1. Introduction
With the rapid development of the global economy, fuel consumption, and increasingly serious environmental problems, there is an urgent need to develop clean, efficient, and sustainable energy-storage and -conversion technologies [
1,
2]. Based on the working principle of electrochemical energy conversion and storage, alkali metal-ion batteries are considered as the most promising next-generation energy-storage devices, which can effectively promote the development of sustainable energy and reduce environmental pollution [
3]. At present, the demand for high-energy-density and high-power-density electrochemical energy-storage devices is increasing, and the demand for long-cycle stability and low-cost electrode materials is particularly urgent. Among the numerous nanomaterials, two-dimensional (2D) materials have broad application prospects in alkali metal-ion batteries due to their unique layered structure [
4]. The layered structure can provide abundant channels for ion diffusion, accelerate the ion-diffusion process, and facilitate the realization of fast electron transport within the atomic layer. In addition, the layered structure can buffer the volume change during charging and discharging and improve the contact stability of the material [
5].
As a new type of 2D layered transition metal carbides, MXenes have received extensive attention since the successful acquisition of MXenes in the MAX phase [
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12]. The general formula is M
n+1X
nT
x (
n = 1–3), where M represents an early transition metal (Ti, V, Cr, Nb, etc.),
X is C or N, and
T is the surface terminus [
8,
13,
14,
15,
16,
17]. MXenes have abundant surface functional groups and have been widely studied as electrodes for Li/Na-ion batteries [
18,
19,
20] and supercapacitors [
21,
22,
23,
24] due to their good electrical and ionic conductivity.
Since Gogotsi et al. [
9] obtained 2D Ti
3C
2T
x materials by selective HF etching of Ti
3AlC
2 compounds in 2011, the family of 2D transition metal carbides, nitrides, and carbonitrides (MXenes) has gradually expanded. After more than ten years of research, dozens of MXenes materials have been successfully prepared. Pure-phase MXenes exhibit similar metallicity to their precursor MAX, but theory predicts that they could also be semiconductors [
25] or topological insulators [
26]. In general, the electronic structure of MXene is affected by the following three aspects: chemical composition (elemental species of M, X, T), crystal structure, and location of functional groups. Therefore, surface-controlled functionalization modification has become a common method to improve the physicochemical properties of MXene and endow its composites with new functions. In addition, MXene not only has the performance of traditional two-dimensional materials, but also has energy storage, good electrical conductivity, and self-lubricating properties, etc., showing great application potential in many fields such as energy storage, catalysis, and tribology. However, the current understanding of the structure and properties of MXene is still limited, and a lot of research work is still needed to fully understand the various properties of MXene.
The preparation of MXenes is usually performed by etching the MAX phase by the HF or LiF/HCl system. After etching, -O, -F and -OH functional groups will be introduced on the surface of the material. The Li ions penetrate and store the inner MXene sheet with a theoretical capacity of 447.8 mAh g
−1 [
27]. However, the -F termination groups usually reduce the initial discharge capacity and cycling stability due to poor electrode/electrolyte interface. The introduction of fluorine end-groups also increases the interface resistance between the electrode and the electrolyte. This further reduces the lithium-storage performance and cycle stability of the electrode [
12,
28,
29]. In addition, MXenes bulks have many problems such as easy stacking of sheets, poor mechanical strength, and easy oxidation during the preparation process, which lead to the blockage of electron-/ion-transport channels and the collapse of the microstructure. Therefore, it is necessary to improve MXenes-based energy-storage materials from the perspective of surface functional groups and bulk microstructure. In terms of bulk microstructure, Lian et al. used KOH solution to exfoliate Ti
3C
2T
x nanosheets, and the interlayer spacing of the exfoliated Ti
3C
2T
x nanosheets expanded, thereby accelerating ion transport [
30]. In terms of surface functional groups, Ahmed et al. used H
2O
2 to treat Ti
2CT
x material to realize the surface -O functional group modification of MXene, and used it as a negative electrode material in LIB [
31]. Due to the increase in -O functional groups, the proportion of active sites increases, which in turn promotes the adsorption of Li
+ and improves the lithium-storage performance of electrode materials.
Herein, chemical exfoliation and low-temperature annealing methods were used to control the surface termination groups’ surface end-capping groups of a few-layer Ti3C2Tx nanosheet, which exhibited a reversible lithium-ion-storage specific capacity of 444.1 mAh g−1. The increase in -O functional groups could increase the diffusion rate of Li+, promote the transport of electrons, and accelerated the kinetics of the electrode reaction, thereby improving the performance of lithium-ion storage.
2. Materials and Methods
Preparation of Ti3C2Tx-F: The MAX phase (Ti3AlC2) was etched and stripped with HF solution to obtain two-dimensional layered Ti3C2Tx. A total of 0.83 g of Ti3AlC2 powder was slowly added to a polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) beaker filled with 20 mL of HF (40%) aqueous solution and stirred in a constant-temperature water bath at 60 °C for 2 h, centrifuged at 8000 rpm for 10 min, and washed multiple times with deionized water until the pH of the supernatant was 6–7. The washed production was put into a vacuum oven and dried at 80 °C for 24 h.
Preparation of Ti3C2Tx-T: a total of 0.5 g of Ti3C2Tx-F was dispersed in 5 mL of TMAOH solution and sonicated for 30 min, followed by magnetic stirring at 50 °C for 2 h and further ultrasonic treatment for 1 h to obtain the Ti3C2Tx-T material. The above suspension was transferred to a dialysis bag (MD 44 mm), put into a beaker containing deionized water for dialysis treatment for 7 days, and the deionized water was changed regularly until the suspension in the dialysis bag became neutral. The resulting suspension was snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen and freeze-dried to obtain few-layer Ti3C2Tx.
Preparation of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O): The surface modification of the few-layer Ti
3C
2T
x-T material was carried out by low-temperature annealing. In brief, 0.5 g of Ti
3C
2T
x-T material was heated to 280 °C for 2 h with a heating rate of 5 min
−1 in tube furnace to obtain Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O). The schematic illustration for the preparation of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) is described in
Scheme 1.The surface morphologies and microstructures of the samples were observed by SEM (Quanta FEG, USA), TEM and HRTEM (FEI Talos F200X, USA). XRD (ARL Equinox 3000 using Cu Kα1 radiation, USA) was used to measure the components and crystal structure. Raman (HORIBA JOBIN YVON S.A.S., France) spectroscopy was used to analyze the defect types and crystallinity of samples. Elemental chemical environment of the sample surface was analyzed by XPS (Thermo Scientific, ESCALAB 250 Xi, USA). FTIR spectra were recorded on PerkinElmer TL9000 (Canada) using KBr disks. The galvanostatic intermittent titration technique (GITT) was performed at a current density of 0.05 A g−1. The specific surface area and pore-size distribution were measured by nitrogen absorption and desorption method on Microtrac BEL (Japan).
The samples were tested for electrochemical performance by LIBs. A total of 80 mg of the prepared material, 10 mg of acetylene black and 10 mg of polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) binder were weighed according to the mass ratio of 8:1:1, and then put into an agate mortar and fully ground for 30 min to obtain a uniformly dispersed slurry. The obtained slurry was coated on copper foil, scraped with a 200 μm scraper until the surface was uniform, transferred to a vacuum oven, and dried at 80 °C for 12 h. When the oven temperature dropped to room temperature, the copper foil was cut into circular electrode pieces with a diameter of 12 mm using a microtome, and the active material loading was about 1.15 mg cm−2. In this paper, lithium foil was used as the counter electrode to assemble a CR2032 button battery case in a glove box filled with high-purity argon gas, and its electrochemical performance was tested. The liquid electrolyte was 1.0 M LiPF6 in a mixture of ethylene carbonate (EC)/diethyl carbonate (DEC) with a volume ratio of 1:1, and the separator was a microporous membrane (Celgard2400). Constant current charge/discharge performance tests (cycling performance and rate performance) were performed by an automatic battery-tester system (Land CT2001A, China) at a constant temperature of 25 °C in a voltage range of 0.01 V to 3.0 V. Cyclic voltammetry (CV) tests were performed on a potential window range of 0 to 3.0 V at scan rates from 0.1 mV s−1 to 2 mV s−1 used a CHI760E (CH Instruments, China) electrochemical workstation. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) was performed on a CHI760E electrochemical workstation with a test frequency range of 0.01 Hz to 1 MHz. The galvanostatic intermittent titration technique (GITT) was performed on an automatic battery-tester system (Land CT2001A, China) with a voltage range of 0.01 V~3.0 V (vs. Li/Li+), a current density of 50 mA g−1, a pulse of 5 min, and a relaxation of 55 min.
3. Results and Discussion
As shown in
Figure 1a, the SEM image showed that Ti
3C
2T
x-F had a graphene-like layered structure, and its sheets were arranged in parallel in an accordion shape. As shown in
Figure 1b, the few-layer Ti
3C
2T
x-T material prepared by exfoliating the layered Ti
3C
2T
x-F by TMAOH organic reagent showed the morphology of tightly stacked nanosheets, indicated that the layered Ti
3C
2T
x-F material was formed by the TMAOH organic reagent. It was peeled off into a few layers of Ti
3C
2T
x-T material, and the surface was relatively complete. As shown in
Figure 1c,d, after low-temperature annealing, the edges of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) nanosheets were wrinkled and slightly curled to form a 3D network structure. It was found that the exfoliated MXene sheets maintain the diameter of the pristine MAX sheets in the size of ~10 μm.
In order to explore the microstructure on the surface of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) nanosheets, Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) was tested by TEM. As shown in
Figure 2a,b, Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) nanosheets were thin and transparent, with wrinkles on the surface and edges, relatively complete morphology, no obvious defects, and oxide particles, indicating that the successful preparation had larger-size nanosheets with fewer defects. The EDS-mapping images showed that C, F, O, and Ti elements were uniformly distributed in the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) nanosheets.
The crystal phase structures of the above three materials were analyzed and tested by XRD, as shown in
Figure 3a. After HF etching, the characteristic peak at 39° of the Ti
3AlC
2 raw material (JCPDS No 52-0875) almost disappeared, confirming that the Al atomic layer was removed from Ti
3AlC
2. The characteristic peaks at 9°, 18°, and 27° of Ti
3C
2T
x-F obtained by HF etching and lift-off corresponded to (002), (004), and (006) crystal planes, respectively [
32]. The intensity of the diffraction peak of the high Miller index crystal plane of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T material obtained by TMAOH organic reagent for secondary exfoliation decreases, indicating that the multilayer Ti
3C
2T
x-F was fully exfoliated to obtain a few layers of Ti
3C
2T
x-T. The (002) characteristic peak intensity of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) material obtained by low-temperature annealing treatment was weakened, indicating that the material had certain wrinkles and curls, which was consistent with the results observed in SEM.
In order to explore the molecular-structure information of the surface of Ti
3C
2T
x material before and after modification, Raman spectroscopy was used to explore the material. As shown in
Figure 3b, the characteristic peak I corresponded to the vibration of Ti–O or Ti–OH bonds (152.6 cm
−1), confirming that the surface contains Ti
3C
2O
x and Ti
3C
2(OH)
x compounds. The characteristic peaks of II and III corresponded to the stretching vibrations of Ti–C bonds (401.5 cm
−1 and 606.2 cm
−1) [
33]. There were two characteristic peaks, D peak and G peak, at 1313.7 cm
−1 and 1567.2 cm
−1, respectively. The D peak was caused by the deformation vibration of amorphous carbon or six-membered ring, and the G peak was caused by the stacking of graphite hexagonal network planes. After low-temperature annealing, the intensities of D peak and G peak of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) material increased, indicating that the carbon content of the material increased. After the micro-oxidation treatment, the Ti atomic layer in Ti
3C
2T
x was destroyed, exposing more C atoms, which resulted in a slightly higher intensity of the G peak than that of the D peak [
34].
Figure 3c,d showed the specific surface area and pore-size-distribution curves of the anode of Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti
3C
2T
x-T, and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O), respectively. As shown in
Figure 3c, the specific surface areas of Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti
3C
2T
x-T and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) can be calculated by BET theory to be 7.69 m
2 g
−1, 41.209 m
2 g
−1 and 44.165 m
2 g
−1, respectively. As shown in
Figure 3d, the pore sizes of Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti
3C
2T
x-T, and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) materials were calculated using the BJH model to ~0.013 cm
3 g
−1, ~0.101 cm
3 g
−1 and ~0.106 cm
3 g
−1, respectively. Comparing the obtained data, it can be seen that the specific surface area of the sample showed a gradual trend of increasing, while the pore size showed a trend of first being larger and then smaller. The trend of sample porosity was basically consistent with the trend of the specific surface area of the sample.
To explore the elemental chemical environment on the material surface, XPS analysis was performed on Ti
3C
2T
x-F and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) materials. As shown in
Figure 4a,d, the characteristic peaks located at 281.8, 284.8, 286.3, and 288.5 eV in the C 1
s XPS spectrum correspond to C–Ti–O, C–C, C–OH and O–C=O bonds [
35]. In the O 1
s XPS spectra, 529.8, 531.6 and 533.0 eV correspond to Ti–O, Ti–OH and H
2O [
36], respectively (shown in
Figure 4b,e). As shown in
Figure 4c,f, four pairs of double peaks (Ti 2
p3/2 and Ti 2
p1/2) could be obtained by fitting the Ti 2
p XPS spectra, and each pair of peaks conforms to a fixed area ratio (2:1) and a fixed peak spacing (5.7 eV). The peaks at binding energies of 454.8 and 455.8 eV in Ti 2
p3/2 correspond to Ti–C and Ti–F bonds, and the peaks at binding energies of 457.0 and 458.6 eV correspond to Ti–O bonds (Ti
3+:Ti
xO
y, Ti
4+:TiO
2). Compared with Ti 2
p in Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti 2
p in Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) had reduced the characteristic peak intensity of Ti–C at 454.8 eV and Ti–F at 455.8 eV, and enhanced the Ti–O characteristic peak intensity at 458.6 eV [
37]. The quantitative analysis of the sample surface by XPS indicated that the proportion of oxygen atoms of Ti
3C
2T
x-F was 18.04 at.%; the proportion of fluorine atoms was 12.74 at.%. In addition, the proportion of oxygen atoms of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) was 44.15 at.%, and the proportion of fluorine atoms was 1.72 at.%. The above phenomenon showed that the relative content of Ti–O on the surface of the material increased and the relative content of Ti–F decreased after low-temperature annealing treatment. Oxygen substitution occurred after the Ti–F bond was oxidized, and the content of oxygen-containing functional groups on the surface of the material increased.
Figure 5a showed the constant current charge–discharge curve of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) negative electrode in the voltage range of 0.01 V–3.0 V. Under the current density of 0.1 A g
−1, the discharge-specific capacity of the first cycle was 650.41 mAh g
−1, the charge-specific capacity of the first cycle was 406.87 mAh g
−1, and the corresponding initial coulomb efficiency (ICE) was 62.56%. The voltage plateau at 0.8 V in the first cycle of the discharge curve corresponds to the formation of the SEI (solid electrolyte interface) film in the first cycle. The charge–discharge curves of the 2nd, 50th, and 100th cycles basically coincide, which proved that the material had good cycle stability.
In order to study the electrochemical kinetic process of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode, EIS test was carried out. The Nyquist curve consisted of a semicircle in the high- to mid-frequency region and a sloping line in the low-frequency region. The semicircle represented the charge-transfer resistance (R
ct) of the electrode and the electric double-layer capacitance (CPE) with capacitive properties, and the oblique line corresponds to the diffusion resistance (Z
w) of lithium ions in the electrolyte. The intercept in the high-frequency region on the Z’ axis represented the contact resistance (R
s) between the electrode and the electrolyte [
38]. As shown in
Figure 6a, the R
ct values of Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti
3C
2T
x-T and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anodes were 506.8, 202.5 and 89.1 Ω, respectively, indicating that Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anodes had good charge-transfer kinetic characteristics and good conductivity.
As shown in
Figure 6b, at the current densities of 0.1, 0.2, 0.5, 1, 2, and 5 A g
−1, the discharge-specific capacities of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode were 285.2, 228.6, 209.2, 188.9, 174.4, and 151.4 mAh g
−1. When the current density returned to a small current density of 0.1 A g
−1, the discharge capacity of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode recovered to 265.2 mAh g
−1, indicating that the material had good reversibility. In contrast, the specific discharge capacities of Ti
3C
2T
x-F electrodes at current densities of 0.1, 0.2, 0.5, 1, 2, 5, and 0.1 A g
−1 were only 193.5, 118.4, 94.5, 75.0, 58.3, 43.1, and 124.9 mAh g
−1. Compared with the Ti
3C
2T
x-F electrode, the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) electrode had better rate performance, because the few-layer structure can effectively shorten the ion-diffusion path and improve the diffusion rate; the specific surface area increased, the oxygen-containing functional groups on the surface increased, the proportion of active sites increased, and the reaction kinetics was promoted.
As shown in
Figure 6c, the initial discharge-specific capacities of the Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti
3C
2T
x-T, and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anodes were 226.2, 444.9, and 665 mAh g
−1, respectively. The ICE of Ti
3C
2T
x-T anode was 49.15 %, and the ICE of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode after oxidation treatment was 53.75 %. The improvement of ICE might be related to the substitution of -F functional groups on the surface by -O functional groups. After 200 cycles, the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode exhibited a specific discharge capacity of 444.1 mAh g
−1 and a capacity retention rate of 124.05 %. In contrast, the Ti
3C
2T
x-T anode had a specific discharge capacity of 224.8 mAh g
−1 after 200 cycles, and a capacity retention rate of only 92.21 %. According to the analysis of physicochemical properties/electrochemical lithium-storage performance, the improved electrochemical cycling stability of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) was closely related to the substitution of -O functional groups for -F functional groups on the surface of Ti
3C
2T
x-T, in which a large number of oxygen-containing functional groups could provide more energy for Li
+ more active sites, thereby improving the lithium-storage performance of the electrode. The Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) negative electrode exhibited a phenomenon of “negative growth” (capacity first decreases and then increases) during the cycle. It was speculated that the repeated deintercalation of Li
+ between the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) layers during the cycle causes the interlayer spacing to increase. The chemically active lithium-storage sites were continuously activated, resulting in an increase in the pseudocapacitance contribution of the electrode surface. In future work, the following methods could be used to improve the ICE of the electrode: short-circuiting the negative pole piece by electrical contact with the short-circuit method, adjusting the resistance and processing time of the short-circuit wire, and realizing prelithiation under the action of the potential difference; using lithium-aromatic compounds (lithium naphthalene, butyllithium) to immerse or spray the negative electrode material to achieve chemical prelithiation [
39,
40]; functionally modifying the metal electrode with the help of artificial SEI layer technology to improve the ICE [
41].
To investigate the Li
+ diffusion kinetics of Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti
3C
2T
x-T and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anodes, GITT measurements were performed at a current density of 0.05 A g
−1, and the pulse and relaxation processes are shown in
Figure 7a. First, a current was applied to the pulse, and the battery potential raised rapidly during the pulse. Subsequently, the charging current was kept constant, and the potential was slowly raised. Finally, entering the relaxation process, the composition in the electrode tended to be homogeneous through Li
+ diffusion, and the potential decreased slowly until it equilibrated again. Compared with Ti
3C
2T
x-F and Ti
3C
2T
x-T, Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode exhibited smaller overpotentials during charging, indicating a better diffusion rate. The diffusion coefficients D of Ti
3C
2T
x-F, Ti
3C
2T
x-T, and Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) electrodes changed periodically with the lithiation process (Corresponding to the discharge process of
Figure 7a), and the maximum diffusion rates were 1.12 × 10
−11 cm
2 s
−1, 3.94 × 10
−11 cm
2 s
−1 and 5.76 × 10
−11 cm
2 s
−1 (
Figure 7b). The Li
+ diffusion coefficients of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) electrode at each potential were higher than those of the two, which was related to the increased oxygen-containing functional groups in the surface modification of the material. The replacement of some -F functional groups on the surface by -O functional groups could improve the diffusion rate of Li
+, optimize the electron/ion transport pathway, and accelerate the kinetics of the electrode reaction, thereby enhancing the cycling stability and rate capability.
By studying the CV curves of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode at different scanning speeds, the kinetics of lithium storage was explored and the contribution ratio of capacitance was calculated.
Figure 8a shows the CV curves of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode at different scan rates. According to the cyclic voltammetry test formula
i =
avb, it was logarithmically transformed to obtain log(
i) = blog(
v) + log(
a). The
b value of the redox peak of the electrode was calculated by plotting the log(
i)-log(
v) curve. When
b = 0.5, it indicated that the electrode reaction was dominated by diffusion, and when
b = 1, it indicated that the electrode reaction was dominated by surface pseudocapacitance as host [
42]. As shown in
Figure 8b, the
b values of the oxidation peak (~1.5 V) and reduction peak (~1.7 V) of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode were calculated to be 0.76 and 0.77, respectively. The total capacity of the electrode was divided into two parts: (1) the capacity contribution provided by the ion-diffusion process; (2) the pseudocapacitive contribution provided by the redox reaction that occurs during the charge-transfer process on the electrode surface. The lithium storage form of the Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) anode was quantified, as shown in
Figure 8c. At the scan rate of 0.1 mV s
−1, the capacitive contribution of the negative electrode of Ti
3C
2T
x-T(O) accounted for 23.14%, and when the scan rate increased to 1.0 mV s
−1, the capacitive contribution increased to 69.75%. With the increase, the diffusion rate of Li
+ at the electrode interface was accelerated, and the pseudocapacitance contribution increased.