Efficacy Analysis of In Situ Synthesis of Nanogold via Copper/Iodonium/Amine/Gold System under a Visible Light
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
See the attachement.
Comments for author File: 
Comments.pdf
Author Response
see file
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
The article: “Efficacy analysis of in situ synthesis of nanogold via copper/iodonium/amine/gold system under a visible light” by Jui-Teng Lin et al. describes the kinetics and the general features of a photopolymerization system (named as G1/Iodonium/TEA/Gold chloride) under visible light. This study is based on a previous article by Tara et al. (Ref. 21). Although the subject of the article is interesting and valuable, the presentation of this study is not at a good level. The reader is confused with the structure of the manuscript and cannot easily follow the authors’ statements. Unfortunately, in this form is not suitable for publication in Polymers. A serious revision is needed before re-submitting it. Some comments are addressed below.
- Line 31-34: The authors repeat the same sentence as above. In general, the introduction part needs serious revision and editing.
- In Scheme 1, what are r1, r2, etc.. refer to?
- Line 87-90: The sentence has to be revised, the reader cannot follow the authors.
- Line 108-111: Where is Scheme 6 refer to?
- The Methods and modeling systems seems more like results and discussion section. The authors do not describe the methods they used clearly.
- Conclusions and Abstract are almost identical. The authors should revise them.
Author Response
see file
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
The authors have answered to the comments provided by the reviewer and revised their manuscript.
Now it can be accepted for publication to Polymers.
