1. Introduction
Wide voltage range DC-DC converters have been discussed and presented for solar cell power conversion due to the variable output voltage of the photovoltaic panel. The output voltage of a photovoltaic panel depends on the solar intensity of the day and night. Therefore, DC converters with a wide voltage range are developed for solar power conversion and the self-supplying power units are developed for remote control systems. Wide voltage DC-DC converters are also needed on a railway vehicle due to many different nominal DC voltages (24 V~110 V) that are requested for the communication system, lighting system, electric door system and braking system. Thus, pulse-width modulation (PWM) converters with a wide voltage operation are welcomed and demanded on railway power supply units. Multi-stage converters [
1,
2] have been proposed to actualize the wide voltage capability operation. The buck or boost circuit topology is selected on the front-stage to achieve a buck or boost operation. The flyback, forward or half-bridge circuit topology with pulse-width modulation is adopted on the rear-stage to regulate output voltage. However, these solutions have high switching losses on power devices and the input voltage range is still limited at
Vin,max ≤ 4
Vin,min or
Vin,max ≤ 6
Vin,min. Series-parallel connection DC converters have been discussed in [
3,
4,
5]. Unfortunately, the circuit structure is too complicated and more expensive for use in low or medium power supplies. Single-stage DC converters with a PWM operation were discussed in [
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12] to extend the input voltage range. However, the input voltage range in [
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12] is still limited at
Vin,max ≤ 4
Vin,min. In [
13], the thermal constraints issue has been discussed for a current-mode monolithic DC-DC converter.
In this paper, we present and investigate a DC-DC converter that has a 16:1 (Vin = 288 V~18 V) wide voltage operation and soft switching turn-on operation. To realize a 16:1 wide voltage operation, a buck/boost DC-DC circuit is utilized in the first stage to accomplish either a voltage boost action if the Vin is on a low input voltage range (Vin,min < Vin < 4Vin,min) or a voltage buck action if the Vin is on a high input voltage range (4Vin,min < Vin < 16Vin,min). Therefore, the output terminal voltage of the buck/boost converter is controlled at a constant value. An LLC converter is used in the rear-stage to control the output voltage while accomplishing zero voltage switching (ZVS) for active devices. Since the input voltage of the LLC converter is almost constant due to the buck/boost converter regulation, the variation in switching frequency is limited to a narrow frequency range. Compared to conventional DC-DC converters and multi-stage converters, the main contributions in this paper are (1) the wide voltage range action, (2) the soft switching operation in the second stage circuit, and (3) the simple control scheme. The converter characteristics are confirmed by the experiments using a prototype circuit.
3. Operation Principle
The studied converter is a two-stage circuit. The front-stage is a buck/boost converter to achieve either a voltage boost action if Vin is on a low input voltage range or a voltage buck action if Vin is on a high input voltage range. The buck/boost converter is regulated by a pulse-width modulation. The second stage is an LLC resonant converter to accomplish both electric isolation and a ZVS turn-on operation for active devices.
3.1. Circuit Operation of the Buck/Boost Converter
The buck/boost converter can work at a voltage boost operation or buck operation. To accomplish a wide voltage operation, the DC bus voltage of the buck/boost converter is controlled at
Vdc = 4
Vin,min. When
Vin,min ≤
Vin < 4
Vin,min, the buck/boost converter operates at a boost operation (
Figure 2a)and
Q1 is on, diode
D1 is off and
Q2 is controlled by a pulse-width modulation to have a voltage boost action.
Figure 3a gives the PWM signals of the buck/boost converter for a voltage step-up action. Under a continuous conduction mode operation, two circuit modes are observed (
Figure 3b,c). Based on a voltage-second balance on the inductor
Lf, the DC bus voltage
Vdc is obtained as
dQ1Vin/(1 −
dQ2) =
Vin/(1 −
dQ2) where
dQ1 and
dQ2 are duty cycles of
Q1 and
Q2, respectively, and
dQ1 = 1 under the boost operation.
Mode 1 [t0~t0 + dQ2Tsw]: At t = t0, Q2 is activated to turn on. Since Q1 is always on and D1 is reverse biased for the voltage boost operation, the voltage across on Lf can be obtained as vLf = Vin and vD2 is −VDC. The inductor current iLf increases and the diode D2 is reverse biased. Capacitor Cdc is discharged to supply current idc to the secondstage resonant converter.
Mode 2 [t0 + dQ2Tsw~t0 + Tsw]: At t = t0 + dQ2Tsw, Q2 is turned off. The inductor iLf flows through D2 to charge Cdc. The inductor voltage vLf = Vin − Vdc < 0 so that iLf decreases. The drain-to-source voltage of Q2 is equal to the DC bus voltage Vdc. Mode 2 is ended at time t0 + Tsw.
When 4
Vin,min <
Vin ≤ 16
Vin,min, the buck/boost converter operates as a voltage step-down operation (
Figure 2b). The switch
Q2 is controlled at an off state, diode
D2 is always conducting and
Q1 is activated by pulse-width modulation to accomplish a voltage step-down. The pulse-width modulation waveforms of the voltage step-down operation are given in
Figure 4a and two circuit modes are shown in
Figure 4b,c under a continuous conduction mode. Based on a flux balance on inductor
Lf, the DC bus voltage
Vdc is calculated as
dQ1Vin/(1 −
dQ2) =
dQ1Vin where
dQ2 = 0 under the buck operation.
Mode 1 [t0~t0 + dQ1Tsw]: At time t0, Q1 turns on. Since Q2 is always off and D2 is forward biased for the voltage step-down operation, the inductor voltage vLf = Vin − Vdc > 0 and vD1 is −Vin. In this mode, iLf increases, the D1 is reverse biased and Cdc is charged.
Mode 2 [t0 + dQ1Tsw~t0 + Tsw]: At time t0 + dQ1Tsw, Q1 turns off. In mode 2, vLf = −Vdc, iLf decreases, vQ1,ds = Vin, vQ2,ds = Vdc and Cdc is discharged. This mode ends at time t0 + Tsw.
3.2. Circuit Operation of the LLC Resonant Circuit
Since the DC bus voltage
Vdc is a constant voltage due to the buck/boost circuit operation, the
LLC resonant converter is operated under almost constant voltage
Vdc. Thus, the switching frequency of the
LLC resonant circuit is controlled at a limited narrow frequency range. The converter voltage gain is calculated as
GLLC = 2
nVo/
Vdc = 2
nVo (1 −
dQ2)/
dQ1Vin.
Figure 5a gives the main circuit waveforms of the resonant converter and
Figure 5b–g shows the six mode operations.
Mode 1 [t0~t1]: At time t < t0, the active device S1 is off, vCS1 is positive and iLr is negative. At time t0, vCS1 = 0 and DS1 is conducting. After time t0, S1 can turn on at the ZVS action. Since Do1 is conducting, vLm = nVo. Power is delivered to a load side through the components S1, Lr, T, Cr and Do1. Lr and Cr are naturally resonant, with frequency . If fr is greater than the switching frequency fsw, then the circuit proceeds to mode 2, or it goes to mode 3.
Mode 2 [t1~t2]: Since fr > fsw, iDo1 will decrease to 0 at t1. Do1 is off. iLr will flow through S1, Lm, Lr and Cr. Together with Lr and Lm, Cr is naturally resonant, with frequency and fm < fr.
Mode 3 [t2~t3]: Active device S1 is turned off at time t2 under zero voltage. After time t2, iLr > 0 and iLr < iLm. Thus, CS2 (CS1) discharges (charges) and the secondary diode Do2 conducts.
Mode 4 [t3~t4]: At time t3, CS2 is discharged to zero and DS2 is conducting due to iLr(t3) > 0. After t3, S2 turns on under zero voltage. Do2 is forward biased on the secondary side, vLm = −nVo. Energy stored on Cr is transferred to the output load. Lr and Cr are naturally resonant, with frequency fr.
Mode 5 [t4~t5]: If fsw < fr, then iD2 will decrease to 0 at t4. Do2 is reverse biased. No power is delivered to the output load. Lr, Lm and Cr are naturally resonant, with frequency fm.
Mode 6 [t5~Tsw + t0]: S2 turns off at time t5. CS1 (CS2) discharges (charges) and Do1 conducts because the iLr(t5) < 0 and iLr(t5) > iLm(t5). Mode 6 ends at time Tsw + t0.
4. Circuit Characteristics
The buck/boost converter is operated by a 16:1 wide voltage range operation. The output voltage
Vdc of the buck/boost converter is controlled at
Vdc,ref = 4
Vin,min. If
Vin is on a low voltage range (
Vin <
Vdc,ref = 4
Vin,min), then the converter is operated at the boost operation. As a result,
Q1 stays on,
Q2 is operated by a duty cycle control and
D1 is reverse biased. When
Vin is on a high input voltage range (
Vin >
Vdc,ref = 4
Vin,min), the converter is operated at a buck operation. As a result,
Q2 stays off and
Q1 is operated by pulse-width modulation. Thus, the
LLC resonant circuit is operated at a constant input voltage of
Vdc = 4
Vin,min. The buck/boost converter is controlled at a continuous conduction mode. For the boost operation,
VLf =
Vin (or
Vin −
Vo) if
Q2 is on (or off) as shown in
Figure 3. For the buck operation,
VLf =
Vin −
Vo (or −
Vo) if
Q1 is on (or off) as shown in
Figure 4. For a continuous conduction mode, the DC bus voltage
Vdc is calculated as:
where
dQ1 and
dQ2 are duty cycles of
Q1 and
Q2, respectively.
Vin is greater than
Vin,min and less than 4
Vin,min on the low voltage range. Therefore, the maximum and minimum duty cycles of
Q2 are expressed as:
In the same manner, the maximum and minimum duty cycles of
Q1 are expressed as (4) and (5) on the high input voltage range (4
Vin,min <
Vin < 16
Vin,min).
If the DC bus current and
dQ1 and
dQ2 are given, then the root mean square (
rms) currents
IQ1,rms and
IQ2,rms are obtained in (6) and (7).
From the on/off states of
Q1,
Q2,
D1 and
D2, the voltage ratings of
Q1 and
Q2 are
Vin,max and
Vdc, respectively. The average currents
ID1 and
ID2 are obtained in (8) and (9).
Vin,max and
Vdc are the voltage ratings of
D1 and
D2 respectively. Based on the boost or buck operation, the
rms inductor current is calculated as:
The half-bridge resonant circuit is controlled with pulse frequency modulation. Since
S1 and
S2 have a 50% duty cycle, a square wave voltage waveform with 0 and
Vdc is generated on voltage
vab. The
rms value of
vab approximates
. According to the conducting states of
Do1 and
Do2, a square voltage waveform is generated on the magnetizing voltage
vLm and
. The fundamental primary-side resistance is calculated as
, where
Ro is the DC load resistance. Since the resonant tank (
Lm,
Cr, Lr and
Rac) is adopted in the rear-stage, in (11) the voltage transfer function of the resonant tank is obtained.
where
LB = Lm/
Lr,
and
fn =
fsw/
fr. Since the DC bus voltage
Vdc is regulated at
Vdc,ref by the front-stage buck/boost circuit, the switching frequency
fsw depends on
Io or
Ro. The
LLC resonant circuit is controlled at an inductive load. Therefore, active devices of the resonant circuit are operated using a soft switching operation.
5. Experimental Results
The studied circuit is tested and investigated to show the performance of the prototype circuit. The prototype is designed under the following specifications:
Vin = 288 V~18 V (16:1 ratio),
Vo = 12 V,
Po,rated = 500 W and
fr = 60 kHz. When
Vin = 18 V~65 V, the buck/boost converter is controlled at boost operation. The voltage
Vdc is maintained at 72 V. If the input voltage
Vin = 76 V~288 V, then the buck/boost converter is operated at a buck operation and the DC bus voltage
Vdc = 72 V. However, no voltage step-up or step-down is operated on the buck/boost converter when 65 V <
Vin < 76 V.
Q1 (
Q2) is on (off) under this condition and
Vdc =
Vin. Therefore, the resonant circuit is designed under the input of a DC bus voltage
Vdc = 65 V~76 V. Two Schmitt voltage comparators are used to detect the three input voltage ranges 18 V~65 V, 65 V~76 V and 76 V~288 V. If
Vin is on a low voltage range (18 V~65 V),
Q2 is controlled by a duty cycle scheme to achieve a boost operation. The duty cycle of
Q2 is calculated in (12) and (13) under continuous conduction mode.
For a high input voltage range of 76 V~288 V,
Q1 is controlled by a duty cycle scheme to achieve a buck operation. The duty cycle of
Q1 is given in (14) and (15) under continuous conduction mode.
It is assumed that the ripple current Δ
iLf is 5% of the maximum input current at 18 V of input voltage. Therefore, inductance
Lf is given in (16).
The
rms switch currents
IQ1,rms and the
IQ2,rms are expressed in (17) and (18).
The voltage ratings of
Q1 and
Q2 are
Vin,max = 288 V and
Vdc,max = 76 V. Switch
Q1 used two MOSFETs STB35N60DM2 (STMicroelectronics, Geneva, Switzerland) with 600 V/28 A ratings, while switch
Q2 adopted MOSFET IRFB4110PbF (Infineon Technologies, Neubiberg, Germany) with 100 V/120 A ratings. The average diode currents of
D1 and
D2 are obtained in (19) and (20).
D1 has a voltage stress of Vin,max = 288 V and D2 has a voltage stress of Vdc,max = 76 V. SF1006G (TSMC, Hsinchu, Taiwan) and STPS20SM100S (STMicroelectronics, Geneva, Switzerland) with 400 V/10 A and 100 V/20 A ratings are used for diodes D1 and D2, respectively.
For the
LLC resonant circuit design, the necessary resonant frequency and inductor ratio are selected as
fr = 60 kHz and
LB = 8. The minimum, nominal and maximum DC bus voltages are 65 V, 72 V and 76 V, respectively. The nominal voltage gain of
Gnom at
Vdc,nom = 72 V is designed at unity. Therefore, the turn-ratio
n of the transformer is calculated as follows.
The TDK EER42 with
ns = 4 and
np = 12 is used for the transformer
T. Thus, the voltage gains
GLLC,max and
GLLC,min at
Vdc = 65 V and 76 V are calculated in (22) and (23).
For full rated power, the fundamental primary-side resistance
Rac is obtained in (24).
The selected quality factor
Q is 0.7. From the given
Q,
Rac and
fr, the resonant inductance
Lr is obtained as:
due to
LB = 8,
Lm =
LB ×
Lr = 31.2 μH.
Cr can be calculated as:
The voltage ratings of S1 and S2 equal Vdc,max = 76 V and the voltage rating of diodes Do1 and Do2 equals 2Vo = 24 V. Power switches IPP111N15N3 (150 V/83 A) are adopted for active devices S1 and S2 and S60SC6M (60 V/60 A) (Shindengen Electric Manufacturing, Tokyo, Japan) switches are selected for Do1 and Do2. The selected Cdc = 680 μF and Co = 1000 μF. UC3843 (Texas Instruments, Dallas, TX, USA) is selected to regulate the buck/boost circuit while the UCC25600 (Texas Instruments, Dallas, TX, USA) is adopted to regulate the LLC resonant circuit.
Figure 6 illustrates the experiments of the presented converter at
Vin = 18 V and the rated power. Since
Vin = 18 V <
Vdc = 72 V, the buck/boost converter is operated at a boost operation. Therefore,
Q1 is on and
Q2 is controlled by the duty cycle modulation.
Figure 6a shows the experimental waveforms of
vQ2,g,
iLf,
iQ2 and
iD2. When
Q2 is on or off, the
iLf equals
iQ2 or
iD2.
Figure 6b provides the test results of the input voltage
Vin, dc bus voltage
Vdc, the gate voltage
vQ2,g and leg voltage
vab. The duty cycle of
Q2 equals 0.75,
Vdc >
Vin (boost operation) and the leg voltage
vab is a square voltage.
Figure 6c gives the primary-side experimental waveforms of the
LLC resonant circuit at full load. As the switching frequency is close to the resonant frequency,
vCr and
iLr are sinusoidal waveforms and
vab is a square waveform. Since the half-bridge
LLC is controlled in the second stage, the
vCr contains a DC voltage value (
vCr,dc =
Vdc/2).
Figure 6d provides the secondary side currents and load voltage at full load. The output voltage is regulated at 12 V and the load current
Io = 42 A. No serious reverse recovery current is observed on the rectifier diodes
Do1 and
Do2. In the same manner,
Figure 7 illustrates the experiments at
Vin = 65 V and the rated power conditions. Since
Vin = 65 V <
Vdc = 72 V, the duty cycle of
Q2 is calculated as 0.1. The measured waveforms
vQ2,g,
iLf, iQ2 and
iD2 are shown in
Figure 7a. The experimental waveforms
Vin,
Vdc,
vQ2,g and
vab are illustrated in
Figure 7b. The experimental waveforms of the resonant converter are provided in
Figure 7c,d. Since
Vdc = 72 V by the buck/boost converter for both
Vin = 18 V and 65 V, it can be seen that the measured waveforms of the resonant converter under
Vin = 18 V (
Figure 6c,d) and
Vin = 65 V (
Figure 7c,d) are identical.
Figure 8 and
Figure 9 show the experiments of the proposed circuit for
Vin = 76 V and 288 V input on the high input voltage range and rated power. When the input voltage ranges between 76 V and 288 V, the buck/boost circuit is controlled at a buck operation and
Q2 is off. The duty cycle of
Q1 equals 0.95 (0.25) at
Vin = 76 V (288 V). The measured waveforms of
vQ1,g,
iLf,
iQ1 and
iD1 at
Vin = 76 V and 288 V are illustrated in
Figure 8a and
Figure 9a. The buck/boost converter is operated at a buck operation and
Vdc is controlled at 72 V for both
Vin = 76 V and
Vin = 288 V. The experiments of the resonant converter for a 76 V (288 V) input are shown in
Figure 8c,d (
Figure 9c,d). When 65 V <
Vin < 76 V,
Q1 is on and
Q2 is off. No voltage step-up or step-down is realized on the buck/boost converter so that the DC bus voltage
Vdc =
Vin. Under this condition, only the resonant converter is worked to regulate the load voltage.
Figure 10 and
Figure 11 provide the measured waveforms of the resonant circuit at 67 V and 74 V input and the rated power. When
Vdc = 67 V, the resonant converter needs more voltage gain compared to
Vdc = 72 V and
fsw <
fr. Thus,
iLr likes a quasi-sinusoidal signal in
Figure 10a and
Do1 and
Do2 are turned off at zero current switching in
Figure 10b. In the same manner, the switching frequency at
Vdc = 74 V shown in
Figure 11 is greater than the resonant frequency in order to achieve a lower voltage gain.
Figure 12 illustrates the experiments of
S1 at
Vin = 18 V, 67 V, 74 V and 288 V.
Figure 12a,b shows the experimental waveforms of
S1 under 20% load and full load at
Vin = 18 V condition. In the same manner,
Figure 12c,d gives the measured results of
S1 at 67 V input.
Figure 12e,f provides the test results of
S1 at 74 V input. Likewise,
Figure 12g,h shows the experimental waveforms of
S1 at 288 V input (high input voltage range). From the test results in
Figure 12, it can be seen that
S1 turns on at ZVS from a 20% load for all input voltage ranges and turns off at hard switching. Since switch
S2 possesses the same switching characteristics as
S1, it can be expected that
S2 also turns on under zero voltage from a 20% load and turns off at hard switching.