experiments is attributed to
Y. lipolytica because lipase detected after SSF with a monoculture of
A. niger CECT 2915 for two days was 96% lower (
Table 1). Moreover, protease activity in the simultaneous co-culture reached (12 ± 2) U/g after two days of SSF and, in the sequential SSF, an increase of 33% in the activity of this enzyme was registered, which could have also contributed to the lower lipase activity detected in these conditions because lipase can be degraded by proteolysis. In the present study, despite the 6-fold improvement on lipase activity comparing the sequential SSF and the simultaneous co-culture, a standard assay with a monoculture of
Y. lipolytica W29 was performed and higher lipase activity was achieved, reaching (99 ± 1) U/g, which is similar to the results previously reported with this substrate mixture [
9]. These results showed that the mixed cultures of
A. niger CECT 2915 and
Y. lipolytica W29 in the co-culture strategies tested in this work did not favour lipase production; thus, application of other pretreatments in the substrate mixture before SSF should be considered.
3.3. Enzymatic Hydrolysis Pretreatment of the Optimum Substrate for Lipase Production
Because mixed cultures with
Y. lipolytica W29 and
A. niger CECT 2915 did not improve lipase production by the oleaginous yeast, a different strategy was used to degrade the cellulose and hemicellulose fractions of the substrate mixture and increase sugar availability prior to
Y. lipolytica inoculation. For this purpose, enzymatic hydrolysis of the substrate mixture was performed using a crude enzymatic extract produced by
A. niger CECT 2915, as described above; a commercial cellulase was used as a control. The influence of cellulase concentration and incubation time was tested and the time course of reducing sugar release after enzymatic hydrolysis are represented in
Figure 2.
Overall, an increase in reducing sugar concentration was obtained after only 6 h of enzymatic hydrolysis in all the conditions tested (
Figure 2). However, higher sugar release was observed when the enzymatic crude extract from
A. niger was used in comparison with the commercial cellulase. This commercial enzyme only hydrolyses endo-1,4-β-D-glycosidic linkages in cellulose and cellooligosaccharides. In contrast, the crude enzymatic extract used in this work has different types of cellulases and other hydrolytic enzymes, resulting in increased reducing sugar release. In fact, besides the endoglucanases (carboxymethyl cellulases) measured herein, β-glucosidase and xylanase were also found in extracts of the fermented mixture [
21]. Regarding the results using
A. niger crude extract, sugars release was mainly observed in the first 12 h of the hydrolysis process. Indeed, a 46% increase in reducing sugars concentration was observed when the enzymatic extract amount was adjusted to 100 U/g and 150 U/g of cellulase in comparison to the lowest concentration, corresponding to a 3-fold increase of reducing sugars in the substrate mixture after 12 h of treatment. A crude enzymatic extract produced by
A. niger was also successfully used for enzymatic hydrolysis with high solid loadings of brewer’s spent grain and grape pomace, showing the potential of using crude extract in hydrolysis processes before SSF [
3]. Because increasing cellulase concentration to 150 U/g or extending enzymatic hydrolysis above 12 h did not increase sugars release, the crude enzymatic extract with a cellulase concentration of 100 U/g and 12 h of incubation time were selected for further experiments. After 12 h of incubation with the crude enzymatic extract, fiber content decreased by 20% in the substrate mixture (
Table 3), showing that the enzymatic extract obtained by SSF with
A. niger effectively degraded the lignocellulosic matrix of the mixture of OC and SC. This outcome is in accordance with reports showing a reduction in fiber content after SSF with
Aspergillus species [
27,
33]. Additionally, enzymatic hydrolysis resulted in a 42% increase of glucose in the extracts, and a 3-fold increase in xylose concentration compared to the substrate mixture without pretreatment (
Table 3). The differences in the release of these sugars could be related to the production of high levels of xylanase by
A. niger in the ternary mixture of oil cakes used for the enzymatic crude extract production [
21]. Hemicellulose degradation by xylanases could also justify the significant decrease (
p < 0.05) in NDF (
Table 3); the decrease of ADF from the untreated to the hydrolyzed substrate mixture is statistically significant, with a confidence level of 94%.
In the present study, enzymatic hydrolysis was successfully performed with a high solid concentration of 25% (
w/w, wet basis), resulting in a 3-fold increase in free reducing sugars in the substrate mixture. Water is essential in hydrolysis reactions, and increasing the solid loading in enzymatic hydrolysis of the lignocellulosic biomass may have a negative impact on the conversion of the lignocellulosic matrix into fermentable sugars [
34]. However, the implementation of enzymatic hydrolysis processes with high solid loadings have additional advantages, such as low water usage and reduction in the production costs [
34]. The fact that the moisture content used in enzymatic hydrolysis was similar to that used in SSF with
Y. lipolytica W29 allowed for substrate utilization with minimal processing steps.
3.4. SSF of Enzymatically Pretreated Substrate for Lipase Production by Y. lipolytica
A pre-hydrolyzed mixture of OC and SC was fermented with
Y. lipolytica W29 for two days, and the lipase activity registered in these conditions was very low (
Table 4).
While distilled water was used to adjust the moisture content in the substrate mixture of OC and SC in SSF for lipase production in most of the experiments in the above sections, in these experiments, citrate buffer with a pH of 4.8 was used to guarantee suitable conditions for enzymatic hydrolysis before SSF. Thus, to examine if the low lipase activity observed after enzymatic hydrolysis was related to the changes in the substrate mixture pH, SSF was performed in the mixture of OC and SC without enzymatic hydrolysis using water and citrate buffer (pH 4.8) to adjust the moisture content. It appears that the use of citrate buffer had some influence on lipase secretion because a 29% reduction on lipase activity was observed when the buffer was used instead of water in SSF with the untreated substrate mixture. However, an 11-fold decrease in lipase activity was attained when enzymatic hydrolysis was performed before SSF, compared to the untreated mixture (moistened with citrate buffer), revealing that low pH in these fermentations may not be the only reason for low lipase detection. Another aspect considered in these experiments was the effect of enzymatic hydrolysis on the cell concentration obtained after SSF. Although a similar cellular growth was observed in SSF without enzymatic pretreatment, an almost 3-fold increase in yeast cell concentration was observed when the substrate mixture was pretreated with the fungal enzymatic extract. This outcome could be related to the increased reducing sugars available in the substrate mixture, which improved cellular growth in detriment of biocompound production. To further understand the effect of enzymatic hydrolysis on lipase production, kinetics of SSF was performed for up to 5 days, and the results are represented in
Figure 3.
The maximum cellular concentration was attained at the second day of fermentation, and cellular growth stabilised until the end of the experiments (
Figure 3A) at higher values than the ones reported in previous work on SSF without pretreatment [
9]. Likewise, the 3-fold increase in reducing sugars concentration in the substrate mixture after enzymatic hydrolysis improved
Y. lipolytica growth. The sugar availability in the substrate mixture allowed
Y. lipolytica to metabolize around 137 mg/g of reducing sugars. After the third day of SSF, a residual value of reducing sugars was maintained until the end of the experiments, possibly corresponding to monomers that were released during enzymatic hydrolysis, that
Y. lipolytica is unable to efficiently assimilate. Concerning lipase activity, a 7-fold increase was observed between the second and third days of SSF (
Figure 3B). After reaching its maximum on the third day of cultivation, lipase activity decreased and, by the end of SSF, 34% of this enzyme activity was still detected. In these conditions, a decrease in lipase productivity (U/g/day) was observed because the maximum activity was attained later in the SSF process. In particular, 39 U/g/day was obtained in the two-day standard assay with the untreated substrate mixture (
Table 4) and a 69% reduction in lipase productivity was observed after substrate hydrolysis. The delayed peak could be explained by the higher concentration of reducing sugars in the SSF medium because lipase secretion into the extracellular medium occurs when the concentration of carbon sources are low [
12]. In experiments with
Y. lipolytica CB7504 cultivated in a medium containing both glucose and olive oil, lipase production peak was delayed and lower values were obtained compared to medium only supplemented with olive oil [
35]. While
LIP2, the gene coding for the most produced extracellular lipase in
Y. lipolytica, is induced in the presence of oily substrates, it appears that the presence of glucose in the culture medium has a repressive effect on this gene expression [
36]. In fact, it has been observed that hexokinase, which is responsible for the phosphorylation of hexoses in the early stage of the glycolytic pathway, is involved in the repression of
LIP2 in
Y. lipolytica [
37]. Even though glucose was present in the substrate mixture before enzymatic hydrolysis, the 42% increase in glucose concentration could be sufficient to alter
Y. lipolytica metabolism. Moreover, the increase of other reducing sugars’ concentrations besides glucose could also play a role in the decreased lipase production observed in this work. Previously, pH values increased until the end of cultivation, with the untreated substrate mixture reaching values above 8 [
9]; however, the pH in the present study was kept below 7 until the end of SSF. Furthermore, an increase in medium pH is often related to protease release, leading to lipase degradation by proteolysis both in solid state and submerged fermentations [
14,
38]. Despite the lower pH observed in this work, protease activity was also detected in the aqueous extract obtained after SSF (
Figure 3B).
Yarrowia lipolytica secretes two enzymes with proteolytic activity, and their secretion is influenced by the medium pH. While the most secreted protease is induced by alkaline pH, an acid protease is also secreted by the oleaginous yeast [
39]. Thus, the lower pH after enzymatic hydrolysis still induced protease production by
Y. lipolytica, and the activity of this enzyme increased until the end of SSF, possibly resulting in lipase degradation.
Regardless of the lower lipase activity detected in the pretreated mixture of 50% (w/w, dry basis) OC and SC, the results obtained in this study showed the great potential of employing crude extracts produced by filamentous fungi in enzymatic hydrolysis processes without any enzyme purification steps. Furthermore, these conditions favoured yeast biomass production, which could result in oil cake biotransformation and improvement of the nutritional value of these materials enriched with microbial protein. Moreover, the fact that the hydrolysis was successfully performed in a high solid loading system allowed the obtention of a solid substrate mixture with increased free and easily assimilable sugarss through an economic and eco-friendly process.
3.5. SSF and Semi-Solid Fermentation after Physical Pretreatments for Lipase Production by Y. lipolytica
Physical pretreatments are often applied prior to enzymatic hydrolysis, resulting in higher yields of fermentable sugars that can be subsequently used in biotechnological processes for value-added compound production [
20]. However, these pretreatments can also be beneficial before SSF because the changes in the solid substrate can increase the access of microorganisms to soluble compounds and microbial enzymes to their substrates. Thus, in the present study, the substrate mixture of OC and SC with a solid loading of 25% (
w/w) was placed in an ultrasonic bath for 15 min or was submitted to microwave irradiation for 2 min before SSF for 2 days with
Y. lipolytica W29 (
Table 5).
Microwave and ultrasound pretreatments resulted in 10% and 16% increases in reducing sugars content in the substrate mixture, respectively, compared to the untreated mixture (
Table 5), although the values are not statistically different. These values are significant lower compared to the sugar release observed after enzymatic hydrolysis (
Figure 2) because the severity of the pretreatments was not enough to hydrolyse the polysaccharides from the lignocellulosic matrix. Ultrasound pretreatment had no effect on cellular growth; however, when the substrate mixture was irradiated with microwaves, a 44% increase in this parameter was obtained (
Table 5). Moreover, the pretreatments used in this work improved lipase production, highlighting the results obtained with microwave pretreatment, which resulted in a 1.2-fold enzyme activity increase in comparison to SSF with the untreated substrate mixture. In a previous study, a 3 min microwave pretreatment of rice hulls and wheat bran before SSF did not significantly alter cellulase production by
Trichoderma sp. [
5]. Additionally, the authors reported that improved enzyme production was only achieved when microwave was combined with an alkaline pretreatment. In the present work, microwave pretreatment was enough to increase lipase production by
Y. lipolytica W29, resulting in less downstream processing of the solid materials after pretreatment and before SSF. Regarding protease activity, the pretreatments had no effect on this enzyme activity because the differences observed are not statistically significant.
Besides pretreatment with an ultrasonic bath, the substrate mixture at a solid loading of 10% (
w/w) in water suspension was also pretreated with an ultrasonic probe. This semi-solid mixture was composed of 10.8 g/L of reducing sugars, and the pretreatment led to a slight increase in sugar content (12.2 g/L) after 6 min; extending pretreatment time to 10 and 15 min did not improve reducing sugars release. Although the sonication did not result in significant changes in the reducing sugars concentration in the mixture of OC and SC, it is possible that this pretreatment improved the accessibility of
Y. lipolytica W29 to other biomolecules present in the substrate. Thus, ultrasound pretreatment for 6 min was applied to the substrate mixture before yeast inoculation. As previously stated, to perform these experiments, the amount of water added to the substrate was higher than in the experiments of SSF, resulting in a semi-solid mixture of OC and SC. Moreover, to minimize the complexity of the bioprocess, which would require the drying of the pretreated substrate followed by moisture adjustment before SSF, the semi-solid mixture was directly inoculated with
Y. lipolytica W29 after a sterilization step and fermentations were carried for 30 h (
Figure 4). A semi-solid fermentation with an untreated semi-solid mixture was performed as a control.
The majority of reducingsugars consumption occurred in the first 15 h of cultivation in both untreated and pretreated mixtures (
Figure 4). Similar to what occurred in SSF (
Figure 3B), a residual value of reducing sugars was detected until the end of the fermentation process. Moreover, ultrasound pretreatment did not result in changes in yeast cell growth with respect to the untreated semi-solid mixture. In particular, after 30 h of cultivation, yeast cells had already entered a stationary phase and a final cell biomass of around 20 g/L was obtained in both conditions tested. In SSF after ultrasonic pretreatment (
Table 5), the 18 mg/g of yeast biomass obtained after two days of SSF corresponds to 2.3 g/L; thus, an almost 10-fold increase in cell concentration was achieved in semi-solid fermentation. In these experiments, oxygen transfer was favoured by medium agitation, which could explain the high yeast biomass production in semi-solid fermentation in comparison to SSF. Moreover, the high amount of water in these conditions and the agitation of the slurry medium could increase the solubilization of the substrate mixture, also increasing bioavailability of compounds that could be metabolized by the yeast. Besides reducing sugars and lipids,
Y. lipolytica may also metabolize phenolic compounds present in the oil cakes used in these experiments [
9]. In fact, this yeast has been used to reduce the content of phenolic compounds in olive mill wastewater [
40,
41]. Additionally, other compounds such as alcohols and organic acids could be present in this substrate mixture, contributing to
Y. lipolytica growth. Lipase activity quantification was performed and, regardless of the pretreatment used in the semi-solid mixture, lipase secretion occurred mostly at the end of the experiments (
Figure 4). These results are in agreement with a previous study, which showed that lipase secretion to the culture medium by
Y. lipolytica begins when carbon sources become limited [
42]. In the control condition, lipase activity increased until the end of semi-solid fermentation, reaching its maximum value of 233 U/L. Conversely, ultrasound pretreatment improved lipase activity, which peaked after 27 h of fermentation and was 2-fold higher than the maximum lipase activity detected in the control assay. Thus, it is possible that the application of ultrasounds in the mixture of OC and SC could increase the bioavailability of lipids in the substrate mixture and the fact that, in these experiments, the semi-solid mixture was constantly agitated improved the access of
Y. lipolytica to these lipase inducers. Protease activity was quantified by the end of these experiments and 1576 U/L were obtained with the untreated semi-solid mixture. Furthermore, protease activity in the experiments with the pretreated semi-solid mixture was 21% lower, which could also contribute to the higher lipase activity detected in these conditions.
After semi-solid fermentation, the content of the flasks was dried without yeast biomass separation and the remaining solid was characterized to understand the influence of
Y. lipolytica growth in substrate composition (
Table 6).
While yeast growth had no impact on crude protein content, a 50% reduction in lipid content was observed after 30 h of incubation with respect to the mixture without inoculation (0 h) (
Table 6). Lipase production by
Y. lipolytica and the ability of these enzymes to hydrolyse triacylglycerol [
6] can explain the decrease in lipid content in the fermented solid. Using the same substrate mixture, SSF with
Y. lipolytica W29 for two days resulted in a 29% decrease in lipid content [
9], showing that in semi-solid fermentation, yeast cells were able to reduce the lipidic content of the substrate mixture more effectively in a shorter period of time. Moreover, SSF with
Y. lipolytica NBRC-10073 resulted in a lipid content reduction in fish by-products, demonstrating the potential of this microorganism for by-product biotransformation [
43]. Moreover, the profile of long-chain fatty acids (LCFAs) were also analyzed after semi-solid fermentation (
Table 6). The substrate mixture composed of OC and SC used in this work is characterized by a high oleic acid (C18:1) content, a fatty acid present in high percentages in the by-products obtained after olive oil extraction [
44]. Moreover, this value is followed by linoleic acid (C18:2), showing that more than 80% of the fatty acids in this substrate mixture are unsaturated fatty acids. Semi-solid fermentation resulted in a 3.3- and 3.5-fold increase in palmitoleic acid (C16:1) in the substrate mixture treated with ultrasounds and in the untreated mixture, respectively. Moreover, yeast cultivation for 30 h also resulted in around a 16.5% increase in linoleic acid. Although the contents of heptadecanoic acid (C17:1), stearic acid (C18:0) and oleic acid were unaffected by semi-solid fermentation, this bioprocess resulted in a 14% reduction in palmitic acid (C16:0) percentage.
Fermentations can be used to improve the nutritional properties of agro-industrial by-products before their incorporation into animal feed formulations [
27]. Moreover, oilseeds are often used as fat supplementation in some feedstocks to increase the intake of some unsaturated fatty acids, such as oleic and linoleic acids [
45]. In the present study, a slight increase in the percentage of unsaturated fatty acids was observed regardless of the utilization of ultrasonic pretreatment. Furthermore, because the content of saturated fatty acids suffered a 10% reduction, the fermented substrate presented a higher ratio of unsaturated to saturated fatty acids, resulting in a nutritional enhancement of the mixture of oil cakes and showing its potential application in animal feed formulations.