1. Introduction
Enhanced oil recovery (EOR) is an essential method for maximizing crude oil extraction from reservoirs once primary and secondary recovery techniques become insufficient. Among various EOR methods, polymer flooding has gained significant attention due to its ability to increase the viscosity of injected fluids, thereby enhancing oil displacement efficiency by improving the mobility ratio between oil and water phases [
1]. Commonly utilized polymers in EOR, such as hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) and xanthan gum, face major challenges in high-temperature and high-salinity reservoir conditions, often leading to thermal, mechanical, and microbial degradation [
2]. Consequently, there is growing interest in alternative polymers and additives that can maintain their viscosity and structural integrity under such harsh environments.
To address these challenges, researchers have explored the use of inorganic nanoparticles, such as titanium dioxide and silica, as additives to enhance the rheological properties of polymers in EOR applications, leveraging their ability to withstand high-temperature and high-salinity conditions [
3]. However, issues like nanoparticle aggregation, poor dispersion, and environmental concerns limit their practical application [
4]. Additionally, the need to combat global warming necessitates the pursuit of environmentally efficient solutions. Biopolymers like cassava starch (CS) have emerged as promising, eco-friendly alternatives due to their biodegradability, availability, cost-effectiveness, and excellent swelling capacity in water [
5]. Despite these advantages, native cassava starch exhibits limitations, including large particle sizes that can clog reservoir pores and instability in high-temperature and high-salinity conditions [
6]. Reducing cassava starch to the nanoscale—resulting in cassava starch nanoparticles (CSNPs)—increases surface area, enhances stability, and improves interactions with reservoir fluids, thereby increasing viscosity and aiding efficient oil recovery [
7].
Despite the potential of CSNPs, traditional synthesis methods often face challenges in achieving high yields and stability. For instance, acid hydrolysis with strong inorganic acids like sulfuric acid (H
2SO
4) and hydrochloric acid (HCl) has been linked to low yields and lengthy processing times, with Shahrodin et al. reporting yields as low as 0.54% to 1.10% after treating native cassava starch with H
2SO
4 at 37 °C for 5 to 7 days [
8]. Recent advances in starch modification offer promising alternatives. Alassmy et al. (2023) demonstrated the potential of sustainable organocatalytic esterification to enhance starch stability, using potato starch and acetic anhydride to achieve intermediate degrees of substitution (0.2 < DS < 1.5), offering insights into green chemistry approaches that can be adapted for EOR [
9]. Matovanni et al. (2023) synthesized cassava starch-grafted polyacrylamide hydrogel using a microwave-assisted method, achieving high viscosity and stability under reservoir conditions, directly supporting its potential for EOR polymer flooding [
10]. Akinyemi et al. (2021) evaluated cassava starch as a viscosifier in water-based drilling muds, demonstrating its rheological enhancement under oilfield conditions, and suggesting its potential for EOR with further modification [
11]. Additionally, Qi et al. (2024) reported that extrusion-induced modification of cassava starch reduces molecular weight and enhances enzymatic hydrolysis, offering a sustainable approach to improve starch functionality that could be adapted for EOR applications [
12]. These advancements highlight the potential of modified cassava starch as a sustainable alternative to synthetic polymers in challenging EOR environments.
Ultrasonication has emerged as a promising technique to further enhance the synthesis process by providing mechanical forces that facilitate the dislodging and fragmentation of starch granules, selectively targeting amorphous regions while preserving crystalline domains essential for mechanical stability [
13]. This method also reduces particle aggregation, ensuring that the resulting nanoparticles remain well-dispersed, which is crucial for reliable viscosity enhancement and injectivity in reservoir operations. However, systematic studies on the combined and optimized effects of acetic acid hydrolysis and ultrasonication for producing high-performance CSNPs tailored for EOR remain limited.
This study aims to bridge this gap by employing response surface methodology (RSM) to optimize key parameters—acid concentration, temperature, and hydrolysis time—for an ultrasonication-assisted acetic acid synthesis route to CSNP production [
14]. The objective is to achieve consistently high yields of small, stable nanoparticles capable of delivering robust viscosity and withstanding the high-salinity, high-temperature environments typical of oil reservoirs. This optimized process will contribute to greener manufacturing practices and offer an alternative to strong-acid hydrolysis processes, supporting efforts to enhance oil recovery through more durable and environmentally responsible polymer flooding agents.
4. Discussion
The present study successfully optimized the synthesis of cassava starch nanoparticles (CSNPs) using ultrasonic-assisted acetic acid hydrolysis, achieving high yields and desirable physicochemical properties tailored for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) applications. The optimization process, facilitated by response surface methodology (RSM), revealed that varying the acid concentration, temperature, and hydrolysis time significantly influenced the yield, particle size, and viscosity of the resulting CSNPs. Notably, the two optimized samples, CSNP A and CSNP B, demonstrated distinct characteristics that underscore the efficacy of the chosen synthesis parameters.
One of the most compelling outcomes of this study is the remarkably high recovery yields of CSNPs exceeding 96%, which contrasts with yields reported in previous studies employing strong inorganic acids such as hydrochloric acid (HCl) and sulfuric acid (H
2SO
4) [
8,
16,
17]. The improved yield can be attributed to the selective hydrolysis achieved through the use of acetic acid, a milder organic acid that preferentially targets the amorphous regions of cassava starch while preserving the integrity of the crystalline domains. This selective degradation minimizes the excessive breakdown of glycosidic bonds within the crystalline regions, thereby maintaining the structural robustness of the nanoparticles. Additionally, the incorporation of ultrasonication plays a pivotal role by enhancing mass transfer and promoting the efficient cleavage of starch granules into nanoparticles without significant mass loss, as reported by Agi et al. [
15] and Dinari and Mallakpour [
19]. The combined effect of acetic acid concentration and ultrasonication maximized the yield and assisted in producing uniformly sized nanoparticles, which is critical for their performance in EOR applications. From an economic perspective, ultrasonication’s viability for large-scale starch hydrolysis is promising due to its ability to enhance reaction efficiency, reduce processing times, and achieve high yields (>96%) using a milder, less corrosive reagent like acetic acid compared to traditional strong-acid methods [
8,
15]. While energy input and equipment costs are considerations, industrial ultrasonication systems are increasingly scalable, as demonstrated in food and polymer processing [
30], suggesting potential cost-effectiveness. A detailed cost-benefit analysis is planned for future scale-up studies to confirm its economic feasibility.
Morphological analysis through scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) revealed that the optimized CSNPs exhibited reduced particle sizes compared to native cassava starch. CSNP B, synthesized under more intensive hydrolysis conditions, displayed nanoparticles ranging from 6 to 41 nm, which is smaller than the 13 to 83 nm range observed for CSNP A. This reduction in particle size is advantageous for EOR as smaller nanoparticles offer a larger surface area, enhancing their interaction with reservoir fluids and improving the mobility ratio during polymer flooding. The smaller size of CSNP B facilitates deeper penetration into low-permeability reservoirs, thereby increasing oil displacement efficiency. However, it is essential to balance particle size to prevent pore-blocking in high-permeability reservoirs, a consideration that underscores the practical applicability of both CSNP A and CSNP B in different reservoir conditions.
Rheological assessments demonstrated that both CSNP A and CSNP B exhibited shear-thickening behavior, with CSNP B showing a higher viscosity compared to CSNP A and native cassava starch. The shear-thickening property is particularly beneficial for EOR as it ensures that the polymer solution maintains its viscosity under high shear rates encountered during injection, thereby improving mobility control and reducing the likelihood of viscous fingering [
39,
40]. The higher viscosity of CSNP B is attributed to its smaller particle size, which improves inter-particle interactions and electrostatic repulsion, leading to increased suspension viscosity. Moreover, the ultrasonication process contributes to a more organized nanoparticle structure, further augmenting internal resistance and viscosity [
21]. These rheological improvements position CSNP B as a superior candidate for polymer flooding in EOR, particularly in scenarios demanding sustained viscosity for effective oil displacement.
Thermal analysis via differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) revealed that CSNP B possesses enhanced thermal stability and increased crystallinity compared to both native cassava starch and CSNP A. The DSC thermograms indicated that CSNP B required greater enthalpy changes for gelatinization, reflecting a more organized and crystalline starch matrix. This enhanced crystallinity, confirmed by X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis, is crucial for maintaining structural integrity under the high-temperature conditions prevalent in many oil reservoirs [
50]. The TGA results further demonstrated the thermal robustness of CSNP B, showing a higher decomposition onset temperature and significantly lower weight loss, which indicate a denser and more stable nanoparticle structure. These thermal properties ensure that CSNP B remains effective and stable during the injection process and prolonged exposure to reservoir conditions.
Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopic analysis confirmed that the fundamental chemical structure of cassava starch remained intact post-hydrolysis, with no significant shifts in peak positions. However, a reduction in peak intensity suggested a decrease in bound water content and a more compact structure due to selective hydrolysis. The increased relative crystallinity observed in CSNP B, as evidenced by higher R1047/1018 and lower R1018/995 ratios, aligns with the XRD findings and indicates a successful enhancement of the crystalline regions. These structural modifications are integral to resisting the harsh thermal, salinity, and mechanical stresses typically encountered during EOR.
The successful application of RSM optimization confirms that the interplay of acid concentration, temperature, and reaction time can be fine-tuned to yield desirable nanoparticle sizes, high recovery percentages, and robust rheological characteristics. This outcome not only validates the effectiveness of RSM in complex, multivariable systems but also provides a roadmap for industrial-scale production of CSNPs tailored to specific reservoir requirements. Given the reproducibility and accuracy of the optimized conditions, scaling up the current laboratory approach to pilot or commercial levels appears feasible. Moreover, the use of acetic acid, with its lower corrosiveness and environmental footprint, aligns with the industry’s move toward more sustainable chemical processes. The favorable rheological performance and enhanced thermal stability of CSNP B highlight its potential as an alternative or complementary agent to conventional EOR polymers, which often face degradation under high-temperature or high-salinity conditions. By retaining high viscosity and ensuring stable flow characteristics over the lifespan of the flooding process, CSNP B can help mitigate common issues such as polymer breakdown and rapid viscosity loss. Although field trials will be necessary to verify laboratory outcomes in real reservoir environments, the demonstrated synergy between green processing, high yields, and strong performance underlines the relevance of this approach in addressing global energy challenges.
Preliminary Assessment of CSNPs for EOR Applications
The primary objective of synthesizing cassava starch nanoparticles (CSNPs) in this study was to develop a sustainable, high-performance material tailored for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) through polymer flooding. While direct oil recovery experiments, such as core flooding, were not conducted in this initial investigation due to its focus on synthesis optimization and characterization, the physicochemical properties of CSNP A and CSNP B provide a strong foundation for assessing their potential applicability in EOR.
CSNP B, with an average particle size of 99.4 nm (DLS), exhibits a high apparent viscosity and pronounced shear-thickening behavior (
Figure 5), which are critical for improving the mobility ratio between oil and water phases during polymer flooding [
1,
39]. The smaller particle size enhances its ability to penetrate low-permeability reservoirs, increasing sweep efficiency and oil displacement, as smaller nanoparticles are known to improve fluid interaction and reduce pore-blocking risks in such conditions [
34,
35]. Conversely, CSNP A, with a larger particle size of 206.77 nm, may be better suited for high-permeability reservoirs where pore clogging is less of a concern, offering a cost-effective alternative due to its shorter synthesis time (3 days vs. 7 days for CSNP B) [
37,
38]. The shear-thickening property observed in both CSNPs ensures that viscosity is maintained or even increases under the high shear rates encountered during injection, mitigating the viscosity loss commonly observed in conventional EOR polymers like hydrolyzed polyacrylamide (HPAM) under similar conditions [
2,
45]. This behavior is particularly advantageous for maintaining mobility control and reducing polymer dosage requirements in EOR operations.
Thermal stability is another critical factor for EOR applications, given the elevated temperatures often encountered in oil reservoirs. CSNP B demonstrated superior thermal stability, with a decomposition onset temperature of 287 °C and a residual mass of 63.5% as shown in Table, compared to CSNP A (285.9 °C, 10.5% residual) and native CS (278 °C, 8.2% residual). This enhanced stability, coupled with increased crystallinity (14.5% RC,
Table 4), suggests that CSNP B can withstand prolonged exposure to high-temperature and high-salinity environments without significant degradation, a common limitation of biopolymers like xanthan gum [
2,
60]. The ability of CSNPs to maintain structural integrity under such conditions supports their potential to outperform or complement synthetic polymers in harsh reservoir settings.
Furthermore, the high recovery yields (>96%) achieved for both CSNP variants highlight the efficiency of the ultrasonic-assisted acetic acid hydrolysis process, ensuring scalability and economic viability for industrial EOR applications. The use of a biodegradable, eco-friendly material like cassava starch also aligns with the industry’s shift toward sustainable practices, offering an environmentally responsible alternative to inorganic nanoparticles or synthetic polymers [
4,
5].
While these properties strongly indicate that CSNP B, in particular, is a promising candidate for EOR polymer flooding, we acknowledge that laboratory-scale core flooding experiments and field trials are essential to quantify oil recovery efficiency and validate injectivity under realistic reservoir conditions. Such studies will assess parameters like residual oil saturation, displacement efficiency, and long-term stability in porous media, providing conclusive evidence of CSNPs’ practical utility. These next steps are planned as part of our ongoing research to bridge the gap between laboratory characterization and field application, ensuring that the potential demonstrated here translates to tangible EOR performance.
5. Conclusions
This study successfully optimized the synthesis of cassava starch nanoparticles (CSNPs) using ultrasonic-assisted acetic acid hydrolysis, guided by response surface methodology (RSM), to produce two variants—CSNP A and CSNP B—with high recovery yields exceeding 96%, surpassing those of conventional inorganic acid methods. CSNP B, characterized by a smaller particle size (99.4 nm), exhibited superior rheological properties, including higher viscosity and pronounced shear-thickening behavior, alongside enhanced thermal stability (decomposition onset at 287 °C, 63.5% residual mass) and crystallinity (14.5% RC). These attributes position CSNP B as a promising candidate for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) polymer flooding, particularly in low-permeability, high-temperature, and high-salinity reservoirs, where sustained viscosity and structural integrity are paramount. CSNP A, with a larger particle size (206.77 nm) and shorter synthesis time, offers a cost-effective alternative for high-permeability reservoirs. FTIR and XRD analyses confirmed the nanoparticles’ increased crystallinity, while DSC and TGA underscored their thermal robustness, critical for EOR applications. A preliminary assessment based on these properties suggests that CSNPs, especially CSNP B, can enhance mobility control and oil displacement efficiency in EOR by maintaining viscosity under high shear rates and resisting degradation in harsh reservoir conditions. However, to fully validate their efficacy, future work must include laboratory core flooding experiments and field trials to quantify oil recovery performance under realistic conditions. Scaling up the synthesis process also remains a key step toward industrial applicability. This study lays a strong foundation for developing sustainable, high-performance biopolymer nanoparticles, offering a viable alternative to conventional EOR agents and contributing to greener oil recovery practices.