Effect of Wet Expansion Behavior on Polyimide Membrane Diffractive Lens

Abstract

Optical polyimide (PI) membrane is a potential substrate to fabricate a diffractive primary lens in large aperture space-borne telescope. In this paper, we investigated the wet expansion behavior of PI via a strain gauge method and measured the coefficient of wet expansion (CWE) of PI membrane supported by different fixtures. The CWE of silica-fixed, ring-fixed, and free state PI membrane were near zero, 5 ppm/%, and 10 ppm/% respectively. It is found that Fresnel zone lens (FZL), based on PI membrane with lower CWE, achieve a better imaging quality with smaller wave-front errors. The underlying mechanisms and methods to improve imaging quality of ring-fixed FZL are discussed. This work provides direction in fabricating a flexible membrane diffractive lens with applicable imaging quality.

1. Introduction

Polyimide (PI), with unique properties such as good space environmental adaptability, excellent chemical stability, and mechanical properties, has been widely applied in aerospace engineering, micro manufacturing, display panels industry, and so on [1]. A Fresnel zone lens (FZL) is fabricated by photolithography and subsequent etching process to form concentric rings in an optical substrate, and act as a diffractive lens. A traditional silica substrate-based FZLs are commercialized products, and different fabrication methods are available according to different technical specifications [2]. Large aperture FZLs, based on thin polyimide membranes, are promising primary lenses, used to build space-based telescopes, due to their light-weight and relaxed surface figure tolerance [3,4,5,6,7,8]. Wave-front error is the key parameter in evaluating the imaging quality of FZLs. The wave-front error of PI membrane, FZL, is theoretically influenced by substrate wave-front error and fabrication errors [9,10,11,12]. The key fabrication error for PI membrane FZL is structure position error (Δr_m), as shown in Figure 1 [13,14,15]. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) fabricated a PI membrane FZL and found that PI membrane expands and contracts substantially as humidity level of testing environment changes [16].

This behavior can distort the diffraction pattern, if the temperature and humidity change from laboratory to field, especially when the field is in space.

Previous studies of PI materials mostly focus on achieving good thermal and mechanical properties, tailoring coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) and Young’s modulus [17,18]. Published papers on PI’s wet expansion behavior mainly look at the water absorbing mechanism and its electric application [19,20,21]. Blumentritt explored PI membrane’s anisotropy and dimensional stability and found that coefficient of wet expansion (CWE) varies in different directions, and anisotropy behavior was correlated to molecular orientation [22]. However, a traditional method that measures CWE of PI membrane, through an optical microscope, lacks precision and does not measure real-time data. Studies on the wave-front error of PI membrane FZL are rarely published. Further research needs to assess the way wet expansion behavior affects imaging quality of PI membrane FZL.

In this paper, we introduced a new method, based on strain gauges to online monitor wet expansion behavior of PI membranes, supported by different fixtures. We measured CWE of PI membrane, supported by ring-shape fixture under different stress. Then we fabricated two PI membrane FZLs, supported by a silica fixture and ring fixture, and measured corresponding wave-front errors. Finally, we discussed the influence of CWE on wave-front error and put forward possible approaches to eliminating the effect of wet expansion behavior on wave-front error.

2. Results and Discussion

Optical grade PI membranes were synthesized by 1,2,4,5-Benzenetetracarboxylic anhydride (PMDA) and 2,2’-Bistrifluoromethylbenzidine, and formed uniform membranes with 25 μm thickness and Φ80 mm aperture by multiple spin cast and imidization. We prepared three PI membrane samples, where the first was stretched and supported between two Φ80 mm aluminum ring-shape fixtures, as shown in Figure 2a below; the second was supported by silica substrate via vacuum contact, as shown in Figure 2b below and; the third was a free-state PI, without fixture. We also prepared a pure silica substrate as the fourth sample.

Commercial strain gauges BA120-3AA(11)-Q400 (Jingce Dianqi Co., Ltd., Hanzhong, China), with resistance value 119.9 ± 0.1 Ω and sensitivity coefficient 2.06% ± 1%, were glued on the sample surface, shown in Figure 2c. Strain data was recorded and processed by DH3820 system with 2 Hz sampling frequency. Then we placed all four samples in 5% tetra methyl ammonium hydroxide (TMAH) solution at room temperature for more than 5 h to simulate development process.

The results are shown in the Figure 3 below, in which the red line refers to sample in free state, the green line refers to sample supported by ring-shape fixture, the purple line stands for sample supported by silica substrate, and the blue line represents pure silica substrate. Notably, silica-fixed PI achieves near zero CWE similar to silica substrate. The reason is that PI membrane and silica substrate formed strong adhesive force through vacuum contact. We also found that CWE of ring-fixed PI is smaller than that of free state PI.

Accurate CWEs of PI membrane, supported by ring-fixture with different initial stress, were measured through humidity program, as shown in Figure 4 below. Humidity was controlled by HUT720P environmental test chamber (Hardy Technology Co., Ltd., Chongqing, China), with nominal 10%–98% range.

CWE is calculated by Equation (1) in which ΔL/L stands for strain and ΔH stands for humidity change:

$$\mathrm{CWE}=\frac{\Delta L}{L \times \Delta H}$$

(1)

The results are shown in the Figure 5 below, where the red line refers to the sample in free-state (initial stress = 0 MPa), the blue line refers to sample under 5 MPa initial stress, and the black line refers to sample under 10 MPa initial stress.

It was found that once humidity increases, the ring-fixed PI membrane expands less than 50% of free state PI membrane, and the corresponding CWE is around 5 ppm/%. We also notice that humidity from 30% to 60% initial stress of ring-fixed PI membrane does not influence CWE and humidity from 60% to 90% larger initial stress corresponds to lower CWE. The possible reason is that, when humidity increases from 60% to 90%, the stress of PI membrane continues to decrease, and at some point, the sample under 5 MPa initial stress becomes free state, while the sample under 10 MPa initial stress still keeps stretched. The underlying mechanism is that, once PI has expansion trend upon absorbing water, the ring relaxes a little thus exerting lower stress to PI leading to a shrinkage trend. The final impact is that the real expansion is lower than the free-state PI, as illustrated in Figure 6 below. The black line refers to expansion trend and its slope equals CWE of free state PI membrane. The red line refers to the shrinkage trend, and its slope is the decreased strain divided by increased humidity.

Because the membrane and ring-fixture are under static equilibrium, Equation (2) is established; on the left side m₀ is original size of PI membrane under humidity H₁, m₁ is stretched size of PI under humidity H₁, E_m and A_m refer to Young’s modulus and cross sectional area of PI and remain unchanged with humidity. On the right side k₀ is original size of ring fixture, k₁ is compressed size of ring fixture under humidity H₁, E_k and A_k refer to Young’s modulus and cross sectional area of ring fixture and remain unchanged with humidity:

$$\frac{m_1-m_0}{m_0}{E}_{\mathrm{m}}{A}_{\mathrm{m}}=\frac{k_0-k_1}{k_0}{E}_{\mathrm{k}}{A}_{\mathrm{k}}$$

(2)

$$\frac{m_2-{m^{\prime }}_0}{{m^{\prime }}_0}{E}_{\mathrm{m}}{A}_{\mathrm{m}}=\frac{k_0-k_2}{k_0}{E}_{\mathrm{k}}{A}_{\mathrm{k}}$$

(3)

Assume that humidity increases from H₁ to H₂ (H₂ > H₁), a new static equilibrium is established, as expressed by Equation (3), where on the left side m₂, is the stretched size of PI under humidity H₂, m’₀ is original size of PI membrane under humidity H₂. On the right side k₂ is the compressed size of ring fixture under humidity H₂. It is obvious that the sizes of PI and fixture have relations shown in Equations (4)–(7).

$$m_0<m_1<m_2$$

(4)

$$k_1<k_2<k_0$$

(5)

$$m_1=k_1$$

(6)

$$m_2=k_2$$

(7)

The right side of Equation (3) is smaller than the right side of Equation (2) because (k₀ − k₁) > (k₀ − k₂), whereas on the left side m₂ > m₁, thus, to match the Equations, there must be m’₀ > m₀. It is reasonable because wet expansion causes stress release, and m’₀ and m₀ follow Equation (8), by which ΔH equals (H₂ − H₁) and CWE is of free state PI. We can also transform Equation (2) to Equation (9):

$$m_0^{\prime }=\left(1+\Delta H\times \mathrm{CWE}\right)m_0=\mathsf{\alpha }{m}_0$$

(8)

$$\frac{m_1-m_0}{k_0-k_1}=\frac{m_0{E}_{\mathrm{k}}{A}_{\mathrm{k}}}{k_0{E}_{\mathrm{m}}{A}_{\mathrm{m}}}=\mathsf{\beta }$$

(9)

Then we can derive a relationship between m₂ and m₁ in Equation (10). α and β are used for simplification. Because α > 1, thus m₂/m₁ < α and Equation (11) can be derived:

$$\frac{m_2}{m_1}=\mathsf{\alpha }·\frac{1+\mathsf{\beta }}{1+\mathsf{\alpha }\mathsf{\beta }}$$

(10)

$$m_2=\left(1+\Delta H\times {\mathrm{CWE}}^{\prime }\right)m_1.$$

(11)

In Equation (11) CWE’ is a ring-fixed PI membrane and there must be CWE’ < CWE. This explains why CWE of ring-fixed PI is less than that of free state PI.

Then, FZLs were fabricated on ring-fixed, with 10 MPa initial stress, and silica-fixed PI membranes, by contact photolithography and subsequent reactive ion etching. Fabrication process is shown in Figure 7 below and detailed photolithography and etching process parameters are listed in

Table 1. Detailed process parameters.

Process Steps	Parameters	Humidity
Photoresist	AZ3100, 2000 rpm, 60 s	40%–60%
Soft bake	100 °C, 5 min	10%–20%
Exposure	4.5 mW/cm2, 20 s	40%–60%
Development	5% TMAH, 30 s	100%
Hard bake	120 °C, 5 min	10%–20%
Dry etching	O2, 30 sccm, 1 Pa, 100 W, 5 min	0%

below.

Finally, the wave-front errors of fabricated FZLs were measured. The schematic of wave-front error measurement system is shown in the Figure 8 below with site photo. Interferometer and high precision standard mirror were applied to form a self-collimating light path, the PI membrane lens was placed between interferometer and a standard mirror, where the focal plane of interferometer and of Fresnel lens overlapped with each other.

Wave-front error of the PI membrane lens is sensitive to the position accuracy of Fresnel structures [23]. Our designed F# is 10 and maximum acceptable wave-front error is λ/20 in root mean square (RMS). The optical wave-front of PI membrane and silica substrate is less than λ/30 in RMS. The results are shown in Figure 9 below, where silica-fixed PI lens achieved good imaging quality with wave-front error smaller than λ/30 in RMS, and ring-fixed PI lens acquired wave-front error about λ/3 in RMS. The result demonstrates that silica-fixed PI membrane with near zero CWE ensures structure position accuracy of PI membrane FZL. The result also reveals that ring-fixed PI membrane with CWE around 5 ppm/% experienced considerable deformation and caused saddle-shaped astigmatism, as shown in Figure 9b, which indicates anisotropic expansion in plane.

Moreover, if we lower the temperature of the ring fixture when humidity increases, it is possible to eliminate deformation and achieve good imaging quality. Because in Equation (3), if temperature of ring fixture is lowered, the original size of ring decreases from k₀ to k’₀ to balance the Equation. Similarly, we can increase the temperature of the ring fixture when humidity decreases. Therefore, if initial stress of ring-fixed PI membrane is isotropic and sufficient, it is possible to achieve good imaging quality by controlling the temperature of the ring fixture.

3. Conclusions

In conclusion, we introduced a method based on strain gauge to study the wet expansion behaviors of PI membranes, supported by different fixture, and found that silica-fixed PI membrane achieves near zero CWE and FZL, based on silica-fixed PI achieves good imaging quality. We also measured CWE of ring-fixed PI under different stress and discussed the underlying mechanisms. Controlling the ring fixture temperature is expected to eliminate membrane deformation brought by humidity change and achieve good imaging quality for ring-fixed PI membrane FZL.