1. Introduction
An umbilical is the core equipment of the entire production system, which is widely applied to connect a floating body to the subsea manifold, providing hydraulic transmission, chemical injection, electrical energy, and control signal transmission for sub-sea trees. The subsea production system’s umbilical structure is shown in
Figure 1 [
1]. The umbilical is typically a multi-layer elongated helical wound armored structure, which generally consists of internal components such as cables, optical cables, steel pipes, etc. During the operation of the umbilical, it is subject to complex loads such as waves and currents. Hence, the safety of the umbilical structure has been directly related to the normal operation of the entire underwater production system. The mechanical properties of the umbilical can directly reflect the safety of the structure. Nevertheless, the umbilical consists of a multi-material and multi-component composite structure, with a large amount of nonlinear contact and friction, which is a typical heterogeneous anisotropic structure. The above factors bring great challenges in solving the mechanical properties of the umbilical [
2,
3].
During operation, the umbilical is subjected to tension at the top of the umbilical where it connects to the floating body, and the mechanical behavior of the umbilical at the touchdown point is also subjected to axial compression. Mechanical behaviors such as tension and compression act on the umbilical structure over the long term. Consequently, it is essential to analyze the mechanical properties of the umbilical. To effectively restore the working environment of the umbilical, the industry normally adopts Deepwater Immersion Performance (DIP) experiments that simulate the actual working conditions to perform relevant research. Braga et al. [
4] reproduced the lateral slip instability damage pattern of the umbilical helical armor layer by the DIP experimental method, which revealed that the bending load plays an important role in inducing the lateral slip instability of the armor layer. Secher et al. [
5] observed the lateral slip instability of the armor layer under combined bending and compression loads while conducting structural simulation certification experiments for the umbilical at 3000 m water depth, and then determined the limit capacity of the armor layer of the umbilical to resist lateral slip instability damage through experimental data analysis. Considering the extremely high cost and difficult operation of DIP experiments, most scholars have tried to investigate the umbilical from indoor equivalent loading experiments, theoretical analysis, and numerical simulations. Sousa et al. [
6] constructed an indoor simulation experimental setup to simulate the umbilical structure with combined bending and compression loads and carried out the corresponding destabilization damage research. The experimental data on the displacement and torsion angle of the steel armor wire have been analyzed, which has verified the feasibility of the numerical simulation and explained the destabilization damage mechanism.
Sertã et al. [
7] designed an experimental setup to simulate combined bending, compression, and external pressure loads, and performed instability damage simulation experiments for umbilical with 2.5-inch and 4-inch diameters, simultaneously comparing the traditional results with the data to prove the validity of the developed numerical simulation. Féret et al. [
8] used a formula that allows a preliminary estimation of the service life of the umbilical by calculating the inter-layer slip and stresses caused by bending. Nevertheless, the method must be completed by experimentally determining the friction coefficient. Knapp [
9] pioneered a new set of equilibrium equations that were used to solve the cable stiffness matrix under tension and torsion. Bahtui et al. [
10] performed a numerical analysis of the umbilical, which compared the numerical simulation results with various load condition scenarios to demonstrate the feasibility of the numerical simulation. Guttner et al. [
11] developed 2D and 3D models for umbilical subjected to crush load, which were used to predict the strain field of the umbilical with two different numerical methods. The results demonstrated that the numerical calculation of the 2D model can be faster under the crushing load, yet the calculation results of the two models have to be consistent. Qu et al. [
12] designed a new structure for umbilicals to adapt to the working environment of 400 m water depth and utilized UFLEX to study the stress and mechanical properties of the umbilical under 400 m water depth, which verified the rationality and reliability of the structural design of the umbilical. Wagner et al. [
13] developed a novel manufacturing process for seam-welded stainless steel pipes that improves the mechanical properties of the pipes, which avoids the effects of water depth, pressure, and temperature on the structural properties of the umbilical.
Yang et al. [
14] proposed a semi-analytical calculation method to calculate the nonlinear tensile-torsional coupling effect of an umbilical. Tensile experiments were conducted on the umbilical, which demonstrated the accuracy of the method. Simultaneously, it can provide beneficial data references for the design of an umbilical. Mechanical properties of the umbilical are normally analyzed with theoretical analysis, experimental testing, and numerical simulation. Due to the existence of substantial nonlinearities in umbilical, it is difficult to accurately solve the mechanical behavior of the umbilical via theoretical analysis, while the experimental cost is extremely high. Consequently, numerical simulation [
15] has become the mainstream method for the current analysis of the mechanical behavior of an umbilical. Nevertheless, numerical simulation computation is frequently time-consuming and prone to non-convergence.
Consequently, determining how to avoid the high cost of calculation time while ensuring the accuracy of the calculation results is essential. With the development of deep learning, considerable efforts have been focused on using deep learning for real-time computation [
16,
17,
18,
19,
20,
21], which is applied to avoid time cost consumption. Bhaduri et al. [
22] applied deep learning methods to predict the stress fields of fiber-reinforced composites to address the huge computational time cost associated with finite element analysis. The stress field of the composites with different numbers of fibers has been obtained via the U-Net network, which provides a reference for the subsequent material stress analysis. Nie et al. [
23] proposed two different deep learning models, SCSNet and StressNet, for predicting the stress field distribution in 2D cantilever beams, respectively.
Among the existing studies on the mechanical properties of umbilical, few studies have been conducted to obtain the stress field distribution of umbilical in real time. Vinicius et al. [
24] combined finite element analysis with deep learning and proposed the NARX-CNN network model to predict the tension and curvature of the umbilical in the first time, and the accuracy of the proposed network model is higher than that of the finite element method, which avoids the disadvantage of the high computational cost of finite elements. Yan et al. [
25] employed a residual neural network to predict the load–displacement curve of umbilical under radial compression, which prevented the computational errors due to the consideration of elastic deformation in the traditional theoretical calculation. The network can only predict the load–displacement curves of large-diameter umbilicals in the plastic stage with data from small-diameter umbilicals, and the accuracy of the network decreases with the reduction of input data. Although the above research has brought about the prediction of the mechanical properties of umbilical, the network structure is relatively simple. Aiming to avoid the time and economic cost consumption caused by traditional numerical simulation methods, a novel deep convolutional neural network PyEf-U-Net is proposed. Adding the pyramidal convolution (Pyra-Con) module in the network transition layer, which employs multiple convolutions of different sizes for feature extraction of the feature map, which fuses multi-scale features. Additionally, adding the efficient channel attention module (EffCA) module after the low-level feature map, avoids the inefficiency of dimensionality reduction operations for channel attention prediction, while capturing feature information across channel interactions in an extremely lightweight manner. The results demonstrate that the PyEf-U-Net not only has fast convergence characteristics and well-generalized capability but also can achieve real-time accurate prediction of the mechanical properties distribution of umbilical.
2. Mathematical Modeling Solutions
The mechanical properties of umbilical are greatly affected by the way in which their components are laid out. The existing umbilical design process largely depends on artificial experience, which enables the layout of the components to meet symmetry and compactness to the extent possible. To address the problems of blindness and inefficiency in artificial experience, as well as for the diversity of subsequent datasets, the DE-GLM algorithm is proposed to provide feasibility for the rapid design of umbilical component layouts. With certain geometric and mechanical conditions satisfied, the umbilical component layout problem can be regarded as an optimization problem. During the process of setting up the optimization model, it is necessary to make certain assumptions considering the complex diversity of the umbilical cross-section.
(1) The cable and optical cable in the internal components have similar characteristics in terms of structural mechanical properties. Hence, during the optimization process, both are considered similar components, i.e., the optical cable is simplified to the cable.
(2) During the optimization process, it is assumed that the components are rigid bodies and the mutual deformation between the components has not been considered.
(3) Assuming the same size of different kinds of components during the optimization process, and ignoring the impact of filling bodies on the layout. After the layout form has been determined, the filling body can be added by itself according to the shape between the components.
The coordinate details of the umbilical components are shown in
Figure 2. The coordinates of the centers of the steel pipe and the cable are
and
, respectively. Throughout the optimization computation, it is necessary to let these components move in a circle of radius
R until the optimal solution is obtained while the radius
R is minimized. Compactness between the components improves the tensile strength of the umbilical.
The umbilical is required to possess high tensile strength in the operating environment and it is necessary to make the components as compact as possible while reducing costs. It is assumed that the geometric index
GE of the compactness of the component layout of the umbilical is affected by the cross-sectional area. The umbilical geometric index
GE can directly affect the cost
CE and mechanical properties
ME, which are related as shown below:
where
λE refers to the geometric coefficient,
ηE refers to the cost coefficient, and
ζE refers to the mechanical property coefficient.
From Equations (1)–(3), it can be seen that when
GE is smaller, the the cost of the umbilical is lower, and the mechanical properties simultaneously better. Consequently, optimization objective 1 is expressed as:
The umbilical mainly sustains the combination form of tensile loads and bending loads during operation. Tensile performance is more critical to the resistance of the umbilical to mechanical failure. Consequently, for better resistance to the failure of the mechanics, the pseudo-gravity index
G is introduced, with the following expression:
where
Ei represents the elastic modulus of the different components and
Ai represents the area of the different components.
As shown in
Figure 3, the pseudo-gravity of the different components forms a set of parallel force systems, between the center of the parallel force system and the center of the umbilical cross-section, with the distance of size
. The size of the distance
can represent the mechanical properties of the umbilical.
and the mechanical properties of the umbilical
MB can be expressed as
where
denotes the pseudo-gravity of the
i-th steel pipe and
denotes the pseudo-gravity of the
j-th cable.
The center deviation distance varies when the layout form of the umbilical varies. When
, the umbilical layout is unbalanced; when
, the umbilical layout is balanced. Consequently, the optimization objective 2 is
Contact wear between steel pipes should be avoided as much as possible during the layout of the umbilical components. The mechanical damage
Df between the steel pipes is expressed as
in which
is the coefficient of mechanical properties. Hence, optimization objective 3 is expressed as
The layout of the components is the multi-objective optimization problem. The optimal solution of multi-objective optimization problems cannot be optimal for all objectives simultaneously, which requires considering all problems in combination to obtain a compromise solution. To satisfy the requirements of layout with compact, balanced, and reduced wear, the multi-objective problem has been transformed into the single-objective problem via weighting coefficients, and the final optimization objective is expressed as
where
K1,
K2, and
K3 denote the normalized weighting coefficients, and
.
f denote to the objective function.
Accordingly, the optimization constraint condition is shown below:
According to the assumptions that the cable and steel pipe sizes are the same (
), while the multi-objective weight coefficients are treated as
K1 =
K2 =
K3 = 1/3, the optimization model can be expressed as
To solve the umbilical layout optimization model, an easy-to-use, and rapidly reliable global optimization algorithm is required. The DE [
26] has the characteristics of greater robustness and high optimization efficiency. Hence, the DE algorithm is introduced to calculate the multi-objective optimization of the umbilical layout. The DE algorithm mainly consists of four steps:
- (1)
Initialize the Population
The size of the population size in the DE algorithm is denoted by
NP, while the size of the dimension of the individuals is denoted by
D, and the initialized individual is expressed as
in which,
i = 1, 2, ⋯,
NP,
j = 1, 2, ⋯,
D.
xij represents the number of dimensions of the population individuals, while the upper and lower limits are represented by
U and
L, respectively.
r refers to the random number between [0,1].
- (2)
Variant Operation
To maintain the diversity of the population, the DE/rand/1/bin difference strategy is used to make the population variable. The expression is
where the scaling factor
Q is a constant, and
r1,
r2, and
r3 represent the individual number.
- (3)
Crossover Operation
Crossover operation is introduced to maintain the diversity of the population. The crossover operation is
in which
CR denotes the crossover probability and
.
- (4)
Selection Operation
The DE algorithm ensures the convergence of the computation according to the adaptation evaluation mechanism, which is operated as follows:
where
represents the experimental individual and
denotes the baseline individual.
Penalty functions [
27] can be used with the DE algorithm to solve constrained optimization problems. The general form of the penalty function is given as
where
f(
X) denotes the objective function,
stands for the penalty coefficient,
Gi(
X) represents the constraint violation function, and
gi(
X) denotes the constraint function.
GLM [
28] combines the Lagrange multiplier method and the outer point penalty function method for solving the optimal value, which is one of the ways to solve constrained optimization problems. After obtaining the feasible solution
with the DE algorithm, the exact solution
is then rapidly acquired via the GLM algorithm, which can be simplified as follows:
in which
f(
X1) represents the objective function and
gi(
X1) refers to the inequality-constrained equation.
Four different layout cases of the umbilical are presented in
Figure 4.
3. Numerical Simulation and Experimental Verification
The typical umbilical cross-section is shown in
Figure 5, which is mainly composed of six steel pipes, three cables, one optical cable, an inner sheath, armor wires, an outer sheath, and filling bodies. The geometric size of each component of the umbilical is shown in
Table 1. Due to the multi-component and multi-material characteristics of the umbilical, a large amount of contact and friction exists between the components, which can cause great difficulties when performing numerical simulations. Consequently, it has been found in existing studies [
29,
30,
31,
32,
33] that certain parts are typically simplified in modeling due to the smaller contribution of these components to the overall strength of the umbilical. Cable is commonly simplified to the polymer dense-wrapped copper core structure, while the optical cable is simplified to polymer dense-wrapped steel shell structure. The simplified umbilical is shown in
Figure 6.
Numerical simulation analysis of the umbilical is performed via ABAQUS simulation software, which is compared and analyzed with subsequent experiments. The total length of the model is the same as the real size, with a total length of 200 mm. The mesh type, C3D8R, in ABAQUS, is chosen since the precision of the computation analysis is not greatly affected when deformation distortion occurs in the mesh. Since the internal components of the umbilical are mostly helical wound structures, the swept mesh division method is adopted to arrange the same mesh seeds in the axial direction, which makes the different components of the umbilical maintain the same size in the axial direction and ensures better mesh contact between adjacent layers. The whole mesh of the umbilical model is shown in
Figure 7. The mesh independent validation is shown in
Table 2. The number of mesh was selected as 150,960 for calculation after considering the calculation accuracy and calculation time of the model.
Umbilical components consist of complex materials, and during the numerical simulation, the steel pipe and armored steel wire are made of stainless steel and low-carbon steel, respectively [
34]. The sheath and filling body are made of high-density polyethylene material, and the conductor in the cable is made of copper material [
35], with the material parameters shown in
Table 3.
Umbilical is typically a helical wound structure, where the structure causes substantial contact and friction between the umbilical components. Umbilical components are large in number and contact each other, not only between neighboring components in the same layer in the circumferential direction but also between neighboring layers in the radial direction. During numerical simulation, generic contact in ABAQUS simulation software is employed to automatically identify all contact pairs. The normal behavior of the contact pairs adopts the default hard contact, which does not allow the contact surfaces to penetrate each other. The tangential behavior of the contact pairs is modeled by defining the Coulomb friction coefficient to simulate interlayer friction.
The boundary condition for the ABAQUS numerical simulation is shown in
Figure 8. Two reference points, RP-1 and RP-2, are established in ABAQUS, which are connected, respectively, to the two ends of the umbilical by the way of motion coupling. Apply load to RP-1 and constraint to RP-2. Since the non-linear characteristics of the umbilical are obvious during the stressing process, the ABAQUS/Explicit solver is adopted for the numerical simulation calculation, which calculates the entire process of force change of the umbilical via the dynamic display.
To demonstrate the accuracy of ABAQUS numerical simulation, the mechanical properties of the umbilical have been evaluated with a servo control universal material testing machine. The testing machine model is GP-TS2000 M/300 KN, and the fixture filling case for the experiment is shown in
Figure 9. The total length of the experimental sample umbilical is 200 mm, which is the same as the total length of the ABAQUS numerical model. The displacement of the umbilical at pressures of 35 KN and 10 KN, respectively has been tested, which compared the obtained experimental results with the ABAQUS numerical simulation results, as shown in
Table 4. It can be seen that the errors of numerical simulation results and experimental results are 4.15% and 3.67%, respectively, with the obtained results being in excellent agreement with the experimental results, which demonstrates the accuracy of the numerical simulation results.