Skip to Content

1,126 Results Found

  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
2,905 Views
22 Pages

Automatic History Matching Method and Application of Artificial Intelligence for Fractured-Porous Carbonate Reservoirs

  • Kaijun Tong,
  • Wentong Song,
  • Han Chen,
  • Sheng Guo and ,
  • Xueyuan Li and
  • Zhixue Sun
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

22 November 2024

Fractured-porous carbonate reservoirs, mainly composed of dolomites and crystalline rocks with various rock types and extremely poor initial porosity and permeability, are dominated by tectonic fractures and exhibit extreme heterogeneity. The fractur...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Quantitative Evaluation, Efficient Development, Seepage, and Simulation of Geo-Energy Resources)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
3,533 Views
43 Pages

11 June 2020

Waterflooding is a common recovery method used to maintain reservoir pressure and improve reservoir oil sweep efficiency. However, injecting cold water into a reservoir alters the state of in-situ formation stress and can result in the formation frac...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Mathematical Modeling of Fluid Flow and Heat Transfer in Petroleum Industries and Geothermal Applications 2020)
  • Article
  • Open Access
11 Citations
4,580 Views
27 Pages

Parallel Automatic History Matching Algorithm Using Reinforcement Learning

  • Omar S. Alolayan,
  • Abdullah O. Alomar and
  • John R. Williams

12 January 2023

Reformulating the history matching problem from a least-square mathematical optimization problem into a Markov Decision Process introduces a method in which reinforcement learning can be utilized to solve the problem. This method provides a mechanism...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue AI Technologies in Oil and Gas Geological Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
2,939 Views
28 Pages

Calibration under Uncertainty Using Bayesian Emulation and History Matching: Methods and Illustration on a Building Energy Model

  • Dario Domingo,
  • Mohammad Royapoor,
  • Hailiang Du,
  • Aaron Boranian and ,
  • Sara Walker and
  • Michael Goldstein
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

13 August 2024

Energy models require accurate calibration to deliver reliable predictions. This study offers statistical guidance for a systematic treatment of uncertainty before and during model calibration. Statistical emulation and history matching are introduce...

(This article belongs to the Topic Uncertainty Quantification in Design, Manufacturing and Maintenance of Complex Systems)
  • Article
  • Open Access
937 Views
34 Pages

Enhancing Reservoir Simulation History Matching Using SHAP Value for Parameter Range Selection

  • Grachik Eremyan,
  • Adel M. Magdeev,
  • Mohammed Al-Shargabi,
  • Ivan V. Matveev and ,
  • Ivan E. Smirnov,
  • Gleb Y. Shishaev and
  • Shadfar Davoodi
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

9 May 2026

Accurate reservoir history matching is indispensable for reliable subsurface forecasting and optimal field development; however, it remains a formidable challenge due to the high dimensionality of geological parameter spaces, strong nonlinear dynamic...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advanced Techniques in Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) and Smart Reservoir Management)
  • Article
  • Open Access
9 Citations
4,043 Views
23 Pages

Efficient Dimensionality Reduction Methods in Reservoir History Matching

  • Amine Tadjer,
  • Reider B. Bratvold and
  • Remus G. Hanea

27 May 2021

Production forecasting is the basis for decision making in the oil and gas industry, and can be quite challenging, especially in terms of complex geological modeling of the subsurface. To help solve this problem, assisted history matching built on en...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Data Science in Reservoir Modelling Workflows)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
2,347 Views
23 Pages

Four-Dimensional History Matching Using ES-MDA and Flow-Based Distance-to-Front Measurement

  • Eduardo Barrela,
  • Philippe Berthet,
  • Mario Trani,
  • Olivier Thual and
  • Corentin Lapeyre

9 December 2023

The use of 4D seismic data in history matching has been a topic of great interest in the hydrocarbon industry as it can provide important information regarding changes in subsurfaces caused by fluid substitution and other factors where well data is n...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Reservoir Simulation)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
3,098 Views
22 Pages

Joint History Matching of Multiple Types of Field Data in a 3D Field-Scale Case Study

  • William Chalub Cruz,
  • Xiaodong Luo and
  • Kurt Rachares Petvipusit

31 August 2022

This work presents an ensemble-based workflow to simultaneously assimilate multiple types of field data in a proper and consistent manner. The aim of using multiple field datasets is to improve the reliability of estimated reservoir models and avoid...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Reservoir Simulation)
  • Feature Paper
  • Review
  • Open Access
61 Citations
12,885 Views
25 Pages

Review of Field Development Optimization of Waterflooding, EOR, and Well Placement Focusing on History Matching and Optimization Algorithms

  • Jackson Udy,
  • Brigham Hansen,
  • Sage Maddux,
  • Donald Petersen and ,
  • Spencer Heilner,
  • Kevin Stevens,
  • David Lignell and
  • John D. Hedengren
  • + 3 authors+ 0 author

27 June 2017

This paper presents a review of history matching and oil field development optimization techniques with a focus on optimization algorithms. History matching algorithms are reviewed as a precursor to production optimization algorithms. Techniques for...

  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
586 Views
24 Pages

A Data-Efficient Surrogate Model via Simplified Feature Extraction and Pre-Training for Automatic History Matching

  • Yisen Qin,
  • Huayu Li,
  • Xiangling Meng,
  • Xiao He and ,
  • Jinding Zhang and
  • Haijun Zhang
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

19 May 2026

Automatic history matching traditionally depends on a large number of time-consuming numerical simulations, which makes the overall workflow computationally expensive. Deep learning-based surrogate models provide an efficient alternative, but their p...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Application of Artificial Intelligence in Oil and Gas Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
13 Citations
5,852 Views
20 Pages

29 April 2019

Most shale gas reservoirs have extremely low permeability. Predicting their fluid transport characteristics is extremely difficult due to complex flow mechanisms between hydraulic fractures and the adjacent rock matrix. Recently, studies adopting the...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Improved Reservoir Models and Production Forecasting Techniques for Multi-Stage Fractured Hydrocarbon Wells)
  • Article
  • Open Access
13 Citations
9,417 Views
16 Pages

Multi-Objective History Matching with a Proxy Model for the Characterization of Production Performances at the Shale Gas Reservoir

  • Jaejun Kim,
  • Joe M. Kang,
  • Changhyup Park,
  • Yongjun Park and ,
  • Jihye Park and
  • Seojin Lim
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

23 April 2017

This paper presents a fast, reliable multi-objective history-matching method based on proxy modeling to forecast the production performances of shale gas reservoirs for which all available post-hydraulic-fracturing production data, i.e., the daily ga...

  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
3,051 Views
15 Pages

19 August 2020

Reservoir history matching is a well-known inverse problem for production prediction where enormous uncertain reservoir parameters of a reservoir numerical model are optimized by minimizing the misfit between the simulated and history production data...

(This article belongs to the Section L: Energy Sources)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
1,250 Views
13 Pages

18 August 2025

The offshore reservoir development involves large injection and production rates and high injection pressures. High-permeability flow channels usually occur in offshore unconsolidated heavy-oil reservoirs during long-term water flux, substantially im...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue New Insights into Enhanced Oil Recovery Process Analysis and Application, 2nd Edition)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,845 Views
16 Pages

26 July 2023

The proper understanding of reservoir properties is an important step prior to forecasting fluid productions and deploying development strategies of a coalbed methane (CBM) reservoir. The assisted history matching (AHM) technique is a powerful techni...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Enhancing Unconventional Oil/Gas Recovery)
  • Article
  • Open Access
6 Citations
2,989 Views
27 Pages

1 May 2025

Understanding interwell connectivity during water-flooding reservoir development is crucial for analyzing the characteristics of remaining oil and optimizing technical measures. The key lies in establishing an inversion method to identify interwell c...

(This article belongs to the Section Energy Systems)
  • Article
  • Open Access
333 Views
15 Pages

History matching traditionally assumes a spatially uniform clay adsorption coefficient Kd, overlooking the fractal heterogeneity of clay mineral distributions in real reservoirs. This study generalizes the classical advection–dispersion framewo...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Efficient Development of Geo-Energy and Carbon Sequestration in Fractal Geo-Systems: New Challenges, 2nd Edition)
  • Article
  • Open Access
13 Citations
3,712 Views
19 Pages

Interpretation of Gas/Water Relative Permeability of Coal Using the Hybrid Bayesian-Assisted History Matching: New Insights

  • Jiyuan Zhang,
  • Bin Zhang,
  • Shiqian Xu,
  • Qihong Feng and ,
  • Xianmin Zhang and
  • Derek Elsworth
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

26 January 2021

The relative permeability of coal to gas and water exerts a profound influence on fluid transport in coal seams in both primary and enhanced coalbed methane (ECBM) recovery processes where multiphase flow occurs. Unsteady-state core-flooding tests in...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Multiscale and Multiphysics Processes in Unconventional Formations 2020)
  • Article
  • Open Access
18 Citations
5,452 Views
12 Pages

1 December 2017

Since they can provide a natural and flexible description of nonlinear dynamic behavior of complex system, Agent-based models (ABM) have been commonly used for immune system simulation. However, it is crucial for ABM to obtain an appropriate estimati...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Selected Papers from 2017 Health Informatics Conference (ChongqingBioinfo2017))
  • Article
  • Open Access
10 Citations
3,611 Views
17 Pages

28 March 2021

The variability of ground thermal conductivity, based on underground conditions, is often ignored during the design of ground-source heat pump systems. This study shows a field evidence of such site-scale variations through thermal response tests in...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Thermal Response Tests for Shallow Geothermal Systems)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
3,390 Views
20 Pages

6 November 2021

In this paper, the deterministic ensemble Kalman filter is implemented with a parallel technique of the message passing interface based on our in-house black oil simulator. The implementation is separated into two cases: (1) the ensemble size is grea...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue New Challenges in Advanced Process Control in Petroleum Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
4,224 Views
18 Pages

19 November 2019

History matching is a calibration of reservoir models according to their production history. Although ensemble-based methods (EBMs) have been researched as promising history matching methods, reservoir parameters updated using EBMs do not have ideal...

(This article belongs to the Section L: Energy Sources)
  • Article
  • Open Access
513 Views
24 Pages

18 April 2026

Characterizing multiscale fracture networks in shale gas reservoirs remains challenging, while the limited applicability of conventional continuum-based models and insufficient multi-objective coordination often lead to low efficiency in development...

  • Article
  • Open Access
6 Citations
4,344 Views
25 Pages

16 October 2024

This paper aims to evaluate the efficiency of various machine learning algorithms integrating with numerical simulations in optimizing oil production for a highly heterogeneous reservoir. An approach leveraging a machine learning workflow for reservo...

  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
1,922 Views
10 Pages

Clinical Outcomes of Total En Bloc Spondylectomy for Previously Irradiated Spinal Metastases: A Retrospective Propensity Score-Matched Comparative Study

  • Noriaki Yokogawa,
  • Satoshi Kato,
  • Takaki Shimizu,
  • Yuki Kurokawa and ,
  • Motoya Kobayashi,
  • Yohei Yamada,
  • Satoshi Nagatani,
  • Masafumi Kawai,
  • Takaaki Uto and
  • Satoru Demura
  • + 7 authors+ 2 authors

11 July 2023

This study aimed to investigate the clinical outcomes of total en bloc spondylectomy (TES) for spinal metastases previously treated with radiotherapy (RT). This study enrolled 142 patients who were divided into two groups: those with and those withou...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Current Management and Treatment of Primary and Metastatic Spinal Tumors)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
1,697 Views
16 Pages

26 September 2024

The production performances of fractured tight gas wells are closely related to several complex and unknown factors, including the formation properties, fracture parameters, gas–water two-phase flow, and other nonlinear flow mechanisms. The rat...

(This article belongs to the Section Hydraulics and Hydrodynamics)
  • Article
  • Open Access
11 Citations
3,664 Views
24 Pages

31 January 2025

This study presents a comprehensive investigation into the application of reservoir simulation and machine learning techniques to improve the understanding and prediction of reservoir behavior, focusing on the Sarir C-Main field. The research uses va...

(This article belongs to the Section H: Geo-Energy)
  • Review
  • Open Access
19 Citations
9,208 Views
43 Pages

20 August 2023

In recent years, machine learning (ML) has become a buzzword in the petroleum industry with numerous applications that guide engineers toward better decision making. The most powerful tool that most production development decisions rely on is reservo...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning Applications in the Oil and Gas Industry)
  • Article
  • Open Access
9 Citations
4,956 Views
17 Pages

29 May 2020

A novel workflow is presented for integrating fiber optic Distributed Temperature Sensor (DTS) data in numerical simulation model for the Cyclic Steam Stimulation (CSS) process, using an intelligent optimization routine that automatically learns and...

(This article belongs to the Section Optical Sensors)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
4,182 Views
16 Pages

10 February 2017

Reservoir simulations always involve a large number of parameters to characterize the properties of formation and fluid, many of which are subject to uncertainties owing to spatial heterogeneity and insufficient measurements. To provide solutions to...

  • Review
  • Open Access
39 Citations
9,042 Views
53 Pages

20 September 2023

In recent years, Machine Learning (ML) has become a buzzword in the petroleum industry, with numerous applications which guide engineers in better decision making. The most powerful tool that most production development decisions rely on is reservoir...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning Applications in the Oil and Gas Industry)
  • Article
  • Open Access
10 Citations
4,854 Views
16 Pages

20 January 2023

Production forecasting using numerical simulation has become a standard in the oil and gas industry. The model construction process requires an explicit definition of multiple uncertain parameters; thus, the outcome of the modelling is also uncertain...

(This article belongs to the Section H: Geo-Energy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
1,341 Views
13 Pages

Study on Nonlinear Parameter Inversion and Numerical Simulation in Condensate Reservoirs

  • Kuiqian Ma,
  • Chenxu Yang,
  • Zhennan Gao,
  • Xifeng Wang and
  • Xinrong Liu

27 August 2024

The B6 metamorphic buried hill condensate gas reservoir exhibits a highly compact matrix, leading to a rapid decline in bottom-hole pressure during initial production. The minimal difference between formation and saturation pressures results in sever...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Enhancing Unconventional Oil/Gas Recovery, 2nd Edition)
  • Article
  • Open Access
664 Views
14 Pages

While ovarian cancer screening is not recommended in the general population, attention has shifted to screening women with elevated hereditary risks. Although germline BRCA 1/2 pathogenic variants account for 40% of inherited ovarian cancer risk and...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Molecular Biology of Ovarian Cancer)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
3,535 Views
15 Pages

A New Method for Numerical Simulation of Coalbed Methane Pilot Horizontal Wells—Taking the Bowen Basin C Pilot Area in Australia as an Example

  • Xidong Wang,
  • Lijiang Duan,
  • Songhang Zhang,
  • Shuheng Tang and ,
  • Jianwei Lv and
  • Xudong Li
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

20 March 2024

Coalbed methane (CBM) pilot wells typically exhibit a short production period, necessitating evaluation of their estimated ultimate recovery (EUR) through numerical simulation. Utilizing limited geological data from the pilot areas to finish history...

  • Article
  • Open Access
185 Views
33 Pages

A Unified Reduced-Order Framework for Adaptive Reservoir Management in Hard-to-Recover Fields

  • Nikolay Markov,
  • Evgeny Yudin,
  • Svetlana Kraeva,
  • Nikita Trubnikov and ,
  • Sofia Permyakova and
  • Roman Bondorov
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

18 September 2026

Operational management of hard-to-recover (HTR) reservoirs requires modelling tools that can be repeatedly updated and recalculated as new field data become available. This study presents a reduced-order framework that combines a source-based boundar...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advanced Techniques in Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) and Smart Reservoir Management)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
2,490 Views
15 Pages

A New Approach for Production Prediction in Onshore and Offshore Tight Oil Reservoir

  • Kaixuan Qiu,
  • Kaifeng Fan,
  • Xiaolin Chen,
  • Gang Lei and ,
  • Shiming Wei,
  • Rahul Navik and
  • Jia Li
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

30 October 2023

Rapid technological advances have accelerated offshore and onshore tight oil extraction to meet growing energy demand. Reliable tools to carry out production prediction are essential for development of unconventional reservoirs. The existed tri-linea...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue High-Efficient Exploration and Development of Oil & Gas from Ocean)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,046 Views
39 Pages

13 August 2026

Water flooding in low-permeability, highly heterogeneous reservoirs often causes a rapid increase in water cut and inefficient pressure maintenance because injected water preferentially flows through high-permeability channels. In this study, a field...

(This article belongs to the Section Petroleum and Low-Carbon Energy Process Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
7 Citations
1,067 Views
27 Pages

Understanding Tight Naturally Fractured Carbonate Reservoir Architecture for Subsurface Gas Storage

  • Sadam Hussain,
  • Bruno Ramon Batista Fernandes,
  • Mojdeh Delshad and
  • Kamy Sepehrnoori

26 February 2026

This study develops a conceptual framework for characterizing reservoir architecture in multi-component, discrete systems using pressure transient analysis (PTA), aimed at calibrating inflow geometry prior to full-field dynamic simulation for subsurf...

(This article belongs to the Section Energy Science and Technology)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
5,175 Views
12 Pages

27 June 2017

A post-fracturing evaluation is essential to optimize a fracturing design for a multi-stage fractured well located in unconventional reservoirs. To accomplish this task, a production logging tool (PLT) can be utilized to provide the oil production ra...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Oil and Gas Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
3,117 Views
24 Pages

Evaluation of Reservoir Quality and Forecasted Production Variability along a Multi-Fractured Horizontal Well. Part 2: Selected Stage Forecasting

  • Christopher R. Clarkson,
  • Zhenzihao Zhang,
  • Farshad Tabasinejad,
  • Daniela Becerra and
  • Amin Ghanizadeh

22 September 2021

The current practice for multi-fractured horizontal well development in low-permeability reservoirs is to complete the full length of the well with evenly spaced fracture stages. Given methods to evaluate along-well variability in reservoir quality a...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Characterization of Unconventional Petroleum Reservoirs)
  • Article
  • Open Access
310 Views
24 Pages

26 May 2026

The complex fracture networks, multiphase flow behavior, and nonlinear flow mechanisms induced by hydraulic fracturing in horizontal wells of shale oil reservoirs pose significant challenges to production evaluation. In this study, a semi-empirical p...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue AI for Sustainable Development and Production Evaluation of Unconventional Oil & Gas Resources)
  • Article
  • Open Access
479 Views
18 Pages

Experimentally Constrained Dynamic Permeability Modeling of Commingled Production in Stacked Coalbed Methane Reservoirs: A GP-2 Case Study

  • Wenbo Sheng,
  • Junkai Yin,
  • Xiangqiang Liu,
  • Shuailong Feng and ,
  • Yijia Zhang,
  • Fangkai Quan and
  • Zhengyuan Qin
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

10 July 2026

Stacked coalbed methane (CBM) reservoirs can increase the drainage thickness of a single well, but commingled production is influenced by stress-sensitive permeability, gas desorption, water drainage, and interlayer heterogeneity. This study presents...

(This article belongs to the Section Petroleum and Low-Carbon Energy Process Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,066 Views
30 Pages

Displacement Experiment Characterization and Microscale Analysis of Anisotropic Relative Permeability Curves in Sandstone Reservoirs

  • Yifan He,
  • Yishan Guo,
  • Li Wu,
  • Liangliang Jiang and ,
  • Shuoliang Wang,
  • Bingpeng Bai and
  • Zhihong Kang
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

27 December 2025

As a critical parameter for describing oil–water two-phase flow behavior, relative permeability curves are widely applied in field development, dynamic forecasting, and reservoir numerical simulation. This study addresses the issue of relative...

(This article belongs to the Topic Exploitation and Underground Storage of Oil and Gas)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
2,648 Views
14 Pages

Tumor Recurrence and Graft Survival in Renal Transplant Recipients with a History of Pretransplant Malignancy: A Matched Pair Analysis

  • Felix Becker,
  • Anne-Sophie Mehdorn,
  • Vasilios Getsopulos,
  • Katharina Schütte-Nütgen and ,
  • Stefan Reuter,
  • Barbara Suwelack,
  • Andreas Pascher,
  • Jens G. Brockmann and
  • Ralf Bahde
  • + 4 authors+ 0 author

27 May 2021

Organ scarcity demands critical decision-making regarding eligible transplant candidates and graft allocation to ensure best benefit from renal transplantation (RTx). Among the controversial relative contraindications is a history of pretransplant ma...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Infections, Complications and Management of Kidney Transplantation)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
1,646 Views
15 Pages

Effect of Cross-Well Natural Fractures and Fracture Network on Production History Match and Well Location Optimization in an Ultra-Deep Gas Reservoir

  • Dong Chen,
  • Yuwei Jiao,
  • Fenglai Yang,
  • Chuxi Liu and ,
  • Min Yang,
  • Joseph Leines Artieda and
  • Wei Yu
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

25 May 2024

Understanding subsurface natural fracture systems is crucial to characterize well production dynamics and long-term productivity potential. In addition, the placement of future wells can benefit from in-depth fracture network connectivity investigati...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Improving Oil Recovery in Low-Permeability Hydrocarbon Resources)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
2,412 Views
19 Pages

28 February 2025

Advanced strategies for production forecasting, operational optimization, and decision-making enhancement have been employed through reservoir management and machine learning (ML) techniques. A hybrid model is established to predict future gas output...

(This article belongs to the Section H: Geo-Energy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
2,395 Views
19 Pages

A significant part of modern natural sciences aims to establish a model-based approach to describe the behavior of physical systems and forecast their dynamics in different scenarios. The successful application of model-based analysis of transport ph...

(This article belongs to the Section Computational Engineering)
  • Article
  • Open Access
23 Citations
4,392 Views
19 Pages

4 September 2019

Heat demand of a district heating network needs to be accurately predicted and managed to reduce consumption and emissions. Detailed thermal parameters are essential for predictions using physics-based energy models, but they are not always available...

(This article belongs to the Section G: Energy and Buildings)
  • Article
  • Open Access
38 Citations
6,830 Views
26 Pages

Gravity Drainage Mechanism in Naturally Fractured Carbonate Reservoirs; Review and Application

  • Faisal Awad Aljuboori,
  • Jang Hyun Lee,
  • Khaled A. Elraies and
  • Karl D. Stephen

27 September 2019

Gravity drainage is one of the essential recovery mechanisms in naturally fractured reservoirs. Several mathematical formulas have been proposed to simulate the drainage process using the dual-porosity model. Nevertheless, they were varied in their a...

of 23