1. Introduction
As the heart of the hydraulic system power element, axial piston pumps play an irreplaceable role in the aerospace, engineering machinery, national defense, and military industries owing to their high power density [
1], wide variable range [
2], and flexible layout [
3]. In recent years, with the growing emphasis on developing an environmentally friendly and resource-efficient society, researchers in the field of hydraulics, aiming at energy saving and emission reduction, have been committed to technological innovation and optimal design to reinforce the energy efficiency and reliability of the system, and this direction has become an important research hotspot [
4,
5]. Swash plate axial piston pumps typically rely on a valve-operated hydraulic cylinder design for variable control. Although this design has demonstrated its technical superiority in numerous application scenarios, the inherent response delay in hydraulic systems and nonlinear nature of the valve-controlled cylinder in the control process limit the system’s response to changes in external conditions [
6,
7]. At the same time, the pump’s variable displacement mechanism plays a crucial role in enhancing the pump’s flow response. By optimizing the variable displacement mechanism, the flow rate can be regulated faster and more accurately [
8]. Therefore, exploring and optimizing the variable regulation mechanism of axial piston pumps to overcome these inherent limitations has become a key task in improving the overall performance and energy efficiency of hydraulic systems.
Scholars have made significant progress in exploring advanced control methods for the variable displacement mechanism of swash plate axial piston pumps. Chu et al. [
9] designed a neural network-based adaptive controller to regulate the swash plate angle. The time response of the swash plate angle was analyzed through both simulation and experimental validation. The results confirm that the proposed neural network controller effectively tracks the target model, demonstrating superior tracking performance and excellent dynamic response. Ahn et al. [
10] proposed an adaptive backstepping control method for electro-hydraulic actuators, which compensates for nonlinearities and uncertainties by means of an improved algorithm and a special adaptive law, thus improving the robustness of the pump control system. Song et al. [
11] proposed a hydraulic pump displacement control method based on a PI algorithm and feedforward compensation, aiming to enhance the dynamic response and tracking accuracy of actuators in construction machinery. Simulation and experimental outcomes demonstrate that the newly developed controller outperforms the conventional PI controller, effectively minimizing actuator oscillation. Yamada et al. [
12] designed a model predictive control (MPC)-based displacement control system for axial piston pumps, considering a variety of constraints and introducing an adaptive system and variable control input constraints to improve control performance. Feng et al. [
13] proposed a control strategy in view of H∞ control theory to ramp up the response speed and control accuracy of the variable displacement mechanism of the swash plate axial piston pump. The study solved the problems of difficult parameter adjustment, serious hysteresis and large overshooting in the traditional PID control, significantly shortened the regulation time, and significantly improved the system’s performance. Helian et al. [
14] devised an adaptive robust pressure control strategy based on an enhanced simplified dynamic model. This approach effectively addresses the challenge of precise pressure tracking in the variable displacement mechanism of axial piston pumps, especially under conditions characterized by dynamic nonlinearity and parameter uncertainty. The effectiveness of the proposed control strategy has been rigorously validated through a series of experiments and simulations conducted under diverse operating conditions. The above algorithms have a joint feature of considering the nonlinearity of the system through the use of nonlinear models. Nevertheless, applying such nonlinear algorithms in engineering practice is still challenging under the current technological constraints.
Some scholars are actively exploring the integration of electro-hydraulic technology into the design of variable displacement mechanisms in pumps. This approach aims to fundamentally transform the traditional valve-controlled variable displacement method in variable displacement pumps, serving as a key strategy to enhance the system’s dynamic response characteristics and overall performance. Gao et al. [
15] proposed a new type of variable displacement mechanism—this variable displacement mechanism drove the active gear through a DC servomotor to achieve rapid adjustment of the pump displacement—and achieved good results through simulation analysis. There is backlash in the gearing process, which inevitably has a negative impact on system performance when the pump is started or reversed. On this basis, Song et al. [
16] proposed replacing the gearing mechanism with a set of conical worm gear mechanisms to minimize the negative effect of backlash on the system’s performance and also placed the variable displacement mechanism inside the pump casing to reduce the effect of external environment on the pump performance. However, the conical worm gear mechanism also has the problems of lower transmission efficiency and higher friction loss. Ma et al. [
17] proposed an advanced axial piston variable pump, which builds on the foundational design of the A4V pump but incorporates a servo valve for direct control of the variable displacement mechanism. This innovative pump design enables precise and timely load sensing in response to output pressure commands issued by the intelligent pump controller. By accurately capturing load dynamics, the system provides critical data essential for real-time monitoring of pump operating status and facilitates proactive troubleshooting and maintenance. Yang et al. [
18] designed an open-loop control mechanism driven by a servo motor floating cup pump for variable control, and the precise control of swash plate angle was achieved—the response time from 0° to 18° was only 0.08 s. Meanwhile, certain issues in the design were identified, which provided a robust theoretical foundation for the optimal design of the variable displacement mechanism of the floating cup pump.
The above studies were conducted to improve the dynamic characteristics and performance metrics of swash plate axial piston pumps from the perspectives of control algorithm and structural design, respectively. There are still problems attributed to the lack of stiffness compensation for the variable displacement control mechanism. The stiffness of the traditional valve-controlled cylinder variable displacement mechanism mainly depends on the structural design and material properties, while in the hydraulic system, the working conditions are often complex and constantly changing, which leads to the existence of certain limitations of passive stiffness control. In contrast, active stiffness control is better able to adapt to these changes and can adjust stiffness in real time to ensure that the system is always in the best working condition.
Piezoelectric ceramics as smart materials have found extensive application in the fields of micro-robotics [
19] and scanning tunneling microscopes (STMs) [
20] owing to their high frequency response, high stiffness, and large mass ratio [
21]. Therefore, output force control with fast response can be achieved by piezoelectric ceramics. However, the inherent hysteresis, creep, and other [
22] nonlinear characteristics of piezoelectric ceramics pose a challenge for improving their control accuracy. The ball screw mechanism is one of the most widely used drive systems and has the advantages of high speed, large stroke, and high transmission efficiency [
23,
24]. Through the design of its mechatronics, it replaces the traditional valve-controlled hydraulic-type variable displacement mechanism, which significantly increases control precision and response speed of variable displacement pump. The vibration of the swash plate of an axial piston pump is closely related to the stiffness of the swash plate, and the ball screw directly transmits the alternating load of the swash plate through a mechanical connection. Vibration of the swash plate affects the ball screw through this mechanical connection, leading to a loss of system stability and adversely affecting the performance of the overall system. To improve this situation, piezoelectric ceramics were introduced as a variable stiffness actuator into the nut assembly to enable dynamic stiffness compensation control of the ball screw.
In this paper, a stiffness model of a two-nut ball screw is developed to obtain the relationship between the piezoelectric ceramic and the two nuts. The paper also establishes an asymmetric Bouc–Wen piezoelectric actuator model with nonlinear hysteresis characteristics and uses a particle swarm algorithm with improved inertia weights to identify parameters of the asymmetric Bouc–Wen model. Finally, the piezoelectric actuator model based on feedforward inverse model and PID composite control algorithm is applied to the variable displacement mechanism system for stiffness compensation. The ball screw variable displacement mechanism with piezoelectric ceramic compensation shows significant advantages in the application of swash plate axial piston pumps. Simulation results demonstrate that the stiffness compensation provided by piezoelectric ceramics significantly enhances the stability of the plunger pump swash plate. This improvement contributes substantially to the overall efficiency and reliability of the pump. The system exhibits the capability to maintain stable output flow and pressure across a range of operating conditions, underscoring its considerable potential for industrial applications.
5. Results and Discussion
To thoroughly analyze the improvement potential of the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism compared to the traditional valve-controlled variable displacement mechanism in terms of response speed, control accuracy, and overall dynamic performance, we developed a ball screw simulation model actuated by a piezoelectric actuator in the Simulink environment. This model is based on the previously established mathematical framework. In addition, a hydraulic model of axial piston pump containing modules such as plunger vice, distributor disk vice and swash plate torque was built on the AMESim platform to simulate in detail the fluid dynamics inside the pump chamber, the influence of the swash plate position on displacement and the interaction with the external hydraulic circuit. This study utilizes the co-simulation technology of AMESim and Simulink and realizes the efficient integration of the two through the co-simulation framework shown in
Figure 7. We built a comprehensive simulation model of the entire axial piston pump system, incorporating an electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism. This model integrates the Simulink environment with AMESim through an interactive interface, using AMESim’s interface module to facilitate seamless coupling between the two platforms. The force applied to the swash plate is transferred through the interface module to the variable displacement mechanism model built in Simulink, ensuring the transfer and response of the force throughout the whole system.
Figure 8 shows the control of the integrated system in a block diagram, clearly delineating the interconnections and data exchange paths among its components. The primary parameters of the joint simulation model, detailed in
Table 3, serve as the basis for ensuring the accuracy and reliability of simulation results. These parameters are critical for validating the model’s performance and providing a robust basis for analyzing the system’s dynamic behavior, response speed, and control accuracy.
Figure 9 presents a comparison of the response characteristics of the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism and the traditional valve-controlled variable displacement mechanism under target-angle step command conditions. It is worth noting that although both of them adopt closed loop control strategies, the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism, by virtue of its unique mechanical structure design, goes directly through the servomotor-driven ball screw to regulate the position of the swash plate. This mechanism avoids the complex fluid dynamics process in the traditional hydraulic valve control and greatly shortens the signal transmission path, which significantly reduces the control hysteresis and accelerates the speed of regulation. Excellent dynamic performance is demonstrated. The electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism rapidly approaches the target angle compared to the valve-controlled electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism, with a response time of about 0.06 s. This clearly demonstrates the significant advantages of electronic control technology in improving the dynamic response speed of the system, reflecting the potential of electronic control technology in the design of hydraulic systems. This finding not only verifies the theoretical expectation of electronically controlled design in reducing control hysteresis and speeding up the regulatory process but also provides strong empirical support for the subsequent design and realization of high-performance control systems.
To comprehensively evaluate and compare the dynamic responses of the electronically controlled and valve-controlled variable displacement mechanisms, a frequency domain analysis was conducted. Converting the signals in the time domain to the frequency domain allows us to visualize the gain and phase changes at different frequency components and helps to compare the dynamic performance of the two control methods. The resulting frequency response characteristic curves are presented in
Figure 10.
Based on the results shown in
Figure 10, we delve into the significant differences in the dynamic response characteristics between the valve-controlled and electronically controlled variable displacement mechanisms. The cutoff frequency of the valve-controlled variable displacement mechanism shown in
Figure 10a is 2.65 Hz at −3 dB, while the cutoff frequency of the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism shown in
Figure 10b is 5.9 Hz. This not only indicates that the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism has a wider frequency response range but also is able to maintain an effective control accuracy and dynamic adjustment capability in a wider frequency spectrum. The phase Bode plot further reveals the stability advantage of the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism, which has a larger phase margin and helps to improve the system stability. In contrast, the stability of the valve-controlled variable displacement mechanism may be limited in the high frequency band. Consequently, the electronically controlled system exhibits enhanced adaptability to rapidly changing operating conditions.
Figure 11 shows comparative curves of the step response for the electronically con-trolled variable displacement mechanism. The results vividly demonstrate the significant impact of friction on the response characteristics of the system. When friction is taken into account, the system exhibits a smoother response with notably reduced oscillations. Conversely, when friction is ignored, the system’s response becomes more erratic, with increased oscillations. This comparison highlights the critical role of the friction coefficient in achieving stable and precise control performance.
This is due to the fact that the presence of friction in the system acts as a damping effect, reducing oscillations by absorbing the excess energy of the system. The coefficient of friction acts as a “shock absorber” in this case, helping to improve the stability and response quality of the system. However, it is essential to mention that while the friction coefficient plays a beneficial role in reducing oscillations, the complex and nonlinear nature of friction—in particular, its variability with temperature and velocity—can introduce additional challenges in the design and maintenance of control systems for practical applications. In future research, we will more comprehensively consider the impact of friction factors on the control accuracy and stability of the system, aiming to further enhance its overall performance.
Figure 12 reveals the dynamic response characteristics of the control system during the switching process from positive to negative displacement by the electronically con-trolled variable displacement mechanism. The outcomes indicate that the swash plate inclination angle can be better realized under the regulation of the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism to switch from positive to negative full displacement, which verifies the accuracy of the model. However, in the switching of displacement, the problems of overshooting and oscillation are generated. Specifically, the maximum overshoot of the system without stiffness compensation reaches 31.8%, which not only affects the response speed of the system but also reduces the accuracy of position switching. Preliminary analysis may be due to the inertia of the swash plate and the drive mechanism causing overshoot in the switching process. Additionally, the hydraulic system contains a variety of nonlinear factors—such as saturation, dead zone, etc.—that may be more significant in the displacement switching process, especially regarding positive displacement switching to negative displacement performance.
Aiming at the problem of oscillation or overshoot during the switching process of the swash plate, an active adjustment method based on piezoelectric ceramic is proposed in this paper. By precisely controlling the excitation voltage of the piezoelectric element, the local stiffness distribution of the ball screw can be changed in real-time operation. This dynamic tuning function enables the system to immediately adjust its intrinsic frequency and damping characteristics during the swash plate switching period, thus suppressing unwanted vibrations and improving overall dynamics. The swash plate position switching curve under the variable stiffness adjustment of piezoelectric ceramics is shown in
Figure 13. The adjusted system exhibits significantly reduced oscillation and overshoot during swash plate position switching. The maximum system overshoot was significantly reduced to 1.9%. In addition, the tuned system exhibits faster settling time. This demonstrates that dynamically adjusting the total stiffness of the ball screw, the system can accomplish the position switching more smoothly and accurately, and the piezoelectric element is able to adjust its output in real time according to the system’s demand, thus changing the stiffness characteristics of the ball screw. This dynamic adjustment mechanism effectively suppresses the nonlinear effect and reduces the instability caused by the stiffness change, making the system more stable and controllable during the switching process.
6. Conclusions
In order to overcome the limitations in the existing design of the traditional valve-controlled axial piston pump, this paper develops an electronically controlled variable displacement control mechanism with stiffness compensation based on piezoelectric actuators. The vibration of the swash plate is closely related to its stiffness, and its vibration characteristics can be improved by changing its stiffness. Therefore, a piezoelectric element is introduced into the ball screw mechanically connected to the swash plate to compensate for the stiffness of the entire system, thus improving the vibration characteristics of the swash plate and enhancing the stability and dynamic performance of the system. Through mathematical modeling and simulation analysis, it is found that the response speed of the electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism is significantly better than that of the traditional valve-controlled mechanism under specific conditions, and the system bandwidth is higher so that it can better adapt to changes in dynamic working conditions and improve the regulation capability of rapidly changing loads. In order to address the issue of poor system stability resulting from the alternating reaction force of the swash plate during the operation of the ball screw, this paper introduces piezoelectric ceramics characterized by their reversibility, high stiffness, and high frequency response into the nut assembly to achieve stiffness compensation control. Based on this approach, we established a stiffness model for the double nut ball screw and explored the relationship between piezoelectric ceramics and double nut assembly. Furthermore, an asymmetric Bouc–Wen piezoelectric actuator model incorporating nonlinear hysteresis characteristics was developed, and the parameters of this model were identified using an improved PSO algorithm. The results demonstrate that the stiffness compensation system exhibits enhanced stability during both positive and negative full displacement switching of the swash plate. This finding verifies the reliability and efficacy of the proposed electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism and its associated stiffness compensation strategy. In studying the friction factor, it was observed that the reasonable use of friction can significantly improve the stability and control accuracy of the system, while reducing the oscillation of the system response. These findings indicate that the proposed electronically controlled variable displacement mechanism, along with its stiffness compensation method, provides robust support for enhancing the dynamic performance of swash plate axial piston pumps.