ESG-Based Performance Assessment of the Operation and Management of Industrial Parks in Taiwan
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
It is an overall very good article. All of the chapters are very clear presented and in a good structure. The methods are good to find out what the research questions want to analyze.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
I sincerely appreciate your comments. Thank you for helping me make the article better and clearer.
Best regards,
Liling Kao
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
1. section Introduction please add the paper organized in the last paragraph.
2.Table 3. Performance Assessment Indicators for Industrial Park Operation and Management in Taiwan, please formulate detail the where the reference cited.
3.Each table shall be marked with the full name of the code in English
4. the reference 24.25.28, the three format is not same with other literature.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
I sincerely appreciate your comments and have revised my manuscript accordingly. I hope my efforts have effectively addressed your concerns. Thank you for helping me make the article better and clearer.
To expedite your review, those of “revision” are respectively marked with red-color in the revised manuscript. The following paragraphs summarize my efforts in response to reviewer’s comment and suggestions.
as following attched.
Best Regards,
Liling Kao
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Content is more than contextualized enough providing every reader with knowledge on basic ESG platform to its complex use in business practice.
Regarding the methods used I just want to state that any method (DEA, panel analysis) will provide realistic results when the tested variables are choosed in a correct manner. In case of CSR and ESG correctly stated connections among frameworks of sustainability and business practices always provide valid results. The challenge is how to present sustainability correctly, and authors have done this well on a wide sample.
I would also like to state that DEA was alreaddy used in research of the ESG and sustainability platforms. Scientific approach to sustainability is on a verge,therefore reccomendation to the authors would be to use new analytical approaches in future ESG research. In research of sustainability issues for high originality and new scientific findings a new models of sustainability research have to implemented. DEA is not always applicable or ment to be used for sustainability platforms evaluation.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
I sincerely appreciate your comments and have revised my manuscript accordingly. I hope my efforts have effectively addressed your concerns. Thank you for helping me make the article better and clearer.
To expedite your review, those of “revision” are respectively marked with red-color in the revised manuscript. The following paragraphs summarize my efforts in response to reviewer’s comment and suggestions.
Best Regards,
Liling Kao
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
I highly appreciate the quality of the reviewed article.
The research methodology, research model, data acquisition and discussion of the results were thoroughly presented and explained. This was preceded by a presentation of the results of the work related to the research area to date. Clearly explained how the conclusions of the research results obtained should be used in management practice.
Suggestions for directions for further research based on the results obtained are worth adding.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
I sincerely appreciate your comments and have revised my manuscript accordingly. I hope my efforts have effectively addressed your concerns. Thank you for helping me make the article better and clearer.
To expedite your review, those of “revision” are respectively marked with red-color in the revised manuscript. The following paragraphs summarize my efforts in response to reviewer’s comment and suggestions.
Best Regards,
Liling Kao
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 5 Report
The research is very good and addresses an important problem related to human lifeÙˆ its future and the sustainable development.
The English language is good, but it needs improvement, as some sentences were written too long and needed to be split into two or more sentences.
Comments for author File: Comments.pdf
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
I sincerely appreciate your comments and have revised my manuscript accordingly. I hope my efforts have effectively addressed your concerns. Thank you for helping me make the article better and clearer.
To expedite your review, those of “revision” are respectively marked with red-color in the revised manuscript. The following paragraphs summarize my efforts in response to reviewer’s comment and suggestions.
Best Regards,
Liling Kao
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
