3.1. MPs Abundance
MPs were detected in both surface water and sediment samples from all sampling sections within Jingpo Lake reservoir. The average MP abundance in the surface water was recorded as 304.8 ± 170.5 n/m
3 (
Table 1). In the East Lake, Hubei, situated within the Yangtze River Basin in China, MP concentrations ranged from 952.38 to 10,285.71 n/m
3, with an average of 3329.19 ± 2059.26 n/m
3 [
5]. MPs were also identified in the waters of China’s Taihu Lake, with abundance ranging from 1.8 to 18.2 n/L [
17]. For Lake Superior, MP abundance in water samples ranged from 9000 to 40,000 n/km
2 [
18]. Lake Huron exhibited MP abundance spanning from 59 to 335,714 n/kg [
6]. A study by [
19]. demonstrated that within the Laurentian Great Lakes, among the five major lakes, a total of 21 samples were collected from three lakes, exhibiting a wide range of MP counts from 0 to over 450,000 n/km
2, with an average count density of 43,157 ± 115,519 n/km
2. In Rewalsar Lake, MPs were identified across all samples, with concentrations of 13–238 n/L and 750 to 3020 n/kg [
20].
The average abundance of MPs in sediments was (262.2 ± 143.5) n/kg (
Table 1). In sediment samples from East Lake, the MP abundance ranged from 735.43 to 5021.78 n/kg, with an average of 2207.56 ± 1194.04 n/kg and a detection rate of 100% [
5]. In Elk Lake, the abundance of MPs was 80 ± 30 n/kg; in White Iron Lake, it was 30 ± 20 n/kg; in Ten Mile Lake, it was 180 ± 130 n/kg; and in Peltier Lake, it was 270 ± 200 n/kg. Among these lakes, the two with less human disturbance, Elk Lake and White Iron Lake, exhibited lower levels of MPs. The two lakes with higher human activity, Ten Mile Lake and Peltier Lake, showed MP concentrations roughly comparable to those in this study. However, it should be noted that different lower thresholds for MP size might affect the observed differences in MP concentrations. In study on Minnesota, a lower threshold of 250 μm was used. Due to biological fouling, smaller plastics are more likely to be deposited in sediments, potentially increasing sediment concentrations significantly [
4]. In sediments from Taihu Lake, MP abundance ranged from 460 to 1380 n/kg [
17]. For Lake Huron, sediment concentrations ranged from 59 to 335,714 n/kg [
6].
The average abundance of MPs in the digestive tracts of fish was 11.4 ± 5.4 n/ind (
Table 1). MPs were detected in 44% of white sucker fish, ranging from 0 to 14 n per fish in the upper Thames River, Ontario. The MP content in these fish was similar to that observed in the chosen fish species for this study. MPs were found in 31% of common carp in the upper Thames River, Ontario, ranging from 0 to 128 n/individual [
10]. The notably higher content of MPs in the digestive tracts of common carp, compared to the selected Mongolian redfin in our study, can be attributed to variations in individual size, mouth dimensions, and feeding behavior. The carp examined in a research were substantially larger in size and had larger mouths compared to the Mongolian redfin selected for this study. Moreover, the carp were predatory in nature, leading to a heightened uptake of MPs. In Alpine high-mountain lakes, the average concentration of MPs identified in the gastrointestinal tracts (GIT) of Salvelinus fontinalis from the lower lake (0.45 n/g GIT) was significantly higher than those from the upper lake (0.20 n/g GIT). A negative correlation existed between fish size (weight and age) and the MP abundance within the fish GIT, implying that juvenile fish amassed more MPs, possibly due to their elevated consumption rate of prey compared to adult fish. The research findings of some researchers advocate for employing
S. fontinalis as an indicator of MP pollution in high-mountain lake ecosystems. Additional investigation is necessary to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the sources and repercussions of MPs in these isolated ecosystems [
8,
21].
In comparison to other watersheds, the abundance of MPs in the water, sediments, and fish digestive tracts of Jingpo Lake is relatively low (
Table 1).
Table 1.
Comparison of MP abundance in Jingpo Lake and other water bodies.
Table 1.
Comparison of MP abundance in Jingpo Lake and other water bodies.
Lakes | Concentration of MPs | Reference |
---|
Jingpo lake, China | The average abundance of MPs in water was (304.77 ± 170.5 n/m3, (262.2 ± 143.5) n/kg in sediments, and 11.4 ± 5.4 n/individual in fish digestive tracts | This study |
Xinghu lake, China | MPs varies during wet and dry seasons: MPs in water is 247 ± 120.6 and 273.1 ± 353.7, MPs in sediments is 4.8 ± 2.2 and 10.1 ± 7.6 n/m3 | [11] |
Lake Huron, Canada | MPs in sediments: 59–335,714 n/kg | [6] |
East Lake, China | MPs in water was 3329.19 ± 2059.26 n/m3; MPs in sediments: was 2207.56 ± 1194.04 n/kg. | [5] |
Taihu Lake, China | MPs in water: 1700–8500 n/ m3; MPs in sediments: 460–1380 n/kg | [17] |
Lake Manipal, India | MPs in water: 423 (±250) n/m3. After the monsoon season, the average (±SD) abundance decreased to 117 (±40 n/m3). | [22] |
Ox-Bow Lake, Yenagoa, Nigeria | MPs in water: During the dry season, the abundance ranged from 1004 to 8329 n/m3, while during the rainy season, it ranged from 201 to 8369 n/m3. | [23] |
Kodaikanalan Lake (freshwater), Indian | MPs in water: 24,420 ± 32,220 n/m3; MPs in sediments: 28.31 ± 5.29 n/kg. | [24] |
Chaohu lake, China | MPs in fish: 9.07 ± 5.89 n/ind during the rainy season. | [25] |
Poyang Lake, China | MPs in water: 5000–34,000 n/m3; MPs in sediments: 54–506 n/kg for sediments; MPs in fish digestive tracts: 0–18 n /ind. for wild crucians (Carassius auratus). | [26] |
Upper Thames River Ontario, Canada | MPs in fish digestive tracts: MPs were found in 44% of white suckers, ranging from 0 to 14 n/ind, and 31% of common carp, ranging from 0 to 128 n /ind | [10] |
Kumaraswamy Lake, Coimbatore, India, | MPs in water: 10,160 ± 3200 n/m3 (pre-monsoon), 11,330 ± 5500 n/m3 (monsoon), and 8910 ± 570 n/m3 (post-monsoon). | [7] |
Vellayani Lake, Kerala, India | MPs in water: 41,000 n/m3; MPs in sediments: 5.4 n/kg | [9] |
74 high-mountain lakes of Sierra Nevada, Spain | MPs in water: 300–21,300 n/m3. | [27] |
Two high-mountain lakes (Upper Lake Balma and Lower Lake Balma) in the Cottian Alps, Italy | No MPs were found in the water;MPs in sediments: 1.33 ± 0.67 n/m3 and 1.75 ± 0.62 n/m3 in Lower and Upper Lake Balma; MPs in fish digestive tracts: from the Lower (0.45 n/g GIT) than in those from the Upper Lake (0.20 n/g GIT) | [8] |
Lake Superior, Lake Huron, Lake Erie, North America | MPs in water: For Lake Superior, the range was 1277–12,645 n/km2; for Lake Huron, it was 0–6541 n/km2; and for Lake Erie, it was 4686–466,305 n/km2. | [19] |
White Iron Lake, USA | MPs in water: 152,000 ± 154,000 n/km−2; sediments: 30 ± 20 n/kg | [21] |
Ten Mile Lake, USA | MPs in water: 58,000 ± 23,000 n/km−2; sediments: 180 ± 130 n/kg |
Peltier Lake, USA | MPs in water: 110,000 ± 58,000 n/km−2; sediments: 270 ± 200 n/kg |
Elk Lake, USA | MPs in water: 27,000 ± 16,000 n/km−2; MPs in sediments: 80 ± 30 n/kg |
3.2. MP Composition and Temporal–Spatial Variations
This study observed the temporal–spatial variations in MP loads, highlighting the crucial need for a comprehensive assessment of MPs. Given the high variability in the physical and ecological characteristics of inland lakes, even within a specific region or basin type, accurately predicting MP loads is challenging. The samples in this study exhibited significant variability in repetitions, underscoring the necessity to consider factors such as size, shape, color, chemical composition, and season when discussing the temporal–spatial distribution patterns of MPs [
23].
When studying planktonic organisms in natural aquatic environments, they are typically classified into three categories based on size: microplankton (<50 μm), such as dinoflagellates and chrysophyceaes; small plankton (50–1000 μm), including diatoms and cyanobacteria; and mesoplankton (1000–5000 μm), such as copepods [
28]. The harm of MP pollutants to aquatic organisms mainly arises from the fact that MPs are easily mistaken for food and consequently enter the food chain. Therefore, when researching MPs, it is crucial to categorize and analyze them based on their sizes. In the water samples collected from Jingpo Lake, MPs are predominantly found in the size range corresponding to small plankton (50–1000 μm), exhibiting a proportion similar to that seen in fish and sediment samples (
Figure 2). This might be due to the propensity of MPs within this size range to stay in water and sediments, making them more susceptible to ingestion by fish and hence more prevalent in their digestive tracts. Different lower threshold values for MP size could also introduce variations in the observed MP concentrations. In a study by Peter et al. in Minnesota, it was revealed that smaller plastic particles were more likely to accumulate within sediments, suggesting that adopting a smaller value of size threshold could significantly elevate sediment concentrations [
21]. In the inflowing rivers to Taihu Lake, the primary MP particle size is <100 μm, while in the lake water and outflowing rivers, the predominant size range of MP particles is 100–200 μm. MPs smaller than 100 μm account for only 28% of the lake’s surface water, yet they significantly increase to 70% in the sediments. This indicates that smaller MPs might have a greater propensity to settle in the lake [
17]. In Lake Huron, MP microfibers constitute the major particle, comprising 50% of the total count (adjusted), with an average length of 1.2 mm. Fragments make up 30% of the total count, with average sizes ranging from 53 to 500 μm [
6]. In Finnish lakes, plastic fibers detected were larger than fragments in both water and sediment samples, with fiber sizes ranging from 1100 ± 230 μm to 1300 ± 120 μm. The size of plastic fragment detected in water samples were 430 ± 49 μm, while in sediment samples, they were 410 ± 38 μm. Nevertheless, no significant differences in MP size were observed between sampling sections [
29]. According to a study in 2013, the average abundance of MPs in the Laurentian Great Lakes was 43,157 n/km
2, with particles in the size range of 0.355–0.999 mm, accounting for 81% of the total particle count [
19].
Four different shapes of microplastics were detected in our research works; they are fragments, films, fiber, and microspheres (
Figure 2). Two sampling methods (Mann–Whitney U test,
p > 0.05) and the composition percentage of each shape for all sampling sections via each method indicated no significant differences (Kruskal–Wallis test,
p > 0.05). In the samples for Taihu Lake, fibers constitute the majority of MPs at 55.65% of the total count, followed by fragments (24.00%), films (11.57%), and microspheres (5.75%) (
Figure 3). The distribution of MP shapes in fish and sediment samples is similar to that of water samples. These observations are linked to coastal human activities: fibrous MPs commonly result from the weathering and breakdown of human-made items like clothing, ropes, and fishing nets. Fragmented MPs predominantly originate from the degradation of plastic waste, including construction materials and plastic bottles. Film-shaped MPs mainly arise from the disintegration of plastic products like shopping bags and agricultural films. Microspheres primarily come from consumer goods such as cosmetics and personal care items. In areas with limited coastal industrialization, everyday products become a significant source of MPs. In both the US Great Lakes and urban lakes in China, around half of the detected MPs are in the form of fibers. Regarding the MP forms found in Lake Superior’s sediments and water samples, the percentage of fibers in water samples (70%) is slightly higher than in sediment samples (52%). Among sediment samples, MPs primarily exist in fiber form (52%), followed by films (28%) and then fragments (18%) [
18]. In Lake Huron, North America, the majority of particles examined are microfibers (n = 257), followed by fragments (n = 88), while microspheres and films make up 13% and 7% of the remaining distribution, respectively. Only three sampling sections contained microspheres (n = 7) [
6]. In Finnish lakes, MP fibers in sediments (70%) are typically more abundant than those in water samples (40%). In contrast, regardless of the sample matrix, over 80% of MPs in blanks are fragments. Therefore, the concentration of MP fragments reported in both sample types is more likely to be influenced by contamination compared to the concentration of MP fibers. Differences in the relative proportion of MP shapes detected may arise from varying types of MP sources around the study locations, such as sewage treatment plants, littering, and fishing activities. However, due to the sampling, pre-processing, and identification methods employed, certain limitations in detecting specific MPs may exist, potentially contributing to variations [
29]. In Lake Rawaal, the majority of MPs are fragments (82%). The colors of MPs are diverse, with white/transparent and black MPs being common. Polypropylene is the predominant type of MPs in Lake Rawaal (40–74%) [
16].
Microplastic colors were detected separately using a stereomicroscope in our research work. Plastic products used in various industries often come in different types. For example, agricultural plastic films are typically transparent or white, while colored plastics such as black, blue, and yellow are commonly used in clothing. Plastic bags are usually white or transparent, but some regions and sectors also utilize blue, green, red, and other colors. For instance, in many of China’s seafood markets, black plastic bags are often preferred. Judging the source or use of microplastics solely based on their color is clearly too vague, but this method provides us with an idea before more precise traceability techniques are developed, but it still needs to be improved. Therefore, analyzing the colors of MPs can greatly assist in delving deeper into their sources and associated risks. MPs in water samples of Jingpo Lake are predominantly white or transparent, accounting for 55.65% of all MPs. Following these are black, red, and blue colors. The color distribution of MPs in fish and sediment samples is similar to that in the water samples (
Figure 3). MPs found in water samples of Lake Superior display a broader color spectrum compared to those found on beaches. The main colors of MPs in sediments and water samples are blue and pink [
21]. In Finnish lakes, both water samples (87%) and sediment samples (48%) exhibit the highest concentration of transparent and white MPs at each sampling section. Other prevalent colors include gray and blue. Due to sediment samples retaining more diverse substances on the filters, transparent and white MPs may be more easily overlooked compared to more vivid colors. Previous studies on MPs have not shown a distinct color trend, with common colors ranging from blue to white and transparent [
29].
MPs with different chemical compositions exhibit varying levels of toxicity and environmental hazards. Hence, when investigating MP pollution, scientists consider chemical composition as a crucial aspect. In Jingpo Lake, the predominant chemical compositions of MPs in water samples are Polyethylene (PE) (31.83%) and Polystyrene (PS) (25.48%), followed by polypropylene (PP) (17.56%), Polyamide (PA) (11.84%), polyethylene glycol terephthalate (PET) (6.71%),ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer (EVA) (4.56%), and Polycarbonate (PC) (2.03%) in descending order (
Figure 3). Other researchers have also identified PE, PP, and PS as the primary MP pollutants, followed by PP (17.56%). The proportion of MP chemical composition in fish and sediment samples resembles that in water samples. In Rawal Lake, Pakistan, MPs are mainly composed of PP, followed by low-density and high-density polyethylene (PE) [
23]. The major components of MPs identified in China’s third-largest lake, Taihu Lake, were determined to be polyvinyl chloride and PE [
17]. In Finnish lakes, among the 619 particles analyzed in water samples and 1194 particles in sediment samples, 89 and 210 particles were, respectively, identified as plastic. There are significant differences in the relative abundance of polymers detected in water and sediment samples. In the case of water samples, PP and Polyethersulfone (PES) are the most prevalent polymers, accounting for 33% and 29% of the MPs detected in sediment samples, respectively. PES covers 58% of the MPs detected, with PET being included in the count of PES. These findings align with the fact that polymers with densities significantly greater than 1 g/cm
3, such as PES, tend to sediment more readily compared to polymers with lower densities. The polymer composition remains relatively consistent across sampling sections, but certain polymers, like polyamide (PA) and PS, are only present in a few samples. Despite PA being commonly used in textiles, this study detected only one type of PA fiber [
30]. In Rewalsar Lake, the predominant polymers found in most MPs are polystyrene, PE, and PP polymers [
20].
It is essential to emphasize the significance of conducting MP sampling across representative timeframes and spatial scales. Giving special consideration to conducting multiple sampling sessions throughout each year can provide a more comprehensive understanding of the sensitivity of lakes to MP loads and whether such loads are consistent [
21]. Jingpo Lake’s MP contamination exhibits a certain degree of seasonality, with MP content in the water being higher during the summer (46.68%) compared to the spring (36.75%) and autumn (16.56%) (
Figure 3). The proportions of MP content in fish and sediment samples during different seasons closely resemble those found in water samples. The area surrounding Jingpo Lake experiences both agricultural and summer tourism activities. During the summer months, the population increases, and agricultural practices involving plastic films and other plastic products become more prevalent. The combination of precipitation and surface runoff transports a significant quantity of MPs into the lake, potentially contributing to the elevated MP content in the water during the summer [
23]. In Lake Superior, MP abundance per unit area was notably higher in samples of July 2018 (ranging from 18,000 to 40,000 n/km
2) compared to May samples (ranging from 9000 to 11,000 n/km
2) [
18]. MP content within the digestive tracts of fish was found to be higher during the spring sampling period than in summer and autumn. This trend may be due to the fact that spring is the breeding season for fish, when increased consumption of planktonic organisms could lead to the ingestion and accumulation of MPs of similar sizes in the fish’s digestive tracts. Furthermore, MPs tend to remain undigested within the digestive tract, resulting in prolonged retention. During the autumn sampling period, MP content in water samples, fish bodies, and sediments was relatively lower. In Kumaraswamy Lake of Coimbatore, India, MP concentrations were found to be higher at the lake’s outlet during the monsoon season (12.41 ± 0.41 n/L) and pre-monsoon season (11.16 ± 0.47 n/L). In the central area of the lake, MP concentrations were approximately 10.16 ± 0.32 n/L (pre-monsoon), 11.33 ± 0.55 n/L (monsoon), 8.91 ± 0.57 n/L (post-monsoon), and 6.083 ± 1.003 n/L (summer). MPs in Xinghu Lake exhibited concentrations of 247 ± 120.6 during the dry season and 273.1 ± 353.7 during the wet season, which are quite consistent with the findings of this study [
11]. Hassan et al.’s field experiment demonstrated that the lake’s hydrodynamics, influenced by changes in seasonal temperature, impacted the residence time and distribution of MPs in the mid-layer space during autumn. The retention time of MPs during lake turnover was significantly shorter than during the summer, likely due to turbulence in the water column. However, the understanding of MPs’ behavior in real lakes and their absorption probability by lake biota, including planktonic organisms, remains limited. Future research should quantitatively incorporate processes like heterogeneous aggregation and biofouling [
31]. In the surface water samples of Manipal Lake in southwest India, the seasonal occurrence and distribution of MPs were observed. The concentration of MPs was higher during the monsoon season (0.423 n/L) compared to the post-monsoon period (0.117 n/L). This situation is attributed to inflows from rainwater drains connected to the lake and surface runoff during periods of heavy rainfall [
22].
3.3. Analysis of Factors Influencing MP Abundance
MPs have been identified in samples from the surface water, sediments, and digestive tracts of fish at Jingpo Lake. Significant differences in MP concentrations exist among these three sample types, and notable spatial–temporal variations have been observed. These differences bear important ecological implications when assessing variations in MP loads across lakes and the potential impacts of MP pollution on these ecosystems. In this study, we place a strong emphasis on investigating these variations and their correlation with human activities (
Figure 4).
The utilization of the Pearson correlation coefficient for assessing the spatial distribution of MPs in Jingpo Lake’s water, fish, and sediments predominantly indicates human activity influence. The results demonstrate a strong correlation between the content of MPs in water, fish, and sediments and the indicators of NH4-N, TP, and Chla present in the water (
Figure 4a, α = 0.01). This suggests a homological relationship between MP pollution and the levels of NH4-N, TP, and Chla. Given that these three pollutants largely stem from domestic and waste pollution, it is plausible that MP contamination in Jingpo Lake originates from human sewage and waste. To validate this perspective, we scrutinized the impact of population density (
Figure 4b), land usage (
Figure 4c), and vegetation type (
Figure 4d) on MP abundance. The key human activities in the region around Jingpo Lake encompass agriculture, tourism, recreational boating, industry, and fishing. Grounded on concentration levels in sediments and water, the infusion of MPs is more pronounced along the lake’s periphery. Sites S1–S4 are in close proximity to human settlements, tourist docks, hotels, and related reception facilities, while S2, S3, S10, S11, and S12 are closer to agricultural land. Consequently, higher MP loads were observed at S1, S2, S3, S4, S10, S11, and S12 (
Figure 1). MPs have been detected in particle samples of surface water from all inland lakes in Minnesota, the USA. The study revealed the significant impact of land use and the level of lake development on MP loads within the lakes. Additionally, it highlighted the variability in MP loads and distribution within small inland lakes [
21]. Findings from research conducted in a mid-altitude lake in the NW Himalayas indicated a clear correlation between the intensity of human activities and MP abundance. The results suggested that sources like domestic sewage, high-intensity tourism, and surface runoff from residential areas could constitute major area sources of MP pollution, posing substantial threats to lake ecosystems. A study published examined the degree of MP pollution in several lakes across Minnesota, considering varying levels of watershed development and population density [
20]. The conclusions drawn from the MP concentrations detected in surface water and sediments, along with other environmental media, supported the hypothesis that watershed development and population density are critical factors influencing MP loads [
21]. A research revealed that the Great Lakes exhibit substantial spatial variability in plastic pollution within collected samples. Among the three lakes studied, Lake Erie, with the highest population, likely accounts for the consistently elevated counts of plastic pollution observed in all eight samples collected from this lake compared to the other lakes. Despite Lake Superior having the lowest population density among the three, all five samples collected from it were situated closer to the shoreline (and thus closer to pollution sources) than those from Lake Huron. This spatial proximity elucidates why the average MP counts in Lake Superior samples surpassed those in Lake Huron [
19]. Verónica et al. presented evidence suggesting that both natural factors and human activities influence the distribution and abundance of MPs. In their study, they examined the correlation between basin types and other geomorphic features (elevation, surrounding meadow area, basin type, and lake size), which could impact plastic pollution. Their findings indicated that the concentration of MPs was primarily associated with the extent of meadows encircling the lakes. This outcome implies an initial and significant linkage between the abundance of MPs and tourist activities. The variations in MP pollution among lakes are likely associated with materials brought by tourists, such as mountain gear, textiles, cosmetics, and recreational items, as evidenced by other lakes. Although the data do not establish a cause-and-effect relationship between tourists and MP quantities, it is noteworthy that lakes with 10 or more MPs per liter are situated along popular hiking routes [
29]. These findings also reinforce the reliability of our research results within the Jingpo Lake basin. The diversity of MP polymers in Xinghu Lake also highlights the intricate and diverse nature of pollution sources in urban lakes subjected to intense human activities. Overall, activities like urban expansion and economic growth have indeed exerted a significant influence on the substantial accumulation of MPs in urban lakes [
11]. The MP pollution in Vellayani Lake arises as a consequence of tourism and human interventions, encompassing activities such as fishing, the accumulation of waste near the lake shores, sediment weathering, and untreated sewage from these native regions. This MP contamination within lake environments has an impact on their prevalence in edible fish. The direct consumption of fish leads to the incorporation of MPs into the human body [
9]. The outcomes obtained from assessing MPs in lakes across the Nevada Mountains similarly lend support to the conclusions drawn in this study [
27].
3.5. Ecological Risk Assessment
When assessing the potential risks of MPs in aquatic environments, it is essential to consider risk assessment models that incorporate both MP polymer toxicity and MP abundance. A study conducted byintroduced polymer risk indices, revealing that MPs in Jingpo Lake predominantly consist of substances with low toxicity, as indicated by air toxicity indices below 10 (
Table 2) [
32]. To evaluate the environmental risks of MP pollution, three models are adopted in this study: the polymer hazard index (PHI), pollution load index (PLI), and potential ecological risk index (PERI), which were applied to assess MP pollution in water samples [
20,
33,
34]. The specific formulas for these models are as follows:
where
PHI represents the polymer hazard index,
Pn represents the percentage of each polymer at each sampling section, and
Sn denotes the toxicity score of the polymer.
The PLI is employed to assess the MP load at each site. It is correlated with the abundance of MPs, and its calculation formula is as follows:
where
CF represents the degree of MP contamination;
C signifies the MP abundance at each sampling section;
C0 stands for the background value, i.e., the level of MP abundance in the absence of contamination;
PLI corresponds to the MP load index for a specific site; and
n denotes the total number of sites. To facilitate the comparison of MP pollution risk across various regions, it is essential to determine a specific value for
C0. Due to the scarcity of available background data, this study opted for the lowest recorded MP abundance (106.7 n/L) as the background value. The classification standards for polymer toxicity scores and polymer risk indices are presented in
Table 3. Both the PHI and PLI are utilized to assess the potential risks of MPs in Jingpo Lake.
In addition to the PHI and PLI, the PERI primarily focuses on the quantitative analysis of pollutants. The PERI is a crucial method for assessing the potential ecological risks of pollutants in environmental media and finds widespread use in investigating various pollutants, such as heavy metals. The PERI can be considered a comprehensive assessment approach that combines both the PHI and PLI. Therefore, in this study, an enhanced version of the traditional PERI, as proposed by some researchers was adopted as a reference [
35]. The formulas are as follows:
where
Ci and
represent the concentrations of observed plastic polymers and background concentrations, respectively. The toxic coefficient (
) signifies the level of toxicity and biological sensitivity. This coefficient is calculated as the sum of the percentage of specific polymers in the total sample (
Pn/
Ci) multiplied by the hazard score (
Sn) of the plastic polymers. The assessment outcomes are classified into categories such as minor, medium, high, danger, and extreme danger based on the magnitude of the index (
Table 3).
Twelve sampling sections of Jingpo Lake are evaluated according to the criteria provided in
Table 3. The risk category of the PHI, PLI, and PERI are I, I, and minor, respectively (
Figure 6).
The values of the three risk assessment indicators are relatively low, which is attributed to the low toxicity of the MPs distributed within the Jingpo Lake basin. However, the results of the risk assessment demonstrate certain patterns. Sampling sections 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 11, and 12 exhibit higher risk indices, while the remaining five sampling sections present lower risks. This coherence is consistent with the results of the correlation analysis between the population, cultivated land distribution, and MP pollution at the sampling sections (
Figure 4b,c). Some study on Rewalsar Lake indicated that the concentration of certain MPs and associated compounds exceeded recommended environmental risk thresholds. The outcomes of this study underscore the necessity for implementing suitable waste management measures in the region to curtail the influx of these pollutants into the ecosystem. Furthermore, it is imperative to enhance monitoring to regulate the dissemination of emerging pollutants and their influence on the biota [
20]. As an urban lake in China, MPs in Xinghu Lake are mainly composed of PET, RY, PP, and PE. The ecological risk assessed using the PERI index is categorized as Level III [
11]. Similarly, for the urban river East Lake, the PLI in water samples is 0.66, and the sediment PLI is 1.89, indicating that over half of the sampling sections exhibit risks ranging from danger to extreme danger. The predominant chemical composition of MPs includes PET, PP, PE, and PVC [
5]. In southern India, Lake Manipal’s MPs are primarily composed of PET and CL. The risk level of MPs in the lake exhibits seasonal variation. During the monsoon period, the PLI of Lake Manipal is 1.62, which slightly decreases to 1.39 after the monsoon. PLI values consistently remain below 10, indicating a risk level of 1. For the Kodaikanalan Lake (freshwater) in India, the average PLI in sediments is 1.33, which can be classified as risk level I (<10), while the PHI is classified as risk level V (>1000) due to the presence of MPs made from PEU and PS. However, these current levels represent relatively minor ecological risks [
22]. In the case of Kumaraswamy Lake in Coimbatore, India, during the monsoon season, the PLI for MP contamination is higher at the lake’s outlet (1.15) and center (1.36) areas compared to the inlet (1.68) [
7]. Some researchers evaluated the risk index of MP pollution in Vellayani Lake, Kerala, in 2023. The results indicate the PLI of sediment: ND-3.87, PERI: ND-536, water PLI: ND-3.32, PERI: ND-516. The main components of MPs in the lake are PY, PP, PE, etc. [
9].