1. Introduction
Plant–arthropod interactions are thought of as an important question in ecological research, which can provide insight into the dynamics of ecological communities and the mechanisms that shape interactions in complex food webs [
1,
2]. Plant–arthropod interactions can be markedly shaped by bottom-up forces, which are affected by abiotic factors and can in turn influence the performance of insect herbivores [
1,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7]. Plant nutrients could impact the performance of herbivorous insects via changes in plant quality in terms of nutritional and defensive aspects and determine bottom-up effects on plant–insect herbivore interactions. Among the plant nutritional factors that influence the performance of insect herbivores to a crop is total nitrogen [
8,
9,
10].
Due to a large difference in nitrogen content between herbivorous insects and plant tissues, the nitrogen-containing nutrients of host plants are frequently considered as a limiting resource for the population development of herbivore insects [
11]. The nitrogen content of plants is often regulated by nitrogen fertilizer application [
11]. Insufficient nitrogen input to plants was shown to impair the performance of herbivore insects, which was termed the “nitrogen limitation hypothesis” [
5,
12]. The harmful effects on the performance of herbivorous insects may be caused by the accumulation of high plant allelochemicals and toxic substances found on nitrogen-deficient plants [
4,
5,
10]. Nitrogen-rich plants have positive effects on herbivore insects’ performance, probably owing to deposition-induced improvements in host plant chemistry, which can significantly affect the structure and nutrition of plants [
13,
14,
15]. Most current studies have shown support for the ‘‘nitrogen limitation hypothesis” [
16,
17,
18]. However, several studies show that the development and survival of herbivore insects could respond negatively to nitrogen inputs to host plants, which undermined the generality of the “nitrogen limitation hypothesis” [
19,
20,
21,
22].
Rice (
Oryza sativa L.) is one of the top five carbohydrate crops for the world’s human population, especially in Asia. It is a major staple food, which supports more than three billion people and represents 50% to 80% of their daily calorie intake [
23]. Part of the progress in rice production has resulted from a large amount of chemical fertilizer input, especially nitrogen (N) [
24]. Low soil nitrogen level, especially in depleted croplands, is considered a major limitation for the growth of rice [
16]. Therefore, the intensive use of nitrogen fertilizer has been a common approach for pursuing higher crop yields, and nitrogen application in rice production has shown a gradually increasing trend, as high as 350 kg/ha in many Asian regions, exceeding the reasonable amounts of 150 to 250 kg/ha [
25,
26]. However, rice is attacked by about 800 species of insect pests in the field and postharvest storage [
27]. The white-backed planthopper,
Sogatella furcifera (Horváth) (Hemiptera: Delphacidae), one of the most destructive migratory pests of rice, poses a substantial threat to rice production. Notably, Zhou et al. [
28] found that the infestation ratio of
S. furcifera was higher in paddies with high nitrogen fertilizer application. However, how high nitrogen fertilization level leads to high
S. furcifera infestation and the nutritional interactions between rice and
S. furcifera are poorly understood.
In the present study, we hypothesize that rice subjected to varying nitrogen inputs may trigger bottom-up effects on behavior as well as population fitness of S. furcifera. To test our hypothesis, we set up a trophic “rice-planthopper” system to carry out a series of bioassays under laboratory conditions, including (1) feeding and oviposition preferences of S. furcifera, (2) the life parameters of S. furcifera, (3) the physical and physiological indexes of rice, and (4) the relationships between behavior preferences, life parameters of S. furcifera, and physical and physiological indexes of rice with different nitrogen fertilizer applications. With these, we provide an insight into how excess nitrogen fertilization shapes rice–planthopper nutritional interactions and the consequent potential positive effect on S. furcifera infestation. Furthermore, these results may help to optimize the integrated pest management (IPM) of S. furcifera by nitrogen fertilizer manipulation.
3. Discussion
In the present study, our results demonstrated that variation of nitrogen input to rice plants significantly affected the behaviors and life performance of S. furcifera. We found that: (1) higher nitrogen fertilizer application to rice plants increased the feeding and oviposition preferences of adults, and (2) nitrogen fertilizer application extended the adults’ longevity and shortened the generation reproduction time of S. furcifera. These results indicated that altered nitrogen inputs to rice plants trigger a bottom-up effect on the biological traits of S. furcifera and then may explain the high infestation ratio of rice paddies with high nitrogen fertilizer by S. furcifera. The physical and physiological indexes change in host plants further explained the effects on the biological traits of S. furcifera. Nitrogen fertilizer application increased physical indexes (including plant height, leaf area, and leaf width) and physiological indexes (including chlorophyll content, water content, dry matter mass, and soluble protein content) in rice.
To understand insect behaviors, it is necessary to predict and prevent insect infestation outbreaks [
29]. Feeding behavior is the first stage of acquiring nutrients for herbivorous insects, which is the foundation for a series of physiological activities to maintain the insect population. Oviposition behavior, the last stage of an herbivore’s life cycle, has a crucial influence on the nutrition of the next-generation larvae [
30,
31,
32]. Host orientation is a process by which organisms select host plants with potential nutritional resources, and it plays an important role in the process of feeding and oviposition [
1]. In this study, nitrogen input to rice increased the feeding and oviposition preference of
S. furcifera adults (
Figure 1), especially in high nitrogen (N250, 350). In other words, excessive nitrogen fertilization favors the colonization of
S. furcifera, which in turn leads to a high infection rate in the paddy. We assumed that the rice plant quality was improved under nitrogen input, thus causing the behavior preference. Indeed, we found that the physical and physiological parameters of rice were improved with nitrogen fertilizer applications (
Table 5 and
Table 6). In particular, there was a significant correlation between the rice chlorophyll content (SPAD) and feeding preference after nitrogen application (
Table 7). The chlorophyll content was positively correlated with nitrogen content and could be regarded as an indicator of the nitrogen content of plants [
33]. Therefore, the nitrogen content of rice plants plays an important role in the feeding orientation of
S. furcifera adults. Similarly, the leaf area, leaf width, and soluble protein content may play more important roles in oviposition orientation. In addition, most insects rely on olfactory cues to determine their host orientation [
34]. We assumed that volatile organic compounds (VOCs) changed under nitrogen input, thus causing the behavior preference of
S. furcifera. For example, tomato plants released less volatiles and increased the preference of
Bemisia tabaci after high-nitrogen treatment [
35].
For herbivorous insects, nitrogen plays a role in plant–herbivore interactions and the insects’ development. Nitrogen fertilizer application on host plants not only influences many aspects of the behavior of herbivorous insects [
36], but also impacts consumer survival, development rates, and fecundity by bottom-up effects after colonization [
37,
38]. The complete development of herbivorous insects depends on whether they obtain sufficient nutrients from the host plants [
39,
40]. In our study, nitrogen inputs positively affect
S. furcifera survival and development (
Table 1). In other words, excessive nitrogen fertilization favors the survival and development of
S. furcifera. Furthermore, the rice nutrients (including chlorophyll content, water content, dry matter mass, and soluble protein content) were significantly increased in high nitrogen. Organic nitrogen (including amino acids and proteins) is considered as a limiting nutrient factor for herbivorous insects. When herbivorous insects feed on nitrogen-deficient plants, their metabolism can be reduced or impaired during the critical growth period [
5,
8]. Here, the developmental duration of
S. furcifera egg and nymph had significant negative correlations with rice chlorophyll content (SPAD) and soluble protein content (
Table 7). Therefore, we suggest that chlorophyll content (SPAD) and soluble protein content were key regulated factors influencing
S. furcifera. Besides, it is worth noting that under nitrogen fertilizer, the water content has a significant correlation with all life parameters of
S. furcifera. Similarly, Han et al. [
5] reported that
Tuta absoluta had a lower survival rate and longer development time when fed on the host plants subjected to drought. We assumed that
S. furcifera had difficulty in obtaining enough water for optimal development, thus causing a slow development when fed on the nitrogen-deficient rice plants. In addition, we found that the development time of
S. furcifera from egg to first oviposition did not significantly shorten when fed on N150–N350 rice plants. Similar results were found in
Aphis gossypii [
41] and
Trialeurodes vaporariorum [
42]. The total pre-oviposition period of
T. vaporariorum was not significantly different fed on a nitrogen concentration of more than 310 ppm in the nutrient solution of the tomato plants [
42]. We assumed that the
S. furcifera may excrete excess nutrients from its body when they fed on N150–N350 rice plants [
43].
Mechanical barriers can reduce herbivores’ ingestion performance, as they increase plant resistance [
44]. Zheng et al. [
45] reported that
Laodelphax striatellus preferred to feed on rice with a large leaf area. In this study, we found that the plant height, leaf area, and leaf blade width of rice significantly increased after nitrogen fertilizer application, which may help the
S. furcifera to select its optimal host. Besides, leaf thickness is related to a decline in the ingestion ability of sap-sucking insects [
46,
47,
48]. For example,
Aphis gossypii needed to spend more time penetrating thick cotton leaves, which resulted in reduction of feeding efficiency [
49]. Similarly, the penetration of mature lemon leaves by
Parabemisia myricae nymphs appeared to be inhibited by cuticle thickness [
50]. In this study, we found that there was a negative correlation between the leaf thickness and the levels of nitrogen fertilizer application in rice. We suggest that the leaf thickness of rice decreases after nitrogen fertilizer application, and it reduces the mechanical barrier on ingestion by
S. furcifera. Therefore,
S. furcifera can get more nutrition from high-nitrogen plants, which subsequently favors the survival and development of
S. furcifera.
Adult life expectancies significantly increased when raised on rice with nitrogen fertilizer application, showing a positive correlation between adult lifespan and nitrogen fertilizer application. The times causing 50% and 90% adult cumulative mortality were extended for
S. furcifera in the rice with high nitrogen fertilizer application (
Table 4). Huang and Feng [
51] found that
S. furcifera adults consume more than nymphs, indicating that the adult stage was the most harmful period for rice. Our results suggest that nitrogen input may extend the adult lifespan and thus cause a longer rice infestation time, which may be one of the reasons why the rice with high-nitrogen fertilizer application experienced more damage than the one with low application [
52]. In addition, the rice with high-nitrogen fertilizer application shortened the length of the nymph, pre-oviposition, and egg stages, thus shortening the life cycle of
S. furcifera, however, increasing fecundity and total populations. Therefore, this may be another reason for the high infestation rate of
S. furcifera populations in the paddy with high-nitrogen fertilizer.
To conclude, we suggest that nitrogen input to rice improves plant quality (physiological and physical indexes) and further facilitates the colonization, survival, and development of
S. furcifera. Our findings support the “plant vigor hypothesis”, that vigorous plants are the best and preferred host plants for herbivore insects [
5,
53].
Insufficient nitrogen input to plants triggered negative bottom-up effects on
S. furcifera, which was consistent with the “nitrogen limitation hypothesis” [
54,
55]. Manipulating nitrogen fertilization inputs could help to optimize agronomic practices against herbivore pests [
7]. This method could gain optimal ecological and economic benefits based on a little damage to plants and negligible crop yield losses. Based on a complex agronomic database covering a wide range of climate conditions, soil types, and field managements, Che et al. [
56] found that in most rice-growing areas, rice grain yield with nitrogen inputs of 200–250 kg/ha was higher than other nitrogen rate inputs. Here, the preference of infestation behaviors (feeding and oviposition), the infestation time (adult lifespan), and generation reproduction time (nymph, pre-oviposition, and egg period) of
S. furcifera in 200 kg/ha nitrogen input were sub-optimal compared to high-nitrogen inputs (250 and 350 kg/ha). Therefore, we propose 200 kg/ha nitrogen input as an optimal fertilizer level in rice field managements since this will create a win-win situation. Moreover, rice cultivars that are tolerant to nitrogen-deficiency stress were deliberately selected in breeding, underpinning agronomic leverage for IPM packages against
S. furcifera by the bottom-up effect.
4. Materials and Methods
4.1. Preparation of Soil with Various Fertility Levels
Soil for planting the rice plants was obtained from the fields at the Yangtze University Experimental Station for Crop Pests (30°35′50″ N, 112°14′77″ E) in Hubei, China. To prepare the planting soil with specific fertility levels, the dry soil was mixed with urea fertilizer (soluble nitrogen ≥ 46.4%, Hubei Sanning Chemical Co., Ltd., Zhijiang, China) at the rate of 0, 50, 150, 200, 250, and 350 kg/ha. This converted to 0, 0.033, 0.098, 0.131, 0.164, or 0.229 g urea respectively, mixed with 456.50 cm3 dry soil to fill each pot (diameter 7 cm, height 14 cm). Thirty pots for each of the above six fertility levels were prepared for planting rice, and a batch of 180 pots was prepared every 10 days to ensure enough pots were available for planting rice plants for the experiment.
4.2. Rice Plants’ Preparation for Nitrogen Treatments
Germinated rice seeds of the variety Taichung Native 1 (TN1), susceptible to S. furcifera, were individually planted (one seed per pot) in each prepared pot already filled with soil amended with fertilizer. Thirty single-seed pots were prepared and repeated every ten days, for each fertility level, to ensure enough rice plants for the experiment, and they were then kept in cages, measuring 60 × 80 × 60 cm3, under laboratory conditions (26 ± 1 °C, 70–80% RH, and 14 h light). Seeded pots were watered as needed and the water level was kept below the upper edge of each pot. Pesticides were not used on the rice plants throughout the experiment. The rice plants grown from the six fertility levels were called N0, N50, N150, N200, N250, and N350 rice, respectively. The rice plants were used in the experiments, 35 days after transplanting (DAT).
4.3. Insects
A colony of S. furcifera was kindly provided by Dr. Hou of the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences. To maintain and increase the test insect population, they were reared on the N0 rice plants without exposure to any insecticide. The rice plants were enclosed in 80-mesh screen cages (30 × 30 × 60 cm3) placed in a climate-controlled rearing room with 26 ± 1 °C, 70 ± 5% RH, and a photoperiod of 14L:10D.
Under the same conditions mentioned above, S. furcifera was also reared on N50, N150, N200, N250, and N350 rice plants in order to obtain test insects that were reared at various nitrogen fertility levels. Newly hatched nymphs (<24 h) and newly emerged adults (<24 h) were used in the experiments, except where otherwise specifically noted.
4.4. Feeding and Oviposition Preferences
To prepare for the experiment testing rice nitrogen levels on the feeding and oviposition preference of S. furcifera, one 35 DAT potted rice plant from each of the six nitrogen levels (N0, N50, N150 N200, N250, and N350) was randomly selected to be included in the test. The selected rice plants, 6 in total, were trimmed such that only the main stem remained in each pot. Then, the cleaned 6 potted rice plants were placed within a cage (30 × 30 × 60 cm3, made of iron wire frame and covered with 80-mesh nylon netting) and randomly arranged in a circular shape.
Thirty newly emerged macropterous adults (<24 h, 15 females and 15 males) from the S. furcifera colony reared on N0 rice plants were released from a 9 cm Petri dish placed into the center of the cage. After 96 h from release, the number of adults on each of the 6 plants was recorded, and the feeding preferences of each nitrogen fertility level were expressed as a percent of the adults settling on a specific plant. The feeding preference was calculated as: Feeding preference = The number of adults settling on a specific fertilizer level plant/Total number of tested adults × 100. This experiment was repeated 5 times and for each repetition, the location of the plants in the cage was rotated to avoid the effect of other factors.
The same arrangement was used to observe the adult’s oviposition preferences. Fifteen pairs of newly emerged macropterous adults from the S. furcifera colony reared on N0 rice plants were released for the oviposition preferences test. The experiment was replicated 5 times. After that, the number of first instars emerging and unhatched egg on a specific plant to count the total number of eggs laid. The leaf midribs and leaf sheaths of each nitrogen level rice were dissected under a binocular microscope to count the unhatched egg. The tests were performed in a climate chamber (RZH-260A, Hangzhou Huier Instrument Equipment Co., Ltd., Hangzhou, China) at 26 ± 1 °C, 70 ± 5% relative humidity (RH), and a photoperiod of 14L:10D. The oviposition preference was calculated as: Oviposition preference = The number of eggs laid on a specific fertilizer level plant/Total number of eggs laid × 100.
4.5. Life Parameters
A 4 cm-long rice leaf section cut from the top third or fourth leaf, starting 5 cm away from the leaf tip of a 35 DAT potted rice plant receiving a fertility treatment, was placed in a glass tube (1.0 cm in diameter, 7.5 cm in height) filled with 1 mL water. Then, one first instar nymph (<24 h) reared from the N0 rice plants was transferred into the glass tube and the opening was sealed with a sponge to prevent escape. The leaf section in the glass tube was replaced daily with a freshly cut leaf section from the same fertility treatment. Using the same procedure, rice leaves from all 6 fertility levels were prepared to evaluate the host’s impact on the life parameters of S. furcifera. All glass tubes containing rice leaf sections and individual nymphs were kept in a climate chamber at 26 ± 1 °C, 70 ± 5% RH, and a photoperiod of 14:10 (L:D) h. The nymphs’ developmental stage and mortality were recorded daily until they died or became adults, and the emerged adults were then sexed. The observation of nymphal survival was repeated at least 50 times for each of the 6 fertility levels.
The effects of nitrogen fertility on the longevity of newly emerged adults (<24 h) reared from the N0 rice plants were evaluated using the same arena and method as those for the nymphs, except that the newly emerged adults were transferred into the glass tubes at the beginning of the experiment. The longevity observation was replicated at least 35 times for each of the 6 fertility levels, and the ratio of males to females tended to be 1:1.
Newly emerged adult males and females (<24 h) reared from the rice plants of a fertility level were paired, and they were transferred into a glass tube (5 cm in diameter, 40 cm in height) housing a single 35 DAT rice plant of fertility treatment. The top of the glass tube was sealed with a sponge. The rice plant was replaced daily with a new plant from the same fertility treatment. Similar setups were prepared for all 6 fertility treatments. These experimental setups were used to observe the pre-oviposition and egg development periods. The observation of pre-oviposition was replicated four times for each treatment, with one pair of adults as a replicate. The egg developmental period observation was replicated at least 48 times, for each fertility treatment, with 1 egg as a replicate. The tests were performed in a climate chamber at 26 ± 1 °C, 70 ± 5% relative humidity (RH), and a photoperiod of 12L:12D.
4.6. Rice Physical Parameters
The above-ground heights of 35 DAT rice plants were measured, using a ruler, for 10 rice plants from each fertility level. To obtain the blade thickness and leaf areas, the following procedures were performed. From the main stem of a 35 DAT potted rice plant, the third leaf from the top was chosen. A 5 cm-long rice leaf section from the leaf tip was cut and discarded. Another 5 cm-long rice leaf section was cut from the same leaf and then weighed and photographed individually. The images were analyzed using the Image-Pro Plus v6.0 software to obtain the areas of the leaf blade sections. The leaf blade thickness was expressed as the weight per unit area (mg/cm
2) according to Luo et al. [
46]. The leaf blade width was calculated as Blade width = Blade area/Blade length. Four 5 cm leaf blade sections from the rice plants of each fertility treatment were used to obtain the blade area, thickness, and width data. All tests were replicated 10 times for each fertility treatment.
4.7. Rice Physiological Parameters
The chlorophyll content was positively correlated with nitrogen content and can be regarded as an indicator of the nitrogen content of plants [
33]. The rice leaf tissue chlorophyll content was assessed using an electronic portable chlorophyll meter (SPAD-502, Minolta camera Co., Osaka, Japan) and expressed as the SPAD value. The mean of three SPAD readings measured by the chlorophyll meter was obtained from each of the top third leaves of ten 35 DAT rice plants of various fertility levels from 9:00 to 10:00 a.m. The tests were performed in a glasshouse, under natural light and temperature conditions, and repeated 10 times for each fertility treatment.
To obtain water content, the main stems from ten 35 DAT rice plants for each fertility level were cut from the base flush with the soil and weighed individually. These stems were immediately placed in an oven at 110 °C for 30 min and then at 80 °C for 48 h (when constant weight was achieved). The tests were repeated 5 times in each fertility treatment. The water content was calculated as: Water content = (Fresh weight − Dry weight)/Fresh weight × 100. The dry weight was regarded as dry matter mass.
The concentration of the soluble protein of 35 DAT rice plant leaves of various fertility levels was determined using the Coomassie Blue method [
57], with bovine serum albumin as a standard, and the absorbance of the samples was measured at 595 nm using the UV-VIS Spectrophotometer. This procedure was repeated 5 times in each fertility treatment.
4.8. Statistical Analysis
The adult mortality ratio (Adult mortality ratio = Larval mortality/Total number of tested larvae × 100) in all the rice of the six nitrogen levels (N0, N50, N150, N200, N250, and N350) tested was transformed to probability units and analyzed using the logistic regression (Y = A/(1 + Exp (b − k X))), where X is the feeding days in each rice of different nitrogen levels and Y is the adult mortality ratio in probability units. The feeding days and adult mortality ratio data were fitted using probability analysis to estimate the number of feeding days that induced death in 50% and 90% of adults, respectively.
Percentage data (including feeding and oviposition preference, water content) were arcsine square-root-transformed, and all data fit normal distributions. Then, the homogeneity of variance of all data was tested before one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). All data were subjected to ANOVA, followed by the least significant difference (LSD) multiple range test (p < 0.05) for determining the significant differences between the treatments. We investigated the relationships between S. furcifera and rice responses to nitrogen fertilizer application, and the relationships were then tested using the Pearson correlation coefficient. All the statistical analyses were performed using SPSS 17.0.