2.1. Overexpression of the SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 Ca2+ ATPase Pumps Alters T Cell Ca2+ Signaling Pathways, Remodeling Both Ca2+ Release and Influx Responses
We sought to examine the hypothesis that altering specific SERCA pump isoform functions, employing genetic methods to both overexpress and reduce protein expression, could rapidly and significantly reconfigure Ca2+ signaling patterning in T cells.
Figure 1A shows protein overexpression of the SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 Ca
2+-ATPase pumps, the two dominant Ca
2+ pump isoforms expressed in T cells as well as the Jurkat lymphocyte [
16,
17], displaying both the Western blot image and bar graphs of band intensities. Jurkat lymphocytes were transfected via electroporation (Neon NxT electroporation system) with plasmid constructs containing sequences encoding ATP2A2 (SERCA 2b) and ATP2A3 (SERCA 3), and transfections consistently yielded between 85–95% efficiencies, as assessed by co-transfection of a GFP-encoding plasmid, (SERCA 2b expression levels were 115–120% of control, and similarly, SERCA 3 expression levels were 165–170% of control sham transfected Jurkat lymphocytes). Interestingly, we observed an apparent linkage in these experiments between increased SERCA 3 expression and a concomitant increase in SERCA 2b expression (
Figure 1A), whereas the opposite effect was not observed, given that increased SERCA 2b expression did not appear to enhance SERCA 3 expression. These results suggest that SERCA expression levels may not be independent events in cellular Ca
2+ homeostasis, with SERCA 2b expression levels exhibiting biased sensitivity to changes in SERCA 3 pump expression.
Jurkat cells overexpressing either SERCA 2b (SERCA2bOE) or SERCA 3 (SERCA3OE) were then tested for responses to an array of Ca2+ mobilizing agonists in both large and small-cell population studies. In most experiments, Ca2+ release responses were measured while cells were suspended in nominally Ca2+-free media; in some experiments, however, Ca2+ influx was determined by adding Ca2+ back to cells in suspension. Moreover, most experiments were conducted using large cell-number populations (approximately 1 × 106 cells/mL) in cuvette-based spectrofluorimetry; where indicated, we also conducted Ca2+ measurements using microscope fluorimetry, sampling responses from small cell-number populations (approximately 30–60 cells).
Figure 1B shows a clear increase in Ca
2+ store levels, as determined by peak height fluorescent changes as well as Ca
2+ release rates, in cells exposed to thapsigargin (TG, 3 μM) in both SERCA 2b
OE (peak height ΔF 1.14 ± 0.03 fluorescence ratio units and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 9.5 × 10
−3, n = 5, green trace) and SERCA 3
OE (ΔF 1.16 ± 0.05 fluorescence ratio units and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 9.5 × 10
−3, n = 5, purple trace) cells vs. control cells (ΔF 0.85 ± 0.06 fluorescence ratio units and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 7.1 × 10
−3, n = 5, black trace). The high dose of TG used in these experiments likely reflect aggregate Ca
2+ levels stored in all SERCA-regulated Ca
2+ pools; given at this concentration of TG, all SERCA pumps will be inhibited. Similarly,
Figure 1C shows Ca
2+ release responses elicited by high levels of the Ca
2+ ionophore ionomycin (Iono, 3 μM), with a similar effect in exhibiting a significantly greater increase in peak height amplitudes in both SERCA 2b
OE (ΔF 1.64 ± 0.05 fluorescence ratio units and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 7.5 × 10
−2, n = 5, green trace) and SERCA 3
OE (ΔF 1.69 ± 0.04 fluorescence ratio units and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 7.7 × 10
−2, n = 5, purple trace) Jurkat lymphocytes compared to control (ΔF 1.19 ± 0.07 fluorescence ratio units and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 5.4 × 10
−2, n = 5, black trace). The high concentration of ionomycin used in this experiment serves to capture the global status of Ca
2+ stores given Ca
2+ release will occur in both TG-sensitive as well as TG-insensitive Ca
2+ pools. These experiments suggest that overexpression of the SERCA Ca
2+ pumps in Jurkat T cells results in greater Ca
2+ storage capacity, presumably due to increased Ca
2+ pump activity.
Figure 1D,E show experimental results that are a repeat of the experiments shown in
Figure 1B,C, with the exception that these experiments were performed using our small cell-number Ca
2+ measurements, with an additional assessment of Ca
2+ influx responses induced by stimulus application in Ca
2+ add-back experiments. We were prompted to verify that our responses shown in
Figure 1B,C in Jurkat large cell-number population measurements exposed to high concentrations of Ca
2+-mobilizing agonists were representative and could be captured using higher resolution measurements employing microscope photometry methods collecting fluorescence emission from small cell-number samples (30–60 cells).
Figure 1D,E show that high dose TG (3 μM) and ionomycin (3 μM) induce the same general response in small cell-number populations as was observed in large cell-number population experiments (
Figure 1B,C, 2 × 10
6 cells), revealing again that SERCA 2b
OE and SERCA 3
OE result in apparently greater Ca
2+ storage capacity in T cells. These experiments using small cell-number populations, however, did reveal slightly greater sample resolution, allowing a bit finer distinction in the Ca
2+ release responses in SERCA 2b
OE and SERCA 3
OE cells, respectively. We observed, for example, increased Ca
2+ release to high dose TG and ionomycin in SERCA 3
OE cells compared to SERCA 2b
OE cells (purple trace vs. green trace). We noted above that overexpression of the SERCA 3 Ca
2+ pump was also associated with increased SERCA 2b expression (
Figure 1A); thus, the observed enhanced Ca
2+ release in SERCA 3
OE Jurkat lymphocytes may be attributable to greater overall SERCA pump expression and activity, resulting in increased Ca
2+ storage compared to SERCA 2b
OE cells (
Figure 1D,E).
Given the well-known tight coupling between T cell Ca
2+ stores and Ca
2+ influx pathways [
2,
4,
18], we examined the effects of SERCA pump overexpression on TG- and ionomycin-induced Ca
2+ influx responses. As shown in
Figure 1D,E, we observed significantly increased Ca
2+ influx responses when Ca
2+ was added back following TG- and ionomycin-induced store depletion, respectively (
Figure 1D, TG response: ΔF 0.41 ± 0.03 SERCA2b
OE and ΔF 0.53 ± 0.05 SERCA3
OE vs. ΔF 0.25 ± 0.03 control cells, n = 3,
p < 0.05;
Figure 1E, ionomycin response: ΔF 0.62 ± 0.02 SERCA2b
OE and ΔF 0.61 ± 0.04 SERCA3
OE vs. ΔF 0.44 ± 0.05 control cells, n = 3,
p < 0.05). These experiments utilize aggressive Ca
2+ store depletion methods with high dose TG and ionomycin, both suggesting that increasing SERCA2b or SERCA 3 pump expression in T lymphocytes significantly augments the capacity of cells to activate and sustain store-depletion-coupled Ca
2+ entry pathways. Thus, these experiments suggest that T lymphocytes may be able to modulate SERCA pump expression levels, enabling recruitment of tailored Ca
2+ influx responses appropriately scaled to antigen-activated pathways of variable strength.
The experiments shown in
Figure 1B–E suggest that SERCA overexpression can alter the status of T lymphocyte Ca
2+ stores and, via increased pump activity, expand Ca
2+ storage capacity. We next sought to investigate whether SERCA overexpression could influence Ca
2+ signals elicited at a finer level of stimulus strength more in line with a physiological agonist, using cuvette spectrofluorimetry with large cell-number populations to more accurately measure the smaller amplitude signals induced by these agents. We chose to use the low-dose SERCA blocker strategy that our previous work has shown enables assessment of Ca
2+ release from specific SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 Ca
2+ stores in T lymphocytes [
19].
Figure 1F,G show experiments challenging Jurkat lymphocytes with very low TG concentrations (100 pM), which allows specific disruption of SERCA 2b stores ([
19],
Figure 1F) and also low concentrations of 2,5-di-(tert butyl)-1,4-benzohydroquinone (tBHQ), which correspondingly exerts preferential disruption of SERCA 3 Ca
2+ stores (
Figure 1G).
Figure 1F shows that overexpression of the SERCA Ca
2+-ATPases yielded intriguing pump isoform-specific differences when the Jurkat lymphocytes were exposed to the low TG concentrations. In contrast to the increased Ca
2+release responses shown in
Figure 1B,D to high TG levels (3 μM), we observed that SERCA 2b
OE cells displayed reduced Ca
2+ release activity to treatment with much lower TG levels (100 pM, ΔF 0.13 ± 0.003 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 2.7 × 10
−4 for SERCA2b
OE vs. ΔF 0.16 ± 0.004 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 3.35 × 10
−4 for control cells n = 3,
p < 0.05). Surprisingly, this effect was even greater in the SERCA 3
OE Jurkat cells, revealing a greater curtailment of Ca
2+ release than was observed in SERCA 2b
OE and control cells (
Figure 1F, ΔF 0.07 ± 0.002 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.46 × 10
−4 for SERCA3
OE vs. ΔF 0.16 ± 0.004 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 3.35 × 10
−4 for control cells n = 3,
p < 0.05).
These results suggest that when T lymphocytes are exposed to a minimal or manageable SERCA pump stress challenge, increasing expression of either SERCA 2b or SERCA 3 confers sufficient pump function to offset and contain Ca
2+ release induced by nearly subthreshold TG stimulation. Indeed, overexpression of the SERCA 3 isoform appears to produce a T lymphocyte phenotype with the greatest capacity to access increased pump function to counteract the low-dose TG-induced Ca
2+ release response. As noted above, our protein expression experiments suggest that overexpression of the SERCA 3 pump isoform was easier to achieve compared to SERCA 2b and that the sum total of SERCA pump protein was greater in SERCA 3
OE Jurkat lymphocytes (
Figure 1A). These results also suggest compensation mechanisms whereby changing expression levels of the SERCA 3 pump may also increase SERCA 2b pump expression, revealing a potential dynamic interdependence between expression levels of the two major pump isoforms. Indeed, this interpretation would explain the much-reduced Ca
2+ release signal induced by low-dose TG in SERCA 3
OE cells compared to SERCA 2b
OE cells (
Figure 1F). We observed the same effect manifest using low-dose tBHQ (1 μM,
Figure 1G) as the Ca
2+ release agonist on SERCA 2b
OE and SERCA 3
OE Jurkat lymphocytes, in which SERCA 3
OE cells reveal significantly reduced Ca
2+ release responses compared to SERCA 2b
OE and control cells (ΔF 0.29 ± 0.02 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.61 × 10
−3 for SERCA2b
OE & ΔF 0.20 ± 0.04 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.11 × 10
−3 for SERCA3
OE vs. ΔF 0.28 ± 0.03 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.55 × 10
−3 for control cells n = 3,
p < 0.05). As above, overexpression of the SERCA 3 Ca
2+ pump results in greater Ca
2+-ATPase sequestering efficacy, particularly to low tBHQ concentrations that allow preferential targeting of the SERCA blocker to the SERCA 3 pumps. Indeed, tBHQ-induced responses in SERCA 2b
OE cells, which, as shown above, do not significantly change SERCA 3 expression levels, display responses similar to control lymphocytes, consistent with the interpretation that the SERCA 2b-regulated Ca
2+ stores are less sensitive to tBHQ at low concentrations (
Figure 1G).
We next investigated the effects of SERCA pump overexpression on Ca
2+ signals induced by T cell receptor (TCR) activation using phytohemagglutinin A (PHA) application as a surrogate for TCR activation and inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate (IP3) production [
10]. Similar to the low-dose TG experiment, we observed that overexpression of both SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 Ca
2+ pumps diminished TCR-activated Ca
2+ release compared to control sham-transfected Jurkat lymphocytes (
Figure 1H, SERCA 2b
OE: ΔF 0.13 ± 0.008 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 4.74 × 10
−4, n = 3,
p < 0.05; SERCA 3
OE: ΔF 0.17 ± 0.02 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 6.20 × 10
−4, n = 3,
p < 0.05 vs. control ΔF 0.26 ± 0.04 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 9.5 × 10
−4). These experiments suggest that increasing expression/activity of SERCA pumps can exert a real-time suppressive effect on TCR/IP3-induced Ca
2+ release from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Moreover, these constrained Ca
2+ release responses in the presence of overexpressed SERCA pumps were also associated with reduced Ca
2+ influx activation, presumably due to downregulation of the coupled store-depletion pathway (
Figure 1H, SERCA 2b
OE: ΔF 0.42 ± 0.015, n = 3,
p < 0.05; SERCA 3
OE: ΔF 0.41 ± 0.02, n = 3,
p < 0.05 vs. control ΔF 0.46 ± 0.03, n = 3). These experiments with SERCA pump overexpression suggest that T lymphocytes can achieve significant reconfiguration of Ca
2+ signaling patterns even with modest changes in SERCA expression levels, motivating further interest in SERCA ER Ca
2+ pumps as a novel regulatory site for T cell management of antigen-activated signaling pathways.
2.2. Specific Knockout of SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 Ca2+-ATPases Further Clarifies T Lymphocyte Ca2+ Store Signaling Regulation at the Level of Ca2+ Release and Ca2+ Influx Pathways
To complement the overexpression studies and to further investigate the roles of SERCA pumps on T lymphocyte Ca2+ signaling pathways, we conducted experiments using SERCA 2b/SERCA 3 knockout Jurkat lymphocytes, testing responses to the same Ca2+ mobilizing agonists used in the overexpression studies.
Figure 2A shows the Western blot results and the corresponding bar plots of band densitometry depicting specific knockout of SERCA 2b (SERCA2b
KO), SERCA 3 (SERCA3
KO) and double knockout of both pump isoforms (SERCA
DKO). To achieve the specific knockout of SERCA pump isoforms, Jurkat lymphocytes were subjected to CRISPR gene editing methods in which cells were transfected using electroporation of specific nucleotide sequences for SERCA 2b (ATP2A2) and SERCA 3 (ATP2A3). Gene transfection efficiencies were quite high (85–95%), assessed as described for the overexpression experiments (see
Section 4), and the protein expression levels were determined 5 days following transfection, and they revealed that we achieved significant reduction in SERCA 2b expression levels (
Figure 2A: SERCA 2b
KO 15–20% of control; SERCA
DKO 15–20% of control) and SERCA 3 expression levels (
Figure 2A: SERCA 3
KO 15–20% of control; SERCA
DKO 5–10% of control). Interestingly, similar to our SERCA overexpression experiments, we observed an apparent interdependence of SERCA 2b expression on changes in SERCA 3 levels, given we found that SERCA 2b pump expression is enhanced in SERCA 3
KO cells (
Figure 2A). Indeed, previous studies have shown a similar effect during T cell activation, reporting reduced SERCA 3 Ca
2+ pump expression accompanied by increases in expression of the SERCA 2b isoform [
20,
21,
22]. We tested SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA 3
KO and SERCA
DKO Jurkat lymphocytes 5 days following transfection using the same protocols and Ca
2+ activating agents as described above for the overexpression experiments.
Figure 2B shows a significant reduction in high-dose TG- (3 μM) induced Ca
2+ release in SERCA 2b
KO T lymphocytes displaying the knockout phenotype (ΔF 0.19 ± 0.02 and Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.25 × 10
−3, 38% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 3.30 × 10
−3, n = 5,
p < 0.05). We observed a much smaller reduction in TG-induced Ca
2+ release in SERCA 3
KO cells (Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 2.93 × 10
−3, 88% of control). These results are consistent with previous studies indicating that TG primarily releases Ca
2+ from the IP3-sensitive SERCA 2b-regulated store [
23,
24]. The small response still observed in SERCA 2b
KO lymphocytes under the knockout condition may be due to Ca
2+ release primarily from SERCA 3-regulated Ca
2+ stores, given that at these high TG concentrations, all SERCA pump isoforms will be inhibited. This interpretation is further supported by the results shown in
Figure 2C with the application of the low-dose TG (100 pM) treatment. Reducing TG levels to these low concentrations clarifies substantially the specificity of TG’s targeted actions on the SERCA 2b Ca
2+ pool, as we observed near complete abrogation of Ca
2+ release activity in the SERCA 2b
KO cells (
Figure 2C, 25% of control sham transfected cells, n = 3,
p < 0.05), whereas virtually no change was observed in the SERCA 3
KO cells.
Similar to the SERCA overexpression studies, we performed additional experiments using small cell-number population samples to provide assurances of signal fidelity and response interpretations obtained with the standard large cell-number population measurements.
Figure 2D,E show Ca
2+ release patterns obtained using microscope photometry in SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA 3
KO Jurkat lymphocytes treated with high-dose Ca
2+ release agonists TG (3 μM) and ionomycin (3 μM). These experiments are designed to aggressively empty the composite SERCA replenished Ca
2+ stores with high dose TG and also assess the broader global increment of Ca
2+ pools including TG-insensitive Ca
2+ storage compartments using high dose ionomycin.
Figure 2D shows a similar result to
Figure 2B, in which the SERCA 2b
KO condition largely abolishes high-dose TG-induced Ca
2+ release, while this response is mostly preserved in SERCA 3
KO T lymphocytes, suggesting, as before, greater selectivity of TG’s actions on the SERCA 2b Ca
2+ store.
T cells expressing reduced SERCA 2b/SERCA 3 Ca
2+-ATPases revealed an intriguing differential pattern in our small cell-number population experiments treated with high-dose ionomycin. We observed that both SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA 3
KO corresponded to a much-reduced ionomycin-induced Ca
2+ release response indicating that reduced SERCA pump expression resulted in a more global state of depleted Ca
2+ stores (
Figure 2E). We noted, however, that SERCA 2b
KO appeared to reduce the composite Ca
2+ pools to a significantly greater extent than SERCA 3
KO lymphocytes (
Figure 2E, SERCA 2b
KO: Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 3.20 × 10
−3, 43% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 7.40 × 10
−3,
p < 0.05; SERCA 3
KO: Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 5.40 × 10
−3, 73% of control,
p < 0.05, n = 3). As mentioned previously, this effect may reveal a differential dynamic balance between distinct Ca
2+ pools in T lymphocytes, suggesting that Ca
2+ sequestered in SERCA 2b-regulated stores translocates or exchanges more readily than Ca
2+ contained in the SERCA 3-regulated stores, given the greater loss of ionomycin-induced releasable Ca
2+ in SERCA 2b
KO T cells. As mentioned previously, this effect may also be due in part to our observations that SERCA 2b
KO cells experience no significant compensatory increase in SERCA 3 expression, in contrast to the SERCA 3
KO cells, and thus have reduced total SERCA expression/function resulting in reduced Ca
2+ storage, as revealed by high dose ionomycin treatment (
Figure 2E).
Indeed, we did observe a greater sensitivity of T lymphocyte Ca
2+ influx activation in cells with reduced SERCA 2b/SERCA 3 expression, consistent with reduced SERCA function, producing a leakier state of Ca
2+ stores, as shown in
Figure 2F. Thus, even though high-dose ionophore stimulated diminished Ca
2+ release in SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA 3
KO T lymphocytes, we still observed larger Ca
2+ influx responses when Ca
2+ was added back to the cells (
Figure 2F). Like the SERCA overexpression studies, these experiments suggest that T lymphocytes may be able to modulate coupling strength to the essential Ca
2+ influx pathways via modest alterations in SERCA pump expression or activity.
We observed that a corresponding reduced SERCA expression could also alter T lymphocyte Ca
2+ signals induced by TCR/IP3 activation using PHA treatment as a nonspecific TCR activator [
10]. Like the high-dose TG and ionomycin treated cells, we observed diminished PHA-induced Ca
2+ release responses in SERCA 2b
KO (Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 7.6 × 10
−4, 76% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.0 × 10
−3, n = 3) and SERCA 3
KO (Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 7.6 × 10
−4, 76% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.0 × 10
−3). Jurkat lymphocytes (
Figure 2G). Reduced SERCA function thus diminishes IP3-mobilizable Ca
2+ pools with a corresponding relatively more depleted Ca
2+ store, as revealed by the significantly larger Ca
2+ influx responses compared to sham-transfected Jurkat lymphocytes (
Figure 2G, SERCA2b
KO: ΔF 1.40 ± 0.07, SERCA3
KO: ΔF 2.04 ± 0.09, n = 3, vs. control ΔF 1.32 ± 0.05,
p < 0.05). We noted an intriguing distinction in Ca
2+ influx responses with an apparent stronger activation of these pathways in SERCA 3
KO T cells in both ionomycin and PHA treated cells (
Figure 2F,G), suggesting that SERCA 3-regulated Ca
2+ pools exhibit incrementally more robust coupling to influx machinery than SERCA 2b-regulated pools. Thus, it appears that reduced SERCA 3 expression in the SERCA 3
KO cells results in the depletion of SERCA 3-regulated Ca
2+ stores, along with measurably greater activation of Ca
2+ influx pathways compared to SERCA 2b
KO cells containing reduced SERCA 2b pump expression.
We concluded our investigation of Ca
2+ signal profiles in SERCA-expression-altered T lymphocytes by employing aggressive perturbation of ER Ca
2+ stores via generation of a SERCA 2b/SERCA 3 double-knockout condition (SERCA
DKO,
Figure 2A). SERCA
DKO Jurkat lymphocytes were maintained in regular continuous culture conditions and presented as generally stable cells, albeit with reduced viability levels (see below). We tested the SERCA
DKO cells using the same battery of Ca
2+ mobilizing agonists described in the foregoing experiments: high-dose TG and ionomycin, low-dose TG and tBHQ and PHA.
Figure 3A,B show the Jurkat lymphocyte responses to high-dose TG and ionomycin, revealing near total abrogation of TG (Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 8.12 × 10
−4, 23% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 3.5 × 10
−3, n = 3,
Figure 3A) and ionophore (Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.24 × 10
−2, 37% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 3.34 × 10
−2, n = 3,
Figure 3B) -releasable Ca
2+ pools in the SERCA
DKO cells. The small Ca
2+ release observed in the high-dose TG experiment (
Figure 3A) may be due to some residual SERCA pump expression, as complete knockout of SERCA expression is not achieved using these CRISPR-based methods (
Figure 2A). The small increment of Ca
2+ release with high-dose ionomycin may reflect Ca
2+ release from non-SERCA regulated pools, yet clearly demonstrating that in the absence of robust SERCA function, this storage compartment is considerably depleted (
Figure 3B).
Similarly, SERCA
DKO Jurkat T lymphocytes display near complete eradication of Ca
2+ release responses to application of low-dose TG (100 pM, Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.15 × 10
−4, 25% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 4.62 × 10
−4, n = 3,
Figure 3C) and low-dose tBHQ (1 μM, Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 2.22 × 10
−4, 16% of control Ca
2+ release rate ΔF/sec 1.41 × 10
−3, n = 3,
Figure 3D). As mentioned previously, these are quite weak agonists at these concentrations, likely producing modest SERCA pump perturbations, and thus, it is not surprising that these responses have been largely abolished in the SERCA double knockout phenotype. Yet, SERCA
DKO T lymphocytes should represent a severe disruption of Ca
2+ stores, a greater ER Ca
2+ store perturbation than we observe in the single selective SERCA knockout experiments, in which some compensation or preservation of internal Ca
2+ pools is likely mediated by residual SERCA pump function. Indeed, as shown in
Figure 3E, we observed that PHA-induced TCR/IP3 activation failed to induce Ca
2+ release in the SERCA
DKO lymphocytes, underscoring the severely depleted state of the Ca
2+ stores. Thus, in this background of aggressively depleted Ca
2+ stores, we observed high sensitivity and strong coupling to the Ca
2+ influx pathway in SERCA
DKO T lymphocytes when Ca
2+ levels (2 mM) were restored following TCR activation (
Figure 3E, SERCA
DKO: ΔF 0.43 ± 0.04 vs. sham-transfected control cells: ΔF 0.35 ± 0.03, n = 3,
p < 0.05).
2.3. Pharmacologic SERCA Modulators and Altered SERCA Expression Levels Suggest Broad Integrated SERCA Regulation of Essential T Lymphocyte Functions
We shifted our investigation from SERCA effects on Ca2+ signaling pathways to a key subset of T lymphocyte functions including cell proliferation, cytokine secretion, glucose acquisition and oxidative stress management.
Figure 4 summarizes Jurkat lymphocyte proliferation responses to various experimental treatments that alter SERCA function or expression levels.
Figure 4A shows dose response effects of treating T lymphocytes with increasing concentrations of the SERCA activator CDN1163 for 72 h. We have previously reported that extended incubation (>24 h) with CDN1163 increased Ca
2+ storage in the Jurkat lymphocyte SERCA-regulated Ca
2+ pools, with a preferential effect on the SERCA 2b Ca
2+ stores [
19]. We found that incubation with CDN1163 concentrations in the low micromolar range produced a modest increase in lymphocyte proliferation, suggesting, as we previously noted, a salutary effect on T lymphocyte growth that correlated with enhanced Ca
2+ storage capacity [
19].
Figure 4B,C show the effects on Jurkat lymphocyte cell growth using the SERCA blockers TG and tBHQ. These experiments revealed the intriguing phenomenon in which low-dose SERCA inhibition with its associated ER Ca
2+ increased permeability, and cytosolic Ca
2+ elevation can stimulate T lymphocyte cell growth. Thus, with imposing moderate ER stress stimulus with TG levels at low concentrations (≤100 pM) and also with low tBHQ levels (≤1 μM), we observed measurable increases in cell proliferation. Indeed, TG was initially categorized as a tumor promoter due to its actions to block SERCA function and stimulate a growth-promoting Ca
2+ signal [
25]. However, increasing TG levels modestly above a sharp transition point (≥200 pM) produced, in contrast, a pronounced inhibition on T lymphocyte growth, suggesting more aggressive perturbation of SERCA-regulated Ca
2+ stores (
Figure 4B). We observed a similar effect for tBHQ exposure, with cell growth inhibition developing at concentrations greater than one micromolar (
Figure 4C).
Perturbation of SERCA functions via altered expression levels also reveals interconnections between T lymphocyte growth control and SERCA-regulated Ca
2+ store function.
Figure 4D shows that overexpression of both SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 significantly boost Jurkat lymphocyte proliferation. This effect is consistent with our previous study [
19] and
Figure 4A, in which pharmacologic SERCA activation with CDN1163 application contributes to increased cell proliferation associated with increased Ca
2+ storage capacity. Indeed, this is also the result we reported in
Figure 1B–E, demonstrating increased Ca
2+ storage in SERCA 2b
OE and SERCA 3
OE T lymphocytes, as revealed by high dose TG and ionomycin treatment. We observed, moreover, a correspondingly diminished growth response in SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA
DKO cells (
Figure 4D). These results hint at a parallel relationship with increased SERCA expression/activity producing augmentation of lymphocyte growth, whereas decreased SERCA expression/activity result in diminished lymphocyte growth. As mentioned above (
Figure 2 and
Figure 3), we do find that genetic knockout of SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 results in substantial reduction in ER Ca
2+ storage capacity. These experiments further suggest SERCA isoform specificity in regulation of T lymphocyte growth responses.
Figure 4D shows, for example, that specific knockout of the SERCA 2b pump significantly decreases cell growth, while knockout of the SERCA 3 pump does not. This result also aligns with our previous work, showing that CDN1163 appears to preferentially act on increasing the SERCA 2b Ca
2+ pools, conferring increased growth and cellular resilience via specific action on the SERCA 2b isoform. Thus, our findings suggest differential modes of T lymphocyte signaling regulation exerted by the SERCA pumps, with SERCA 2b integrated more prominently in cell growth regulation compared to SERCA 3 Ca
2+ pumps.
We next examined the effect of altered SERCA expression levels on T lymphocyte growth responses induced by canonical Ca
2+ signaling pathways activated by the commonly employed lectin T cell mitogens PHA and Concanavalin A (Con A).
Figure 4E,F show dose response effects on Jurkat lymphocyte growth responses for cells exposed to PHA and Con A for extended incubation periods (72 and 96 h). The experiments revealed pronounced and increasing growth suppression with exposure to the two mitogens over the 96 h incubation period. PHA is a well-known mimic of the antigen-activated TCR/IP3/Ca
2+ pathway, which initially stimulates T lymphocyte proliferation followed by triggering of activation-induced cell death pathways and, ultimately, cell growth suppression [
26,
27]. Con A also triggers the activation of T cell Ca
2+ pathways, albeit via recruitment of different signaling mediators [
28]; but like PHA, Con A also induces growth suppression in T lymphocyte populations, though not to the same degree as observed with PHA in Jurkat lymphocytes (
Figure 4E,F). Using this lectin treatment protocol, we tested whether increasing or decreasing SERCA expression levels could modulate the growth-suppressing action of PHA on Jurkat lymphocytes. As shown in
Figure 4G,H, neither SERCA 2b/SERCA 3 overexpression nor SERCA 2b/SERCA 3 knockout could compensate for or protect T lymphocytes from the initial effects of PHA to reduce cell growth (24 h). Indeed, the increase in cell proliferation observed in SERCA 2b
OE and SERCA 3
OE Jurkat cells (
Figure 4D) was eradicated in cells treated with PHA (10 μg/mL) for 24 h. Moreover, treating SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA 3
KO T lymphocytes with PHA (10 μg/mL
) caused an even greater reduction in cell proliferation than was observed in the knockout condition alone (
Figure 4H). Thus, altering Ca
2+ store levels and/or Ca
2+ influx activity as we observed in SERCA 2b
OE/SERCA 3
OE or SERCA 2b
KO/SERCA 3
KO Jurkat lymphocytes (
Figure 1 and
Figure 2, respectively) was insufficient to reconfigure or abort growth-suppressing TCR signals unaccompanied by other essential signaling input that would normally emerge from valid antigen activation.
A key signaling output pathway in T lymphocyte function is the antigen stimulated production of cytokine factors. In our study, we examined the TCR activation pathway that results in IL-2 secretion, utilizing the commonly employed surrogate actions of PHA to nonspecifically stimulate the TCR/IP3/Ca
2+ signal upstream of IL-2 synthesis.
Figure 5A shows the effect of PHA (10 μg/mL) to induce IL-2 secretion above baseline untreated Jurkat lymphocytes. We noted that IL-2 secretion was depressed in SERCA 2b
OE and SERCA 3
OE cells and that PHA stimulation could increase IL-2 levels in the SERCA-overexpressed condition, albeit at levels still below control untreated T lymphocytes (
Figure 5A). This result aligns with our observations in
Figure 1H, showing that PHA treatment in SERCA-overexpressing Jurkat lymphocytes induces both reduced Ca
2+ release and Ca
2+ influx, which would explain reduced IL-2 secretion given this cytokine’s strong dependence on recruitment of the Ca
2+ influx pathway [
4,
5]. In contrast to SERCA overexpression, SERCA knockout did not significantly affect IL-2 production (
Figure 5B). Indeed, this difference may be attributable to the augmented Ca
2+ influx activity we noted in
Figure 2 in SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA 3
KO cells. This interpretation would also be consistent with our observations that PHA stimulation in the SERCA knockout phenotype is still capable of elevating IL-2 production (
Figure 5B), even though Ca
2+ release induced by PHA was curtailed presumably by reduced SERCA activity and reduced Ca
2+ store levels (
Figure 2G). Perhaps the most compelling validation of this idea is our finding that the largest increase we observed in PHA-induced IL-2 production was in the SERCA
DKO Jurkat lymphocyte (
Figure 5B). This finding correlates well with our observations that the PHA-induced Ca
2+ influx response was rapidly and robustly activated in the SERCA
DKO cells, even with nearly eradicated PHA-stimulated Ca
2+ release compared to sham transfected Jurkat controls (
Figure 3E).
We extended our experiments shown in
Figure 5B to assess the effects of the pharmacological modulation of SERCA pumps using the pre-incubation regimen with the SERCA activator CDN1163 reported in our previous study [
19].
Figure 5C reveals that CDN1163 pre-incubation (24 h) failed to significantly alter IL-2 production in unstimulated Jurkat lymphocytes. However, we observed a significant reduction in IL-2 secretion in PHA-stimulated T lymphocytes pre-treated with CDN1163 (
Figure 5C). Thus, this result is analogous to the SERCA overexpression condition and presumably attributable to increased SERCA functional activity with a corresponding increase in Ca
2+ store loading, thereby diminishing Ca
2+ influx and IL-2 synthesis. Indeed, we even observed that CDN1163 exposure could significantly suppress the strong PHA-induced IL-2 synthesis in the Jurkat SERCA
DKO lymphocyte, underscoring the efficacy of pharmacological SERCA activation in modulating T cell activation pathways (
Figure 5C).
Antigen-activated T lymphocytes enter complex and protracted phases of cell proliferation and differentiation and therefore exhibit high demand for glucose uptake and utilization [
29,
30]. We were interested in examining the effect of altered SERCA pump expression on glucose uptake activity in Jurkat lymphocytes, given the demands on activated proliferating cells and also recognizing that SERCA pumps themselves are significant energy-consuming ion transporters operating continuously in the environment of a Ca
2+ permeable ER membrane [
31,
32].
Figure 6A shows that overexpression of the SERCA pumps significantly increases glucose uptake in Jurkat transfected cells, presumably to accommodate in part the increased demand on ATP synthesis needed for enhanced active Ca
2+ transport. Furthermore, intriguingly, just as in our experiments testing cell proliferation and Ca
2+ signaling responses, we observed a SERCA isoform difference in glucose uptake measurements with SERCA 3
OE cells driving significantly greater glucose uptake than was observed in the SERCA 2b
OE T lymphocytes. In keeping with this observation, we noted a significant decrease in glucose uptake in SERCA 3
KO T lymphocytes compared to the SERCA 2b
KO cells (
Figure 6A), further suggesting a greater dependence on glucose utilization for the SERCA 3-regulated Ca
2+ stores. Stimulation of the TCR/IP3/Ca
2+ pathway with PHA treatment also increased glucose uptake compared to untreated Jurkat lymphocytes and was associated with a still greater increment of glucose uptake in SERCA 2b
OE and SERCA 3
OE cells with, yet again, a greater increase observed in SERCA 3
OE Jurkat cells relative to SERCA 2b
OE cells (
Figure 6B). PHA-induced increases in glucose uptake were still measurable in SERCA 2b
KO and SERCA 3
KO T lymphocytes, albeit at much-reduced levels compared to the SERCA-overexpression condition (
Figure 6B). This result may reflect reduced energy demands in a reduced Ca
2+ storage/SERCA-expressing environment. Indeed, part of the enhanced sensitivity of glucose uptake we observed in SERCA 3
OE and SERCA 3
KO T lymphocytes may derive from a uniquely heightened linkage to expression of the Glut3 glucose transporter isoform [
33]. T cells may use changes in SERCA 3 expression levels or activity as a sensor for energy utilization, coupling changes to SERCA 3-regulated Ca
2+ store functions to increased/decreased transcription of the high-affinity Glut3 transporter to accommodate changing T cell energy demands.
Figure 6C shows overexpression of the SERCA 3 pump results in significantly greater expression levels of Glut3 compared to SERCA 2b overexpression, and similarly, knockout of SERCA 3 correspondingly appears to reduce Glut3 transporter expression to a greater extent than SERCA 2b knockout Jurkat lymphocytes.
Our results suggest that SERCA expression levels can influence T lymphocyte energy homeostasis via glucose uptake pathways. We were thus motivated to investigate possible SERCA involvement in common T cell dysfunctional states related to oxidative stress, which are increasingly suspected contributors to maladaptive T cell signaling dynamics, including T cell disrupted function in the tumor microenvironment [
34,
35].
Figure 6D shows that altered SERCA expression is associated with corresponding changes to the production of the common antioxidant mediator reduced glutathione (GSH). We again noted the same SERCA isoform difference as was observed in the glucose uptake experiments with SERCA 3
OE cells associated with significantly greater GSH production than was observed in the SERCA 2b
OE cells (
Figure 6D). Multiple parameters in our study thus suggest differential roles in T cell biology for the SERCA 2b and SERCA 3 Ca
2+ pumps.
Figure 6D further implicates SERCA regulation of GSH antioxidant production as we observed significant reduction in GSH levels in SERCA 2b
KO, SERCA 3
KO and SERCA
DKO Jurkat lymphocytes.