Equilibrium Approximating and Online Learning for Anti-Jamming Game of Satellite Communication Power Allocation
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
In this paper an anti-jamming solution for satellite communications is explored, in the context of equilibrium approximation, focusing on the multi-channel power optimization scenario.
Proofing: the manuscript requires thorough language and grammar proofing before publication. Indicative comments:
- line 15: …problem into an on line shortest…
- line 20: …problem formed in confrontation…
- line 70: …very serious, therefore it is of great significance…
- line 78: …it is not necessary for the communication parties…
- line 80: …in this case is to minimize…
- line 90: sentence should break into at least two sentences in order to convey its meaning correctly
- line 110: …works on multi-channel…
- line 134: …each round of interaction…
- line 138: …When a participant allocates…
- line 142: …are almost limitless…
- line 165: …scenario belongs…
- line 167: …and dynamically learn and…
- …
- line 512: …mainly models and solves…
- line 520: …into an online shortest…
The paper is well structured with adequately backed formulations and illustrations. Although this work is sufficiently complete as is, the content could be further enhanced with a short talk of whether the solutions presented could be implemented and adopted as ‘in-the-box’ solutions, that is if they could be deployed in current (existing) satellite systems or are ‘out-of-the box’ ideas that could only be integrated from scratch in the comm systems of future satellite systems. Adding to the previous suggestion, a short complexity analysis of the algorithmic solution in order to indicate if real-time operation is possible would be a welcome enhancement.
Concerning the mathematical formulation in eq. (2), the W^k parameter is not defined.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
To authors.
I'm happy to review your valuable paper.
Here are some comments after reviewing your paper.
1. Jamming method
- Recently, the partial band jammer and AWGN jammer have been popular in satellite communication because of the simple way to degrade SNR for HTS based on DVB-RCS/S2
- I'm wondering why authors consider the frequency hopping jammer instead of partial and noise jammers.
2. Theoretical analysis
- In order to verify the suggested Do-SINR, authors should provide the theoretical derivation process to reviewers such as supplements to help reviewers understand.
3. Experiment
- I strongly suggest that the authors should add the practical experiment result to verify the suggested algorithm.
- It is hard to understand the proposed algorithm to work in a practical satellite environment.
Thanks.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
To authors.
Thank you for your revising.